Milburn Report Urges Gradual Cut to Employer National Insurance for Under-25s to Spur Youth Jobs

"I feel like the government's foot is firmly on my neck."
Nottingham salon owner Collette Osborne on employment costs that stopped her hiring apprentices.
Mark

Why does this report matter beyond the NI numbers?

Mimi

Because it pairs a tax cut for employers with tougher rules on benefits. Milburn wants under-25s to lose the health element of Universal Credit and PIP, but to be offered a legal guarantee of a job, training or support.

Luke

Worth saying: those are recommendations. The government hasn't adopted any of it yet.

Mark

And the NI cut itself is cautious?

Mimi

Very. It's phased over five years, starts with retail and hospitality, and only happens when fiscal conditions allow. An immediate cut for 21 to 24-year-olds would cost £5.1bn, per the Resolution Foundation.

Luke

That £5.1bn is one think tank's estimate, not a Treasury figure. And "when conditions allow" is not a commitment to a date.

Mark

What does Collette Osborne add?

Mimi

A face for the problem. She went from eight apprentices a year to none, and her staff fell to 21.

Luke

She's one employer's account. It's vivid, but it doesn't show how typical she is, and Milburn himself says the NI rise didn't start the Neets problem.

Mark

So where do the parties split?

Mimi

Whately wants to stop taxing and halve employer NI. McFadden is extending subsidised jobs, which he says will reach 90,000 young people by March 2029.

Luke

That 90,000 is the government's own projection, so treat it as a target rather than a result.

  • A hairdresser turning away applications and losing her apprentice pipeline signals a hiring squeeze that is hitting small employers hardest.
  • Nearly one million young people sit outside work, education and training, and the cost of supporting them is pressing on public budgets.
  • Milburn's proposal to phase down employer NI over five years, starting in retail and hospitality, is caught between urgency and a £5.1bn price tag.
  • Benefit conditions for under-25s, tied to a legal job guarantee, have drawn sharp debate over fairness and obligation.
  • The government is already expanding a subsidised jobs guarantee, while the Conservatives push for deeper tax cuts, leaving the outcome open when the report lands.

In a Nottingham salon, a hairdresser who once trained eight apprentices a year now takes none, and her story sits at the heart of a review that will shape how Britain thinks about the young people left at its margins. Alan Milburn's independent inquiry into youth unemployment proposes lowering employer National Insurance for workers aged 21 to 24, but only as the public finances allow, weighing the cost of a sudden cut against the slower work of building a lasting path into employment. It asks a harder question too: whether support should come with obligation, pairing new help for young people with the expectation that they will take up the work or training on offer. The report's fate will show whether a nation can afford to wait for its young workers, or whether the waiting has already been expensive.

In Nottingham, hairdresser Collette Osborne says her three salons have stopped taking on apprentices altogether. Once she trained eight a year; now she takes none, and her workforce has fallen to 21. Training one apprentice, she says, costs around £60,000 before they can work with a customer. She describes feeling as if the government's foot were on her neck, squeezed by National Insurance, the minimum wage and other employment costs. Her frustration is part of the backdrop to a report due on Tuesday. Former Labour minister Alan Milburn has spent a year reviewing youth unemployment, and he is expected to recommend lowering employer National Insurance for workers aged 21 to 24 over five years, starting in retail and hospitality. The threshold would double from £5,000 to £10,000, but only when fiscal conditions allow, because an immediate cut would cost around £5.1bn.

The problem is large. Nearly a million young people aged 16 to 24 are not in employment, education or training, and Milburn says the state spends £22bn a year supporting young people who are economically inactive. He will also propose that under-25s lose access to certain benefits, including the health element of Universal Credit and personal independence payment, in return for a legal guarantee of a job, training or support. Milburn has also backed the chancellor's decision to slow the equalisation of minimum wages across age groups and supports wage subsidies, arguing that many young people arrive at work with mental health needs that small businesses cannot easily absorb.

The government is already moving. Pat McFadden says its subsidised jobs guarantee for 18 to 24-year-olds on Universal Credit will start after 12 months on benefits rather than 18, and will help more than 90,000 young people into work by March 2029. The Conservatives, through Helen Whately, reject the approach, arguing that businesses want to hire young people but cannot afford to, and that taxes should be cut rather than subsidies offered. As the report lands, the key question is whether ministers will accept a conditional, phased NI cut and adopt a jobs guarantee tied to benefit eligibility.

In Nottingham, hairdresser Collette Osborne says she now turns away a flood of applications from young people. Parents have been so anxious to see their children employed that some have offered to pay the wages themselves. Osborne owns three salons. She used to take on eight apprentices a year and now takes none, and her workforce has more than halved to 21 staff. Training an apprentice, she told the BBC, costs around £60,000 before they are allowed near a customer's head. "I feel like the government's foot is firmly on my neck," she said, describing herself as suffocated by employment costs, National Insurance and the minimum wage among them.

Her frustration sits at the centre of a report due out on Tuesday. Former Labour minister Alan Milburn has spent a year on an independent review of youth unemployment. It will recommend that employer National Insurance be lowered gradually over five years for workers aged 21 to 24, beginning in retail and hospitality, which together provide 37% of jobs for 16 to 24-year-olds. Specifically, Milburn wants the threshold at which businesses start paying NI on these workers doubled from £5,000 to £10,000, but only "when fiscal conditions allow".

The caution is deliberate. Research by the Resolution Foundation, a left-leaning think tank, puts the cost of scrapping employer NI for 21 to 24-year-olds immediately at £5.1bn. Milburn is expected to argue that, given the state of the public finances, an immediate across-the-board cut is not the best use of several billion pounds. He will also say that the NI rise introduced under Sir Keir Starmer's government did not start the problem of young people not in employment, education or training, known as Neets.

The scale of that problem is considerable. Office for National Statistics data show nearly one million Neets aged 16 to 24. Milburn says the government spends £22bn a year supporting young people who are economically inactive. His report also turns to the benefits bill. He will recommend that under-25s lose access to the health element of Universal Credit and to personal independence payment, the main disability benefit in England and Wales. In return he wants a legal guarantee of a job, training or employment support, with benefits at risk for those who refuse the help. He is expected to add that building skills is pointless if there are no jobs to go to.

On the Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme, Milburn backed Chancellor John Healey's decision to slow the equalisation of minimum wages across age groups. Labour's manifesto had pledged to remove "discriminatory age bands". In his Budget, Healey set the rate for 18 to 20-year-olds to rise from £10.85 to £11.27 an hour in April, while those 21 and over move from £12.71 to £13.21. Milburn said he understood the motive, since nobody wants young workers on poverty pay, but that it "imposed a lot of costs on [the] government" and the convergence issue needs careful scrutiny.

He also supports wage subsidies for employers who hire young people. Many arrive at work with mental health problems, ADHD or anxiety, he said, which a small business must absorb, and he argued the state has a responsibility to help.

The government is already moving on subsidies. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said the subsidised jobs guarantee for 18 to 24-year-olds claiming Universal Credit will be extended. Eligibility will begin after 12 months on benefits rather than 18, and the scheme will cover England, Scotland and Wales. It guarantees a six-month job, and McFadden said it will help more than 90,000 young people into work by March 2029.

Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately was unimpressed. It is "just absurd", she said, to tax businesses while subsidising things that look like jobs, and the government should "just stop doing the taxing". The Conservatives want to halve employer NI costs, she said, because businesses tell her they want to hire young people but can no longer afford to.

What to watch once the report lands is whether ministers accept the conditional, phased NI cut, and whether they adopt the jobs guarantee tied to benefit eligibility.

Just stop doing the taxing.
— Helen Whately, shadow work and pensions secretary
I feel suffocated by employment costs.
— Collette Osborne, Nottingham salon owner
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei BBC News ↗
Kontakt FAQ