In a country that prides itself on the promise of care at life's most vulnerable threshold, the buildings where children are born have been quietly coming apart. England's health department now admits it cannot say what it would cost to make maternity and neonatal units safe, even as a national review finds that nearly half of them fall short of basic standards. The gap between what the public expects of its hospitals and what its walls can hold has become a question of money, priority and time, and the answer is still being written.
Ministers Cannot Say What Repairing Crumbling NHS Maternity Units Would Cost
Dozens of maternity units falling apart, and no price on the repair
Why does it matter that ministers can't give a figure?
Because without a cost there's no plan to hold anyone to. NHS England has already said 43% of units fall short of basic safety standards, so the problem is identified but not priced.
Worth being precise: the 43% is NHS England's assessment from its September 2025 review. And the admission came in answers to parliamentary questions, not a public announcement.
What does failure look like on the ground?
Leaks and mould at Musgrove Park, metal poles propping up an antenatal ward, and a ceiling light Jules Wilkinson had to hold for an hour at Stepping Hill.
Those are vivid, but they are individual cases. The systemic number is the 14,519 reported disruptions over three years, and that tells us frequency, not how many harmed patients.
Is care itself bad in these buildings?
Not necessarily. CQC inspectors rated care at Musgrove Park as good despite the mould and leaks.
Which cuts both ways: staff are coping, but the reviews say the buildings add pressure and cause delays.
How does the government respond?
It blames Conservative neglect, cites £271m spent since April 2025, and points to a record capital budget rising to £15bn by 2029-30.
And yet it cut £1bn from capital over four years, while the backlog is £17.3bn. Nobody has said how much of that backlog is maternity. That remains unknown.
The Pulse
- Nearly half of England's maternity and neonatal units fail basic safety standards, and ministers cannot put a price on fixing them.
- A light fitting fell from a ceiling during a birth at Stepping Hill, narrowly missing a midwife, while leaks and mould spread through wards elsewhere.
- Over three years, infrastructure failures interrupted or affected clinical services 14,519 times, with power cuts and faulty call systems delaying procedures.
- A £1bn cut to NHS capital spending lands against a £17.3bn maintenance backlog, pulling against every promise of repair.
- All eyes now turn to the 10-year capital plan and whether it will deliver a costed, funded route to safe buildings for mothers and babies.
In a country that prides itself on the promise of care at life's most vulnerable threshold, the buildings where children are born have been quietly coming apart. England's health department now admits it cannot say what it would cost to make maternity and neonatal units safe, even as a national review finds that nearly half of them fall short of basic standards. The gap between what the public expects of its hospitals and what its walls can hold has become a question of money, priority and time, and the answer is still being written.
At Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport, a light fitting came loose from the ceiling during a labour and dropped within reach of a midwife. Jules Wilkinson, whose daughter Cora was being born in that room, held the fitting up for an hour while staff waited. He described the 121-year-old hospital as being in a death spiral, its ceilings and walls failing around the people trying to care for others. Its chief executive believes the site needs £400m to be safe.
The problem is not confined to one building. When the Liberal Democrats pressed the government in parliament, the health minister admitted that ministers cannot say what it would cost to upgrade maternity and neonatal units across England. NHS England's own review, published last September, found that 43% of these units fail basic safety standards, and that the state of the buildings is tied directly to the safety of patients and staff. Over three years, physical failures interrupted clinical services 14,519 times.
At Musgrove Park in Taunton, leaking roofs, rooms that swing between too hot and too cold, and an antenatal ward held up by metal poles tell the same story. At St Helier in Sutton, services are being moved out so urgent repairs can happen at all. Staff describe units that are outdated and cramped, struggling to meet modern care.
Meanwhile, the money is moving in the wrong direction. A £1bn cut to NHS capital spending was made to help fund defence, even as the maintenance backlog stands at £17.3bn. The government blames years of Conservative neglect, points to £271m spent on maternity and neonatal safety since April 2025, and promises a rise in capital funding to a record £15bn by 2029-30. Whether the forthcoming 10-year plan will put a clear price and timetable on repairing these units remains the open question.
At Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport, Greater Manchester, Jules Wilkinson stood for an hour holding up a light fitting that had come loose from the ceiling while his wife gave birth to their daughter Cora. The fitting had narrowly missed a midwife as it came down. Describing the 121-year-old hospital last week, he said so much of it is falling apart that it is "almost in a death spiral." Its chief executive, Karen James, believes Stepping Hill needs £400m to be safe for patients and staff. It regularly suffers leaks.
It is one example in a wider problem that ministers now admit they cannot price. In answers to parliamentary questions from Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrats' health spokesperson, Karin Smyth, the NHS minister at the Department of Health and Social Care, conceded the government could not put a figure on upgrading maternity and neonatal units. NHS England has judged that these units either need significant repair or replacement soon, or face "a serious risk of imminent breakdown."
Morgan said NHS England had spelt out the seriousness in black and white, with dozens of units falling apart. She called it appalling that the government still has no idea what it would cost to make every unit fit for purpose, and accused ministers of gambling with the safety of mothers, babies and the staff who care for them.
The scale of the problem comes from NHS England's own review, published in September 2025. It found that poor infrastructure meant 43% of maternity and neonatal units in England did not meet basic safety standards. It also found a clear link between the condition of buildings, the experience of patients and staff, and safety. In the previous three years there were 14,519 formally reported cases where clinical services were interrupted or affected as a direct result of poor physical conditions. Power outages and faulty nurse call systems, it said, add pressure on stretched staff and can directly delay procedures such as planned caesarean sections.
The Care Quality Commission raised similar alarms in 2024, warning that too many maternity units are not fit for purpose, lacking space, facilities and, in a small number of cases, appropriate levels of potentially life-saving equipment.
Musgrove Park hospital in Taunton, Somerset, shows what that looks like. Baroness Valerie Amos's review of childbirth services, concluded in the summer, described a unit that is old and not designed for 21st-century care, with leaking roofs and rooms often too hot or too cold. The antenatal ward is propped up by metal poles. In September, hospital bosses acknowledged the unit is old, outdated and cramped after CQC inspectors found water had leaked into clinical areas and mould had formed on the walls and ceilings of the postnatal ward. Inspectors nonetheless rated the care staff provided as good.
At St Helier hospital in Sutton, south London, maternity services are being relocated because of urgent repairs. Mat Shaw, chief executive of the trust that runs it, said the planned significant work cannot be done while maintaining a good birth, gynaecology and fertility experience and a safe environment for babies and families in the building.
The money picture is moving the other way. In last month's budget, ministers cut £1bn from the NHS capital budget over four years to help fund defence spending, even as the most recent official figures put the cost of clearing the NHS maintenance backlog at £17.3bn. Ciarán Devane, chief executive of the NHS Alliance, said many maternity units sit in outdated, decaying buildings, compounding challenges of staffing, unit size and location, and increasingly complex care.
The Department of Health and Social Care blamed the Conservatives for failing to maintain the NHS estate, saying the government inherited services in buildings left to crumble. It said it has invested £271m since April 2025 in schemes tackling critical safety risks in the maternity and neonatal estate, recently announced more than £1.5bn for NHS buildings, and is raising the capital budget to a record £15bn in 2029-30. A 10-year capital plan is meant to put investment on a long-term footing. Whether it includes a costed answer for maternity units is the thing to watch.
Notable Quotes
Ministers are gambling with the safety of mothers, babies and NHS staff caring for them.— Helen Morgan, Liberal Democrat health spokesperson
This government inherited struggling maternity services in buildings left to crumble.— Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson