At TPC Southwind in Memphis, the St Jude Championship offered two contrasting portraits of where a golfer can stand in relation to himself. Scottie Scheffler, the world's best, reasserted his dominance with a 17-under victory — his first win since January — moving through the field with the quiet certainty of someone who has learned to trust his own excellence. Rory McIlroy, meanwhile, confronted the cost of absence, finishing 25 strokes behind and admitting he felt lost within his own swing, a humbling reminder that even the gifted must tend their craft continuously or risk losing the thread.
McIlroy struggles at St Jude as Scheffler reclaims winning form
I felt lost with my golf swing as the week went on
Mark
How does a player like McIlroy—someone who won a major this year—end up 25 shots behind the leader in a single week?
Mimi
Rust is real. He hadn't played competitively in six weeks. You can't simulate that in practice. The body remembers, but the rhythm doesn't.
Mark
But 25 shots is enormous. That's not just rust.
Mimi
No, it's not. It's the combination of rust plus something deeper—he said he felt lost with his swing. That suggests he was searching, adjusting, never quite finding solid ground. Four rounds without a single score under par tells you everything.
Mark
Scheffler, meanwhile, just won his first tournament since January. Does that suggest he was struggling too?
Mimi
Different kind of struggle. Scheffler was playing well statistically but not converting. This week he converted. McIlroy wasn't even playing well—he was searching.
Mark
What's the pressure like now for McIlroy heading into next week?
Mimi
Immense. He's 13th in the standings with two playoff events left. He needs to find his game in seven days, or his season effectively ends.
Mark
Can he do it?
Mimi
He's done harder things. But he'll need to work harder than he's worked in years to get there.
The Pulse
- Scheffler ended a seven-month victory drought in emphatic fashion, pulling seven shots clear of his nearest competitor in the final round alone.
- McIlroy's return from a post-Open layoff was immediately punishing — no round under par, a tee-to-green ranking of 62nd out of 68, and an opening hole six on a par-four that set the tone for the week.
- Brief flashes of brilliance — four birdies across seven back-nine holes — teased the McIlroy the world knows, but bogeys at either end of the round swallowed the progress whole.
- McIlroy's own words carried the sharpest sting: 'I'm so far away from where I need to be to even feel like I have a chance,' a rare public admission of disorientation from a player of his stature.
- With the BMW Championship at Bellerive just seven days away and a place in the Tour Championship's $40 million finale on the line, McIlroy has almost no margin to rediscover his rhythm.
At TPC Southwind in Memphis, the St Jude Championship offered two contrasting portraits of where a golfer can stand in relation to himself. Scottie Scheffler, the world's best, reasserted his dominance with a 17-under victory — his first win since January — moving through the field with the quiet certainty of someone who has learned to trust his own excellence. Rory McIlroy, meanwhile, confronted the cost of absence, finishing 25 strokes behind and admitting he felt lost within his own swing, a humbling reminder that even the gifted must tend their craft continuously or risk losing the thread.
Scottie Scheffler arrived at TPC Southwind already leading and never gave anyone reason to believe the outcome might change. By Sunday, he was operating in a different register from the rest of the field — finishing at 17-under par, seven shots clear of playing partner Sam Burns, to claim his first victory since late January. It was a performance that distilled everything that makes Scheffler so difficult to dislodge: relentless composure, a final-round 66, and the ability to absorb a freak early bogey — when his bunker shot struck a sprinkler head and spun into the water — without losing his footing. Only Justin Rose, carding a Sunday 64, played better on the day, and even he finished at level par for the tournament. Scheffler had been statistically strong for months without converting; this week, it all paid off.
For Rory McIlroy, the same tournament told a far harder story. Having not played competitively since the Open Championship in July, the Northern Irishman never found his footing across four rounds, finishing at 8-over and 25 strokes behind the champion. His tee-to-green performance ranked 62nd of 68 players in the field, and not a single round dipped below par. There were moments — four birdies in seven holes on the back nine hinted at the player he can be — but bogeys framed each round, and his opening hole on Sunday, a six on a par-four, captured the week's tone precisely.
When he spoke afterward, McIlroy was measured but candid, describing a feeling of being lost within his own swing that deepened rather than lifted as the week went on. He ranked 13th in the FedEx Cup standings, a position that felt disconnected from what he had just experienced on the course. The calendar now offers little mercy: the BMW Championship at Bellerive follows in a week, and only the top 30 finishers there will advance to the Tour Championship at East Lake, where a $40 million prize fund awaits. McIlroy won the Masters earlier this season, and the possibility of an unprecedented fourth FedEx Cup title still exists — but the window to rediscover his rhythm is narrow, and the stakes are as high as they have been all year.
Scottie Scheffler arrived at TPC Southwind in Memphis already leading, and he never relinquished that advantage. By Sunday's final round, the world number one was operating in a different stratosphere entirely—finishing at 17-under par, seven shots clear of his playing partner Sam Burns, to claim his first victory since late January. It was the kind of dominant performance that reminded the golf world why Scheffler has spent the year at the top of the rankings: relentless, composed, and nearly impossible to catch once he has the lead.
For Rory McIlroy, the same tournament told a starkly different story. The Northern Irishman limped to a finish of 8-over par, good enough for 66th place and a margin of 25 strokes behind Scheffler. More troubling than the raw numbers was what they revealed about his form. McIlroy had not played competitively since the Open Championship in July, and that absence showed immediately. Across all four rounds at TPC Southwind, he failed to post a single score under par. His tee-to-green performance ranked 62nd out of 68 players in the field—a statistic that captures the depth of his struggle.
When McIlroy spoke after the tournament, his frustration was palpable but measured. He described feeling lost with his golf swing as the week progressed, a sensation that deepened rather than eased as he played more holes. He acknowledged arriving without much competitive rhythm, and the rust never quite shook loose. "I'm so far away from where I need to be to even feel like I have a chance," he said, his words carrying the weight of someone who knows exactly how far he has fallen from his best. He ranked 13th in the season-long FedEx Cup standings, a respectable position that nonetheless felt hollow given his performance this week.
There were brief moments of light. On the back nine, McIlroy strung together four birdies across seven holes—a flash of the player everyone knows he can be. But the round bookended itself with bogeys, and his opening hole was a six on a par-four, the kind of early damage that sets a difficult tone for the day ahead. These were not the mistakes of a player in command of his game.
Scheffler's path was far smoother. He signed for a 66 in the final round, a four-under effort that extended his lead rather than allowing anyone to close the gap. Burns, his playing partner and close friend, finished tied for third after a 73. Even an early bogey—when Scheffler's bunker shot hit a sprinkler head and caromed into the water—barely registered as a blip. Justin Rose was the only player to shoot better than Scheffler on Sunday, carding a 64 to finish at level par for the tournament. Scheffler's consistency throughout the week was what he took most pride in, and it showed in the final tally.
What made this victory particularly significant was the drought that preceded it. Scheffler had not won since the American Express Open on January 27, a span that included several close calls and tournaments where his play was statistically strong without converting to victories. "It's nice for it to pay off this week," he said, "this is a lot better feeling than having a statistically good week." The comment suggested a player who had been searching for this moment, and now had found it.
For McIlroy, the calendar is unforgiving. The top 50 in the FedEx Cup standings now advance to next week's BMW Championship at Bellerive Country Club in St Louis. The top 30 after that event will make the season-ending Tour Championship at East Lake in Atlanta, where a $40 million prize fund awaits. McIlroy has seven days to find his swing, to shake off the rust, and to rediscover the rhythm that carried him to a second Masters title earlier this season. The window for recovery is narrow, and the stakes—both for his season and for his pursuit of an unprecedented fourth FedEx Cup—are substantial.
Notable Quotes
I'm so far away from where I need to be to even feel like I have a chance. I've just got to keep working and hope it turns around a little bit.— Rory McIlroy
I think I've been really consistent. That's what I'm most proud of. It's nice for it to pay off this week.— Scottie Scheffler
Want the full story?
Read the original at BBC News ↗
General News