Late in Life, Roger Rosenblatt Finds Gratitude, Usefulness and Active Empathy on the East River

You take what you get, and you do what you can with it.
Rosenblatt's mentor John Kelleher passed on this advice from his own father, and it closes the essay.
Mark

Why does a personal essay about a tugboat deserve our attention this morning?

Mimi

Because it answers a question most people avoid. Rosenblatt asks whether he made a ripple, and his answer is to be useful to others.

Mark

What does useful mean for him, concretely?

Mimi

About once a week he writes to a friend who has lost a partner. The aim is to make them feel worthy of attention.

Luke

That's the one concrete practice in the piece. The rest is reflection, so we should be clear that this is opinion, not reporting.

Mark

He leans on a lot of voices, doesn't he?

Mimi

Lewis Thomas, Dostoyevsky, Tennyson, Wilbur, and his mentor John Kelleher. The Kelleher line, you take what you get and do what you can with it, anchors the ending.

Luke

Worth noting that the Thomas conversation is his recollection from the 1990s. We have only his account of it.

Mark

And the regrets?

Mimi

He names them honestly, the nights heaped with self-recrimination, then says only the morally aware feel them.

Luke

That's his consolation, not a finding. It's a claim about himself, and nothing here tests it.

  • An aging writer lies awake sorting through regret, wondering whether his life has truly rippled outward into the lives of others.
  • Every wrong word and missed kindness rises in the night, and he admits old age can seem made of nothing but these self-reproaches.
  • He turns toward usefulness and active empathy, writing weekly to a grieving friend and treating care for the isolated as the measure of a life.
  • The tension settles into gratitude for family, rivers, country and life itself, with the quiet understanding that the tug will one day carry him to open water.

On an East River morning, the essayist Roger Rosenblatt, looking out from his apartment at a small tugboat waiting at its work, reflects on what it means to grow old and ask whether one has made any ripple in the world. Drawing on the physician-philosopher Lewis Thomas, Dostoyevsky, Tennyson, and a long-ago mentor's plain wisdom, he finds that a life is measured less by its achievements than by its usefulness to others, and by the quiet practice of empathy toward those who feel alone. Published in the New York Times opinion pages, his essay meets the ageless question of regret and gratitude with a steady, unhurried acceptance: take what you get, and do what you can with it.

Before dawn, Roger Rosenblatt watches a tugboat lit in white and yellow wait beside a sanitation plant on the East River. He thinks of it as a patient little dockworker, and half-imagines Charon at its helm. The river flows uptown past tenements and hospitals, through the churning channel of Hell Gate, and out toward the Atlantic, growing from the small and known into something vast and unseen.

He asks the question he believes every old person asks: have I made a ripple? His family and friends answer yes. His writing he cannot judge, since it goes out like paper boats to an unseen public. For him, a life is measured by use. Remembering his friend Lewis Thomas, who was dying and preferred to talk about living, Rosenblatt recalls Thomas saying that the purpose of life is to be useful, a view he now shares.

He finds that usefulness in empathy for people who feel deserted. Each week he writes to a friend who has lost a partner, hoping to make them feel worthy of attention and loved. Such active empathy, he suggests, may be how a life's progress is truly judged, and it brings a certain peace.

He does not pretend the nights are easy. Regret and self-reproach run beneath his calm. Still, he finds consolation in the fact that only the morally aware are troubled by them. Above all he feels gratitude for those who love him, for rivers and seas, for a country that showed its best colors in recent elections, and for life itself.

He ends with a memory. When his son Carl was on the way, he wrote to his mentor John Kelleher, anxious about fatherhood. Kelleher answered with his own father's advice: you take what you get, and you do what you can with it. Like the tug rolling with the tides, Rosenblatt suggests, life is not easy but can be lived, and it does what it can with us. Overhead, terns wheel over beginnings and endings.

Before dawn on the East River, the first thing Roger Rosenblatt sees from his apartment window is a tugboat lit in white and yellow, waiting to tow and push a load of garbage away from a sanitation plant. He calls it a patient, stoic little dockworker. He has come to think it waits for him, as though Charon were at its helm at the entrance to the River Styx.

He watches the river run uptown past a mix of expensive apartments and tenements, schools and hospitals, then past the dangerous channel of Hell Gate near Randall's and Wards Islands. Beyond his sight it becomes Long Island Sound and then the Atlantic. In his telling, it grows from the small and known into the magnificent and invisible.

The essay, published in the Times opinion section, takes up the question he says every old person asks: have I made a ripple? Family, he says, yes: a wife, children, grandchildren. Friends, yes. His work as a writer he cannot judge, since writers send pieces out to an unseen public like paper boats. He cites Abdul El-Sayed, the senator-elect from Michigan, who says his religion teaches that saving one life is like saving all of humanity. Rosenblatt notes the same idea appears in the Talmud, and calls it the writer's creed too. As a writing teacher he hoped to help students see the world generously and stay open to all experience, dark and light. He quotes the poet Richard Wilbur: step off assuredly into the blank of your mind, and something will come.

His measure of a life is use. In the 1990s he was writing an essay for the Times about Lewis Thomas, the physician-philosopher who wrote "The Lives of a Cell." Thomas, a friend, was dying, and Rosenblatt wanted to ask him about it. Thomas preferred to talk about living, and said he thought the purpose of living was to be useful. Rosenblatt says he feels the same.

He locates a particular kind of usefulness in extending empathy to people who feel deserted or alone. About once a week he writes to a friend who has recently lost a partner. The point, he says, is to make people feel worthy of your time and attention, and in the cold isolation of modern life to help them feel love or something close to it. Dostoyevsky was said to have active empathy, and Rosenblatt suggests that moving from self-interest to that quality may be how a life's progress is judged. It takes a lifetime to appreciate and apply, and it brings a certain peace.

He does not pretend the nights are easy. Beneath the calm runs an undercurrent of regret and self-reproach: wrong things said and done, right things left unsaid or undone. Such attacks are so plentiful, he writes, that old age might seem to consist of nothing else. His consolation is that only the morally aware are troubled by them.

Above all, he feels gratitude: for the people who love him, for rivers and seas, for the country, which he says in the recent elections remembered and showed its best colors, and for life itself. He writes that one day his tug will carry him out to open water, to a place from which no one returns. It is something we can never know, and he notes that Tennyson, in "Crossing the Bar," saw the river as life and the end as a final surprise.

He closes on advice. When he and his wife, Ginny, were expecting their first child, Carl, he wrote to his university mentor John Kelleher, anxious about being a good father. Kelleher replied with what his own father once told him: you take what you get, and you do what you can with it. The tug, he says, rolls with the tides like a boxer rolling with punches. Life is not easy but doable, and it does what it can with you. Overhead, terns swoop and squawk over beginnings and ends. Rosenblatt is the author of "Making Toast," "Kayak Morning," "Cold Moon" and "More Rules for Aging."

You take what you get, and you do what you can with it.
— John Kelleher, quoting his father, to Roger Rosenblatt
The purpose of living is to be useful.
— Lewis Thomas, as recalled by Rosenblatt (paraphrase)
Contáctanos FAQ