Some stories turn on a single object: a ring that a grieving man still wears. In the world of Marshals, the Yellowstone spinoff, Luke Grimes carried a worry that the character could not survive without the wife whose loss defines him, and that worry has become the quiet ground the show now walks on. As Kayce Dutton grieves Monica and feels a new friendship take shape, the question of when the ring will come off stands in for the larger human question of when mourning lets go and something new is allowed to begin.
Luke Grimes Admits He Feared Playing Kayce Dutton Without Monica in 'Marshals'
Kayce Dutton still wears his wedding ring.
Why does it matter that Grimes was worried about doing this show without Kelsey Asbille?
Because he says Monica was the story for Kayce. Everything else in "Yellowstone" was a fight over land, and Kayce was the one who loved his wife. Losing her changes the whole footing of the character.
Worth noting that's Grimes describing his own worry, in an interview. It tells us how he approached the role, not how the show was developed behind the scenes.
So what changed his mind?
He said he came to see that her absence would open new storylines, as long as the show honors it and doesn't skip over it.
And the Andrea Cruz relationship? Is it a romance?
Not confirmed. Grimes says the fans are meant to feel that tension, but he doesn't know where it's going. He calls them kindred souls and stresses that the friendship comes first.
Right, and that's an actor's read on it, not a writers' room announcement. "I don't know where it's going" is the honest state of things.
What about the ring?
He's still wearing it. He and showrunner Spencer Hudnut have talked about when it comes off, and whether it becomes a scene or just quietly disappears.
And that's undecided by his own account. Nothing here tells us when or if that happens.
The Pulse
- Grimes admitted he could not picture Kayce without Monica, and that fear nearly stopped the show before it started.
- Monica's absence cuts through Kayce and Tate's daily life, and the grief is still raw on screen.
- Kayce's growing bond with marshal Andrea Cruz has fans speculating about romance, and Grimes says they are right to feel it.
- The writers are charting a slow-burn friendship with Ash Santos's Andrea, building it carefully rather than rushing toward a romance.
- The wedding ring remains on Kayce's hand, and Grimes and showrunner Spencer Hudnut are still deciding whether it comes off with ceremony or simply disappears.
Some stories turn on a single object: a ring that a grieving man still wears. In the world of Marshals, the Yellowstone spinoff, Luke Grimes carried a worry that the character could not survive without the wife whose loss defines him, and that worry has become the quiet ground the show now walks on. As Kayce Dutton grieves Monica and feels a new friendship take shape, the question of when the ring will come off stands in for the larger human question of when mourning lets go and something new is allowed to begin.
Kayce Dutton still wears his wedding ring. Luke Grimes told Screen Rant that this small detail carries the weight of Marshals, the Yellowstone spinoff now in its second season, and of the fear he felt before agreeing to make it at all. The show's pull, as Grimes saw it, was always Monica. Kelsey Asbille played her throughout Yellowstone, and Grimes found he could not imagine Kayce without her. He saw the rest of that world as a fight over land, while Kayce was the man who loved his wife.
His thinking changed once he saw that Monica's death could open new paths for Kayce. The one condition he holds to is that the show honors what happened and never pretends it did not. Kayce, now a U.S. Marshal in Montana with a cowboy's instincts and a former SEAL's training, is balancing justice and family while he mourns with his son, Tate.
This season, Kayce is growing close to fellow marshal Andrea Cruz, played by Ash Santos. Grimes does not dismiss the romance fans are sensing. He calls them right to feel it, and says he loves a will-they, won't-they story even without knowing where this one ends. What moves him most is the friendship at its root, which he calls rare to see before anything else.
The ring is still unresolved. Grimes and showrunner Spencer Hudnut have talked about when Kayce might take it off, but they have not decided whether it should be a marked moment or simply a day it is gone. For now, it remains on his hand, and viewers will be watching for it.
Kayce Dutton still wears his wedding ring. That small detail sits at the center of what Luke Grimes told Screen Rant about "Marshals," the "Yellowstone" spinoff now in its second season, and about the fear he carried before he ever agreed to make it.
Grimes said the thing that worried him most was doing the show without Kelsey Asbille, who played Monica Dutton, Kayce's wife, throughout "Yellowstone." He called the concern legitimate. In his telling, he simply could not wrap his head around Kayce without Monica. To him, she was the story. The rest of "Yellowstone," he said, was about people fighting over land, while his character was the one who loved his wife.
That left him unsure what a Kayce story could even look like. "Marshals" picks up after the events of "Yellowstone," with Kayce and his son, Tate, grieving Monica's death. Grimes said his thinking shifted once he understood that her absence would open up new storylines. The condition, as he described it, is that the show honors what happened and does not skip over it or pretend it didn't occur.
The series follows Kayce as he joins an elite unit of U.S. Marshals in Montana. He draws on his background as a cowboy and former Navy SEAL to fight crime while balancing his responsibilities to his family. It airs Sundays on CBS and streams on Paramount+.
This season, the show is developing Kayce's bond with a fellow marshal, Andrea Cruz, played by Ash Santos. Their closeness has led some fans to wonder whether romance is coming, even as Kayce continues to mourn. Grimes did not push back on that reaction. He told Screen Rant the fans are not wrong and are meant to feel that way.
He said he has always loved a will-they, won't-they storyline, though he doesn't know where this one is headed. He described the two characters as kindred souls and called the way the show is building their connection beautiful. He pointed to the friendship at its base, saying it is rare these days to see two people form a really amazing friendship first.
One question is still open: when Kayce might take off the ring. Grimes said that for now he's still wearing it, and that he and executive producer and showrunner Spencer Hudnut have discussed when it should come off. They haven't settled whether to make a moment of it or let the ring simply be gone one day. As Grimes put it, they are still figuring that out.
For viewers, the ring is the thing to watch as the season continues.
Notable Quotes
The thing I was most worried about doing 'Marshals' was doing it without Kelsey.— Luke Grimes, to Screen Rant
They're not wrong. They're meant to feel that way.— Luke Grimes, on fans' reaction to Kayce and Andrea, to Screen Rant