On an afternoon at Elland Road that few would remember fondly, Manchester United and Leeds United shared a tepid 1-1 draw in the Premier League, and the Manchester Evening News turned its eye to the individuals on the pitch rather than the scoreline. In the familiar ritual of the player rating, Aaron Wan-Bissaka emerged as the day's clearest figure, while the forward line and the manager's choices drew the sharpest doubt. It is a small moment in a long season, yet it asks an old question of any side: whether the people trusted to act on the day were the ones best placed to do so.
Man United Player Ratings vs Leeds: Wan-Bissaka and Shaw Shine in Tepid Elland Road Draw
Removing Pogba from the XI was illogical.
Why does this set of ratings matter beyond one draw?
Because the marks point to decisions, not just performances. The lowest scores went to Greenwood, Fernandes, James and the manager himself.
What was the complaint about Greenwood?
He started through the middle a week after his manager said he wasn't ready for that role. The paper said he didn't look ready.
Worth saying that's one paper's judgment. The ratings are opinion, and the piece doesn't give us the goals or match stats.
And Pogba?
The paper called him United's best attacker this calendar year and called leaving him out illogical. He came on late and had a half-chance he couldn't control.
So the criticism of the omission is the writer's view. We don't know the manager's reasoning from this piece.
Who came out well?
Wan-Bissaka with an 8, and Shaw, Maguire and Lindelof with 7s. Rashford was bright in the first half before fading.
The 1-1 score comes from the metadata, not the ratings text, so I'd treat who scored as unknown here.
Le Pouls
- Wan-Bissaka earned an 8 for a confident display against Jack Harrison, quietly setting up a good chance for Fernandes.
- Greenwood, deployed through the middle a week after being called not ready for that role, looked out of his depth and was rated 5.
- Fernandes and James both sank to 5s as United's attacking shape stalled, with James's recall called unvindicated.
- Pogba's late appearance from the bench and his omission from the starting eleven have turned the selection debate into a growing pressure on Solskjaer, who was himself rated 5.
On an afternoon at Elland Road that few would remember fondly, Manchester United and Leeds United shared a tepid 1-1 draw in the Premier League, and the Manchester Evening News turned its eye to the individuals on the pitch rather than the scoreline. In the familiar ritual of the player rating, Aaron Wan-Bissaka emerged as the day's clearest figure, while the forward line and the manager's choices drew the sharpest doubt. It is a small moment in a long season, yet it asks an old question of any side: whether the people trusted to act on the day were the ones best placed to do so.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka left Elland Road with the highest mark in Manchester United's side, an 8 from the Manchester Evening News, in a Premier League draw with Leeds that the paper described as tepid. The ratings focused less on the 1-1 scoreline than on who had done their job and who had not. Wan-Bissaka was praised for a confident afternoon against Jack Harrison and for setting up a good chance for Bruno Fernandes. Victor Lindelof, Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw each earned a 7, with Lindelof's one errant first-half pass the only blemish and Shaw's support for Marcus Rashford tempered by a possible handball he may have escaped punishment for.
The midfield and goalkeeper earned steadier grades. Dean Henderson handled routine efforts in the sun and earned a 6, far calmer than his erratic week against Burnley. Scott McTominay was disciplined but not daring, and Fred pressed eagerly before finding Mason Greenwood with a perceptive pass.
The forwards drew the harshest verdicts. Greenwood, starting through the middle despite his manager's earlier doubts, looked unready and was rated 5. Fernandes was subdued again, and his inclusion was seen as undermining the omission of Paul Pogba, whom the paper called United's best attacker this calendar year. Daniel James did not justify his recall. Rashford was the brightest attacker with a 6, but could not carry his side in the second half. Pogba, who came off the bench, was rated 6, while Edinson Cavani was given a 5 for arriving too late.
Solskjaer himself received a 5, and the paper called leaving Pogba out of the starting eleven illogical. Those selection choices are likely to keep the manager under scrutiny.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka finished the afternoon at Elland Road with the highest mark in Manchester United's team, an 8 out of 10 from the Manchester Evening News, in a Premier League draw with Leeds United that the paper called tepid. The summary data lists the score as 1-1, though the ratings piece itself concentrates on individual performances rather than the goals.
Wan-Bissaka earned his mark with a confident display against Jack Harrison, and he also set up a good chance for Bruno Fernandes. The paper described the performance as impressive and all-round. Next in the ratings were the back line's other members. Victor Lindelof and Harry Maguire each got a 7, as did Luke Shaw.
Lindelof had one edgy moment, an errant pass in the first half, but otherwise held firm and dealt well with Patrick Bamford. Maguire passed well when he pushed forward into attacks and marshalled the defence, but he was booked and lost his temper with his teammate Fred. Shaw drove down the left and almost always offered support to Marcus Rashford, though the paper suggested he may have been fortunate not to be penalised for handball inside his own area.
In goal, Dean Henderson had routine efforts to handle in the sun and earned a 6. The paper noted it was a much calmer showing than his erratic afternoon against Burnley the week before. In midfield, Scott McTominay, also a 6, was called disciplined but not daring. He had scored twice against Leeds in December, but was less adventurous this time. Fred, another 6, pressed eagerly in what the paper called Solskjaer's trusted triangle, but had little influence until he played Mason Greenwood in with a perceptive pass.
The forward line drew the harshest marks. Greenwood, who started through the middle a week after his manager said he was not ready for the centre-forward role, got a 5 and the paper said he did not look ready. Fernandes also got a 5. He was described as subdued again and shanked a shot, and the paper said his inclusion undermined the removal of Paul Pogba, whom it called United's best attacker this calendar year. Daniel James, also a 5, did not vindicate his recall. Leeds players treated him roughly, but his decision-making on the ball was poor when United looked threatening.
Rashford was the brightest of the attackers, with a 6. He tormented Luke Ayling and tested Illan Meslier with a dipping free-kick in a bright first half, but could not carry the passengers in the second. Among the substitutes, Pogba had a half-chance he failed to control and got a 6. Edinson Cavani, a 5, came on too late. Donny van de Beek made a cameo appearance and went unrated.
The manager, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, also received a 5. The paper said James's recall was not vindicated and that Pogba's arrival was peculiarly late. It called leaving Pogba out of the starting XI illogical. Selection choices, particularly Pogba's omission and Greenwood's central role, are likely to draw further scrutiny of the manager.
Citations marquantes
The paper judged Pogba's arrival peculiarly late and his removal from the starting XI illogical.— Manchester Evening News player ratings