In the final stretch before Brazil's presidential runoff, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva reversed a decades-held position, announcing support for lowering the age of criminal responsibility from 18 to 16 — a stance his Workers' Party has long opposed. Trailing far-right Senator Flávio Bolsonaro by 2.2 million first-round votes and facing an electorate where 80 percent favor the measure, Lula's shift reflects the ancient tension between political survival and principled conviction. The move raises enduring questions about whether democratic leaders shape public values or merely mirror them — and at
Lula reverses on criminal age in last-ditch electoral push
Approximately 204,000 people in Brazil's 816,000-person prison population are incarcerated for drug trafficking, a crime classified as heinous under Brazilian law.
turned himself inside out on public security
Mark
So Lula just flipped on something his party has opposed for decades. What changed?
Mimi
Public opinion shifted dramatically. Eighty percent of Brazilians now support lowering the age, and Lula is trailing by over two million votes. He needed to move.
Luke
But we should be careful here—is that 80 percent figure from one poll or multiple? And does it specify whether people understand what "heinous crimes" includes? Drug trafficking is in that category.
Mimi
That's fair. The source cites "repeated opinion polls, the latest of them this week" showing 80 percent support, so it seems consistent across surveys. But you're right that we don't know how informed that support is.
Mark
What do the people who study this actually say about lowering the age?
Mimi
Human rights groups and security experts argue it doesn't reduce violence. They say it increases recruitment into organized crime inside prisons and deepens cycles of exclusion rather than rehabilitation.
Luke
That's their position, yes. But has anyone measured the actual effect in places that have done this? The source doesn't cite any data on outcomes.
Mimi
No, it doesn't. It's a warning based on logic and experience, not a study of Brazil specifically.
Mark
And Bolsonaro wants it even lower—to 14?
Mimi
Yes. Both Jair and Flávio have pushed for 14. Lula is proposing 16 as a compromise, though it's still a reversal for him.
Luke
One more thing: about 204,000 people in Brazil's prisons are there for drug trafficking. That's a heinous crime under the law. So this policy, if passed, could affect a lot of young people.
Mimi
Exactly. That's the scale of what's being proposed.
El Pulso
- Lula, trailing by 2.2 million votes with days until the runoff, abandoned a cornerstone of his party's platform in a live television interview — a reversal so sharp that a prominent columnist wrote he had 'turned himself inside out.'
- The announcement landed the same day Brazil's Catholic bishops issued a formal rebuke, warning that funneling teenagers into an already overcrowded prison system will breed more violence, not less.
- The stakes are sharpened by the breadth of Brazil's 'heinous crimes' category — drug trafficking alone accounts for roughly 204,000 of the country's 816,000 prisoners, meaning the policy could sweep vast numbers of young people into that system.
- Human rights groups and security experts warn the move mirrors a familiar political pattern: a measure with high approval ratings that research consistently links to deeper cycles of crime and prison recruitment rather than public safety.
- Lula is pairing the announcement with a flurry of late-campaign promises — a shorter working week, debt relief for small entrepreneurs, free weekend transit — in a broad bid to close the gap before voters return to the polls.
In the final stretch before Brazil's presidential runoff, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva reversed a decades-held position, announcing support for lowering the age of criminal responsibility from 18 to 16 — a stance his Workers' Party has long opposed. Trailing far-right Senator Flávio Bolsonaro by 2.2 million first-round votes and facing an electorate where 80 percent favor the measure, Lula's shift reflects the ancient tension between political survival and principled conviction. The move raises enduring questions about whether democratic leaders shape public values or merely mirror them — and at what cost to the vulnerable.
With just over a week until Brazil's presidential runoff, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva announced during a TV Globo interview that he now supports lowering the age of criminal responsibility for heinous crimes from 18 to 16 — an abrupt departure from a position his Workers' Party has held for decades. Lula is trailing far-right Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, who won the first round by 2.2 million votes and remains slightly ahead in polling heading into the final contest.
The electoral logic is difficult to ignore. Recent polls show 80 percent of Brazilians favor lowering the age threshold, and Lula's campaign has been working to close a significant gap with undecided voters. When pressed on whether he meant reducing the age to 16, Lula answered plainly: yes, for any and every heinous crime. The Bolsonaros — both Jair and his son Flávio — have long pushed for an even lower threshold of 14, a position Lula had consistently opposed until now.
The reversal drew immediate criticism. On the same day, Brazil's Episcopal Conference issued a statement warning that placing young people prematurely into the country's overcrowded prisons deepens cycles of violence and forecloses rehabilitation. Human rights organizations echoed the concern, arguing the policy increases the likelihood that young people will be recruited into organized crime networks operating inside prisons. The warning carries particular weight given that drug trafficking — classified as heinous under Brazilian law — accounts for roughly 204,000 of Brazil's 816,000 incarcerated people.
Columnist Josias de Souza wrote that Lula had decided to 'change himself,' defending on public security what he had always rejected. The announcement is part of a broader late-campaign push that also includes congressional approval for a shorter working week, debt relief for microentrepreneurs, and free public transport on weekends. Whether abandoning a foundational party principle will prove enough to close the gap before the runoff remains the open question.
With just over a week until Brazil's presidential runoff, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva announced on Thursday night that he now supports lowering the age of criminal responsibility for "heinous" crimes from 18 to 16. The reversal came during an interview with TV Globo and represents an abrupt departure from a position his party has held for decades. Lula, the incumbent president, is trailing his far-right opponent, Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, who won the first round by 2.2 million votes and remains slightly ahead in polling as the two head toward a final contest.
The timing of the announcement is difficult to separate from electoral calculation. Recent opinion polls showed that 80 percent of Brazilians support lowering the age threshold, and Lula's campaign has been working to close a significant gap with undecided and independent voters. When asked directly whether he meant lowering the age to 16, Lula answered yes. His words were direct: as a Brazilian citizen, he now favors reducing the age for any and every heinous crime.
The category of "heinous" crimes under Brazilian law is broad. It encompasses murder and rape, but also extends to drug trafficking, the falsification of medicines, and other offenses. Drug trafficking alone accounts for roughly a quarter of Brazil's 816,000 incarcerated people—meaning approximately 204,000 individuals are in prison for that single crime. The Bolsonaros, both Jair and his son Flávio, have long pushed for lowering the age even further, to 14, but Lula and his Workers' Party have consistently opposed the change until now.
The reversal did not go unnoticed or unchallenged. On the same day as Lula's announcement, the Episcopal Conference of Brazil, representing the country's Catholic bishops, issued a statement criticizing the proposal. They argued it fails to address the root causes of violence and warned that placing young people prematurely into Brazil's already overcrowded prison system would deepen cycles of violence and exclusion rather than support rehabilitation. Human rights organizations and security experts have made similar arguments for years, contending that lowering the age of responsibility does little to reduce violence while increasing the likelihood that young people will be recruited into organized crime networks operating within prisons.
Columnist Josias de Souza captured the scale of the shift in his UOL column, writing that Lula had decided to "change himself"—that on public security, the president had "turned himself inside out," now defending what he had always rejected. The move is part of a broader late-campaign push by Lula to appeal to voters concerned about crime and security. In recent days, he has secured congressional approval for a shorter working week, promised debt relief for microentrepreneurs, and announced free public transport on weekends. Bolsonaro himself reversed course on the working week proposal at the last minute, choosing to support it once it appeared certain to pass.
What remains unclear is whether Lula's reversal will move enough voters to close the gap before the runoff. The announcement represents a calculation that the electoral benefit of aligning with public opinion on criminal responsibility outweighs the cost of abandoning a longstanding party principle. Whether that gamble pays off will be determined in the coming days.
Citas Notables
My view, as a Brazilian citizen, is that for any and every heinous crime, I am in favour of lowering the age.— Lula, during TV Globo interview
Placing young people prematurely in the prison system tends to deepen cycles of violence and exclusion, undermining their rehabilitation.— Episcopal Conference of Brazil
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en The Guardian ↗
Politics & Governance