When a republic's streets erupt, the first question is always whether anger has found a voice or lost its way. In France, a movement that began in September over school funding grew, through the months, into a broader reckoning with the rising cost of living and failing public services, until a weekend of burning, looting and clashes left thousands arrested and hundreds hurt. President Emmanuel Macron, after an emergency meeting with his intelligence chiefs and senior ministers, has answered with a ban on demonstrations by groups he says lack legitimate standing, placing the blame on ultra-lef
Macron Vows to Ban 'Illegitimate' Protests as France Braces for Further Unrest
Around 2,700 arrests in a single weekend, and the number of jailings is still rising
Macron says protests by groups without legitimate authority will be banned. What does that actually mean?
In practice, it seems to hinge on permission. Unions can still apply, and prefects will review requests under the law, but they'll propose alternative routes. Protests in Paris, Lyon, Lille and Grenoble were already banned for Thursday.
Worth noting that the phrase 'legitimate authority' isn't defined in the reporting. We don't know the exact legal test being applied.
And yet thousands showed up in Paris on Thursday.
Yes, after a local court was said to have overturned that day's ban. So the ban is already being contested legally.
'Was said to have' matters there. The report attributes it and doesn't confirm the court's ruling in detail, so I'd hold that loosely.
What set this off?
It began in September at a school near Paris over education funding, then spread to other suburbs and cities, and broadened to cost of living and public services. October 17 was the escalation: clashes, looting, fires.
Macron's claim that ultra-left groups aimed to bring down the Republic is the government's framing. The reporting doesn't offer independent evidence of who was responsible for the violence, or how much of it.
The numbers are large, though.
About 2,700 arrests over the weekend, hundreds injured, and 217 jailed in fast-track trials, a figure Darmanin says is still rising.
Those are official figures, and the injury count is only given as 'hundreds.' What happens Saturday, with UNEF and the Yellow Vests both planning events, is still unknown.
Der Puls
- A movement that began over school funding in September has swelled into the worst unrest France has seen in years, with masked rioters clashing with police and setting fire to cars and buildings.
- Around 2,700 arrests and 217 fast-track jailings have followed, while hundreds of protesters, police officers and firefighters lie injured.
- Macron has moved to ban unauthorized demonstrations, blaming ultra-left groups and warning that the Republic itself is under threat.
- Curfews, banned marches in Paris, Lyon, Lille and Grenoble, and a court-reversed ban in Paris have left the streets contested, with a massive weekend security operation being readied.
- Monday's talks with students, unions and employers offer a path back to dialogue, but UNEF rallies and a Yellow Vest march through Paris are already set to test the ban this weekend.
When a republic's streets erupt, the first question is always whether anger has found a voice or lost its way. In France, a movement that began in September over school funding grew, through the months, into a broader reckoning with the rising cost of living and failing public services, until a weekend of burning, looting and clashes left thousands arrested and hundreds hurt. President Emmanuel Macron, after an emergency meeting with his intelligence chiefs and senior ministers, has answered with a ban on demonstrations by groups he says lack legitimate standing, placing the blame on ultra-left actors and framing the violence as an attack on the Republic itself. Yet the same announcement holds open a door: talks with students, unions and employers are set for Monday, and the coming days will show whether order and dialogue can be made to coexist.
On Thursday, after a special security meeting at the Elysee Palace with intelligence chiefs and senior ministers, President Emmanuel Macron announced that demonstrations organized by groups without legitimate authority would be banned in the coming days. He placed the blame for the weekend's violence on ultra-left groups, calling the events political and seditious acts aimed at bringing down the Republic, and asked that no demonstrations be held while the government works to restore calm.
The unrest had grown steadily since September, when a protest at a school near Paris over underfunded education spread through the suburbs and across French cities, gathering in the soaring cost of living and deteriorating public services. On October 17 it became the worst violence in years. Across the country around 2,700 people were arrested, hundreds of protesters, police and firefighters were hurt, and Justice Minister Gerald Darmanin reported 217 people jailed in fast-track trials, a number still rising.
The ban has already reshaped the streets. Several cities imposed curfews, and protests planned in Paris, Lyon, Lille and Grenoble were prohibited, though thousands still gathered in Paris after a local court reportedly overturned that day's ban. Unions may still apply to demonstrate, with prefects offering alternative routes.
The movement shows no sign of retreat. UNEF has called for rallies on Saturday, and the Yellow Vest movement has filed plans for a march through central Paris. Monday brings talks among authorities, students, unions and employers, and Macron has insisted that protesters' legitimate demands must still be heard. With next year's presidential election approaching, this weekend will show whether the ban holds and whether dialogue can follow.
On Thursday, after a special security meeting at the Elysee Palace with intelligence chiefs and senior ministers, President Emmanuel Macron announced that demonstrations organized by groups without legitimate authority would be banned in the coming days. The announcement followed the worst urban unrest France has seen in years.
Macron placed the blame for last Saturday on ultra-left groups. He called the events political and seditious acts whose aim, in his words, was to bring down the Republic. His general recommendation was that no demonstrations be held in the coming days, because the government wants calm to return. The ban, he said, is meant to protect city centers, businesses and public buildings.
He left some room for organized labor. Where trade unions submit requests to demonstrate, prefects will examine them under the law, but alternative routes will be proposed.
The restrictions were already taking hold. After the weekend's violence, several cities imposed curfews on certain parts of town. Protests planned for Thursday in Paris, Lyon, Lille and Grenoble were banned. Even so, thousands gathered in Paris after a local court was said to have overturned that day's ban on the demonstration there. Authorities say a massive security operation is planned for the coming weekend to prevent a repeat of the last one.
The movement began in September at a school near Paris, over a lack of funding for the education system. It spread to other Paris suburbs and then to other French cities, widening along the way to take in the soaring cost of living and deteriorating public services. On October 17 it turned into the worst unrest in years: masked rioters clashed with police, looted shops and set cars and buildings on fire. French media reported that two people have been arrested over an arson attack on the 19th-century city hall in Limoges.
The toll was heavy. Across the country there were around 2,700 arrests last weekend, and hundreds of protesters, police officers and firefighters were injured. Justice Minister Gerald Darmanin said courts had jailed 217 people in fast-track trials linked to the rioting, and that this figure was continuing to rise a lot.
The groups behind the protests are not stepping back. Student and university groups and unions say they will keep mobilizing. UNEF, France's main student union, has called for rallies on Saturday. The Yellow Vest movement, whose protests over fuel prices shook the country in 2018 and 2019, has filed plans for a march through central Paris.
Macron also pointed to dialogue. Talks among authorities, student groups, unions and employers are set for Monday, and he stressed that conversation about protesters' legitimate demands should continue. The unrest comes just months before next year's presidential election, when voters will choose his successor. This weekend will show how the ban is enforced against the rallies already called, and whether the Monday talks can follow.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
Last Saturday we had political and seditious acts by ultra-left groups whose aim is to bring down the Republic.— President Emmanuel Macron
The general recommendation is not to hold demonstrations in the coming days. We want calm to return.— President Emmanuel Macron