On a Thursday in Leeds, in the second week of a trial that has laid bare how a jealous rivalry over a shared boyfriend hardened into something deadly, an 18-year-old woman finally accepted the full weight of what she had done. Kayla Smith, who had earlier admitted only manslaughter, now stands guilty of murdering Chloe Watson Dransfield, a 16-year-old girl who bled to death after a fight that was arranged in advance. The sentence is already fixed in kind if not in length, and what remains open is how the court will measure a life lost so young, and how the claims of two young men still denying
Leeds woman, 18, pleads guilty to murdering 16-year-old love rival in planned knife attack
A 16-year-old girl, Chloe Watson Dransfield, bled to death after being stabbed in a planned fight; her family and community are left bereaved.
"Just themselves, nothing else"
Mark
Smith already admitted manslaughter. Why does the change to murder matter?
Mimi
Manslaughter would have meant she killed Chloe without the intent required for murder. Pleading guilty to murder removes that argument, and it triggers a mandatory life sentence.
Luke
Worth noting the judge hasn't set the minimum term yet. That comes after the trial ends, so any number you hear before then is speculation.
Mark
What is the prosecution's case against the two men still on trial?
Mimi
That Dowling booked the taxi, knowing Smith wanted to stab Chloe, and Rycroft walked out with her, tried to film it and was there to support her if needed.
Luke
Those are the prosecution's allegations. Both men deny the charges, and the jury hasn't decided anything yet.
Mark
The friend said Chloe expected a fight without weapons. Does that matter?
Mimi
It shows how Chloe understood the meeting, as just the two of them. The threats made by phone the night before and that afternoon point the other way, towards a knife.
Luke
Careful, though. That's one friend's account of what Chloe believed. We can't know what she actually expected.
Mark
And the 37 minutes before the ambulance call?
Mimi
It's a stark detail from the evidence. The court heard her grandfather made the call and was seen giving CPR.
Luke
The reporting gives the interval but not the reasons for it, so I'd leave it as a fact and nothing more.
Le Pouls
- Smith switched her plea to guilty of murder on the second day of trial, abandoning her earlier admission of manslaughter.
- Threats made by phone the night before escalated into a planned fight, with Smith vowing to stab Chloe in the throat.
- A taxi booked by Blake Dowling carried Chloe to Smith's grandfather's garden, where the fight was set to begin.
- Chloe was stabbed five times in the neck and back and died, while an ambulance was not called for 37 minutes.
- Co-defendants Dowling and Rycroft deny murder and manslaughter as their trial continues, leaving the case unresolved.
- Smith awaits sentencing at the trial's end, with life imprisonment mandatory and a minimum term still to be set.
On a Thursday in Leeds, in the second week of a trial that has laid bare how a jealous rivalry over a shared boyfriend hardened into something deadly, an 18-year-old woman finally accepted the full weight of what she had done. Kayla Smith, who had earlier admitted only manslaughter, now stands guilty of murdering Chloe Watson Dransfield, a 16-year-old girl who bled to death after a fight that was arranged in advance. The sentence is already fixed in kind if not in length, and what remains open is how the court will measure a life lost so young, and how the claims of two young men still denying their part will be weighed.
On the second day of her trial at Leeds Crown Court, Kayla Smith, 18, changed her plea to guilty of murder. She had already admitted manslaughter in the death of 16-year-old Chloe Watson Dransfield, but now accepted full responsibility for a stabbing the court has heard was planned in advance. The judge, Mr Justice Cavanagh KC, said he will sentence her when the trial concludes. Life imprisonment is the only sentence available, and he must still decide the minimum term she will serve.
The case grew out of a relationship between Blake Dowling, 18, and both young women. Dowling's mother told the court that Smith had been jealous and obsessed over her son's relationship with Chloe, though the two had never met before the fatal encounter. The prosecution said the pair argued by phone the evening before, and Smith repeatedly threatened to stab Chloe. A friend of Chloe's, listening on FaceTime, heard Smith say she would stab her in the throat.
The fight was agreed, and Dowling booked a taxi to take Chloe to Smith's home in Austhorpe. On the way, the friend said, Chloe spoke of getting the fight she had long wanted, and she believed it would be fists only, with no weapons. CCTV and doorbell footage showed Smith leaving her grandfather's annexe holding a knife, with Archie Rycroft, 20, following. Chloe was stabbed five times in the neck and back. Her grandfather, Geoff Smith, called an ambulance 37 minutes later and was seen giving CPR. Chloe was pronounced dead at 6.40am. When police arrived, Smith and Rycroft were reportedly laughing and using nitrous oxide.
Dowling and Rycroft both deny murder and manslaughter. The prosecution says Rycroft walked with Smith to the fight and filmed it, offering support if needed, and that Dowling knew of Smith's intentions and helped arrange the violence. Dowling denies knowing Chloe would suffer serious harm. Rycroft says he followed out of curiosity and did not see a knife. Their trial continues, and Smith's minimum term will not be fixed until it ends.
On the second day of her trial at Leeds crown court on Thursday, Kayla Smith, 18, changed her plea. She had already admitted manslaughter in the death of 16-year-old Chloe Watson Dransfield but denied murder. Now she pleaded guilty to murder, ending any dispute over her own responsibility for a stabbing that the court has heard was arranged in advance.
The judge, Mr Justice Cavanagh KC, said he would sentence Smith when the trial concludes. He told the court the only sentence available to him is life imprisonment, and that he will need to set the minimum term she must serve in custody.
The case centres on a young man, Blake Dowling, 18. The jury heard he had been in a relationship with both Chloe and Smith and knew of the bad feeling between them, although the two had never met in person before the fatal encounter. Dowling's mother told the court that Smith was "jealous and obsessed" over her son's relationship with Chloe.
According to the prosecution, the two had argued by phone the evening before, and Smith threatened several times to stab Chloe. On the day of the attack, Chloe was with Dowling when he spoke to Smith, who was at her grandfather's house in Austhorpe, east Leeds, with Archie Rycroft, 20. A friend of Chloe's was on FaceTime and told the court she heard Smith screaming at Dowling, saying she would smash his head in and that Chloe had better not be there. When Chloe said she was, the friend heard Smith say she would stab her in the throat.
The two young women agreed to fight, and Dowling booked a taxi to take Chloe to Smith's home. The friend told the court that on the way, Chloe said she was off to get the fight she had wanted for ages. Asked by Gill Batts KC, who defends Dowling, what she thought the fight would involve, the friend answered: "Just themselves, nothing else," meaning no weapons.
CCTV and video doorbell footage shown to the jury captured Smith coming out of the annexe in her grandfather's garden holding a knife. Rycroft followed her out. Chloe could be heard shouting "come on big girl". After the stabbing, she was seen on the footage running back to the annexe with Rycroft. Chloe had been stabbed five times in the neck and back, and she bled to death.
Smith's grandfather, Geoff Smith, called an ambulance 37 minutes after the stabbing, and a neighbour saw him performing CPR on Chloe. She was taken to hospital and pronounced dead at 6.40am. When police arrested Smith and Rycroft, the prosecution said, the pair were laughing and joking with two friends and using nitrous oxide in front of officers.
Dowling and Rycroft are both charged with murder and manslaughter and deny the charges. Prosecutor Mark McKone KC said the case against Rycroft is that he took part by walking with Smith to the fight, trying to film her using violence and offering support if needed. Dowling, he said, knew Smith wanted to stab Chloe and by booking the taxi helped organise the violence and encouraged Smith by taking Chloe there to fight. In their defence, Dowling denies knowing Chloe would suffer really serious harm, while Rycroft says he followed Smith out of curiosity and did not see a knife.
The trial of Dowling and Rycroft continues, and Smith's minimum term will be set only once it concludes.
Citations marquantes
Dowling knew Smith wanted to stab Chloe and by booking the taxi played a part in organising the violence.— Mark McKone KC, prosecutor
Smith was jealous and obsessed over her son's relationship with Chloe.— Blake Dowling's mother, giving evidence
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur The Guardian ↗