On a Sunday in Palm Beach, a Learjet 60 bound from Austin for the Bahamas fell out of the sky onto a busy highway, and everyone aboard was lost. Now investigators have walked the scattered evidence back to a truth that matters: a piece of the tail, the surface that steers the nose up and down, came away before the machine reached the ground. Why it parted, whether the failure began the fall or the fall tore it free, remains an open question that the weather the crew described may help answer. For the families of those nine people, the search for a cause is also a search for the moment the ordi
NTSB Finds Key Learjet Tail Parts Miles From Palm Beach Crash Site, Suggesting Pre-Impact Separation
All nine people on board died, including seven passengers such as tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson, his wife, their two young children, family friends, and a nanny.
Pieces of the tail lay miles from the highway where the jet struck
Mark
Why does it matter that the parts were found miles away?
Mimi
Because it places the separation in the air, before the crash. Chapman said that's why investigators concluded the pieces came off before impact.
Mark
And the part itself, the elevator, what does it do?
Mimi
It controls the nose's up-and-down movement. Most of the left one turned up in three pieces, between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the highway.
Luke
Does that mean the missing elevator brought the plane down?
Mimi
Not yet. Chapman said they still don't know whether losing it caused the dive or whether forces on the aircraft caused it to separate.
Luke
So the distance proves timing, not cause.
Mimi
Right. It's a strong clue about where to look next, in his words, not a conclusion.
Mark
What does the cockpit audio add?
Mimi
The crew reported moderate turbulence, managing ice, and precipitation, asked to climb, then reported a fast descent and an overspeed condition.
Luke
Worth noting that weather's role is something the NTSB says it plans to investigate. The audio doesn't establish it as the cause.
Mark
And the wreckage itself?
Mimi
Hard to reach because of the crater, and severely damaged by the impact, Chapman said.
El Pulso
- Most of the Learjet's left elevator was found in three pieces between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the Palm Beach crash site, proving it tore loose in the air.
- Air traffic audio captured a crew fighting turbulence and ice, reporting precipitation and a need to climb, moments before the plane began to plunge.
- The aircraft plunged at up to 20,000 feet per minute, with the pilots shouting about overspeed and a final warning that they were going to hit the ground.
- Investigators are racing to establish whether the lost tail part triggered the dive or was torn away by it, a question that will shape the final cause finding.
- Wreckage sits in a deep crater on a highway, and the impact has so damaged the remains that recovery and analysis remain slow and difficult.
On a Sunday in Palm Beach, a Learjet 60 bound from Austin for the Bahamas fell out of the sky onto a busy highway, and everyone aboard was lost. Now investigators have walked the scattered evidence back to a truth that matters: a piece of the tail, the surface that steers the nose up and down, came away before the machine reached the ground. Why it parted, whether the failure began the fall or the fall tore it free, remains an open question that the weather the crew described may help answer. For the families of those nine people, the search for a cause is also a search for the moment the ordinary flight turned.
On Tuesday, investigators from the National Transportation Safety Board announced a discovery that changes the shape of the Palm Beach tragedy. Most of the left elevator, the tail surface that governs the up-and-down motion of a Learjet 60's nose, had been found in three pieces, scattered between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the highway where the aircraft struck on Sunday. Because the pieces lay so far from the impact, the board concluded the surface came away while the plane was still flying.
The jet had left Austin, Texas, bound for the Bahamas. Air traffic recordings preserve the crew's last minutes: reports of moderate turbulence, a struggle with ice, precipitation building around them, and a call to climb. Then came a rapid descent, an emergency declared, and the pilots' cries of an overspeed condition before their final words that they were going to crash into the ground. All nine people aboard died.
Among the dead were seven passengers, named in a joint statement as tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson, his wife Helen Sharp, their children Emma, four, and Charlie, two, family friends Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr, and nanny Anita Maria Cetina. Media reports identified the pilot as Jeffrey Gregory, 55, and the co-pilot as Nathalia Filgueiras, 20, who had earned her licence at 17.
The central puzzle now is sequence. Did the loss of the elevator start the nosedive, or did the violence of the dive rip the surface away? Chapman has said the part may not have been effective at the jet's speed, and the weather the crew described will be examined closely. The wreckage is hard to reach and badly damaged, so the answer will come slowly, but it will decide what the final finding says about why this flight ended as it did.
On Tuesday, National Transportation Safety Board investigators announced that they had found most of the left elevator from a Learjet 60 in three pieces, well away from the Palm Beach, Florida, highway where the aircraft crashed on Sunday. The elevator is the tail surface that controls the up-and-down movement of the plane's nose. The pieces lay between 1.3 and 3.8 miles (about 2 km to more than 6 km) from the crash site.
NTSB board member Tom Chapman said the distance told investigators the parts came off before impact. "Knowing that it was lost is a very important piece of evidence in terms of pointing us towards other things to investigate," he said. The finding does not yet say why the part came off. Chapman said officials were still working out whether losing the left elevator sent the plane into its nosedive, or whether forces acting on the aircraft caused the elevator to separate. He also said the surface may not have been "effective" at the speed the jet was travelling.
The Learjet 60 had left Austin, Texas, bound for the Bahamas. It nosedived into a multi-lane highway in Palm Beach and exploded on impact. All nine people aboard were killed.
Air traffic control recordings capture the crew's last minutes. Someone in the cockpit reports "moderate turbulence" and says the crew is "managing the ice." The same voice then says the plane is "picking up precipitation" and "we need to climb." Moments later, the voice reports a descent at 10,000 feet (3,048 m) per minute. An emergency is declared. The pilots can then be heard yelling that they are in an overspeed condition, descending at 20,000 feet per minute, before saying, "we are going to crash into the ground."
The NTSB plans to examine what role weather played. The investigation is also physically difficult: the jet left a huge crater in the road, and officials have struggled to reach the wreckage. Chapman said the force of the impact severely damaged what remained.
Seven passengers died. A joint statement named them as tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson; his wife, Helen Sharp; their two children, Emma, four, and Charlie, two; family friends Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr; and Anita Maria Cetina, a nanny. Media reports named the pilot as Jeffrey Gregory, 55. The co-pilot was reported to be Nathalia Filgueiras, 20, who earned her pilot's licence at 17.
The next step is to determine the order of events: whether the elevator failure started the dive, or whether the dive's forces tore the elevator away. The answer, along with the role of the weather the crew described, is likely to shape the NTSB's final finding on cause.
Citas Notables
Knowing that it was lost is a very important piece of evidence in terms of pointing us towards other things to investigate.— Tom Chapman, NTSB board member
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en BBC News ↗
General News