Kharge's 'Modi ka baap' remark sparks nationwide BJP protests as India's opposition row escalates

Two people, 60-year-old Chanderpal and his 36-year-old son Vijay Kumar, died after a slab collapsed at an under-construction house in northeastern Delhi.
Modi ka baap bhi jayega — and a nationwide protest followed
Kharge's reply to a heckler in Bihar prompted the BJP to announce rallies and effigy burnings across India.
Mark

Why did one sentence in Bihar turn into nationwide protests?

Mimi

Kharge was answering a heckler about the voter roll revision, and he reached for a common idiom that invoked Modi's late father. The BJP treated that as crossing a line.

Mark

Is the phrase actually an insult in India?

Mimi

The reporting says it's a commonly used expression. BJP leaders argue that using it about a late parent is offensive anyway.

Luke

Worth noting the translation "even Modi's father will go to jail" comes from the report, and the audience shout comes via Press Trust of India. We don't have a full transcript here.

Mark

What does Congress say?

Mimi

Its leaders defend Kharge and say the BJP has made personal remarks against their people at rallies too.

Luke

That's a defense attributed to unnamed Congress leaders, with no specific examples given. Likewise, Shah's claim about desperation is his characterization, not established fact.

Mark

How big are the protests?

Mimi

BJP spokespersons and regional leaders said rallies would happen across the country, some burning effigies.

Luke

That's an announced plan. Nothing in the reporting confirms turnout or scale.

Mark

And the voter roll fight underneath?

Mimi

Congress alleges vote stealing. Luke would remind us those are the party's claims, though news reports of mass deletions have fueled protests.

  • A single phrase spoken at a Bihar event has ignited a national row that the BJP is turning into street protests.
  • Effigy burnings planned across the country raise the temperature of an already bitter fight over voter roll revisions.
  • Home Minister Amit Shah and party spokespeople are framing Congress as indecent and desperate, while Congress answers that the BJP trades in personal jabs too.
  • The protests are unlikely to fade quietly, and the real test is whether the voter list campaign survives the noise around the words.

On a Monday in late October, India's ruling party announced nationwide protests, some involving the burning of effigies, after Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge let slip a blunt idiom about Prime Minister Modi's late father. The remark, made in Bihar amid the fierce contest over how the country's voter rolls are revised, lands in a long tradition of political language that reaches for the family to wound the man. What it reveals is less a single sentence than a republic where every argument over ballots and power is quickly converted into an argument over honour.

On Monday, October 26, the Bharatiya Janata Party announced protest rallies across India, some of them with effigy burnings. The anger was aimed at a sentence Mallikarjun Kharge, president of the Congress, had spoken a day earlier at a party event in Bihar.

Kharge was attacking officials over the national revision of voter rolls, a process Congress has opposed for a year, accusing the government of using it to steal votes. Amid claims of mass deletions and irregularities, he promised that those responsible, Modi included, would go to jail. When an audience member shouted that Modi would never leave, Kharge replied with a common Hindi phrase, "Modi ka baap bhi jayega," or "even Modi's father will go to jail." BJP leaders said invoking the prime minister's late father was deeply offensive.

Home Minister Amit Shah called the remark indecent and listed past insults Congress had aimed at Modi and his family, arguing the party had turned to personal attacks out of frustration. Congress leaders defended Kharge, pointing to personal remarks the BJP has made about their members.

The same day, a court in Uttar Pradesh acquitted Rahul Gandhi in a defamation case, and in Delhi two men, a father and son, died when a slab collapsed at an unfinished house. The row now stands as a test of whether the voter list campaign will be pushed aside by a quarrel over one phrase, or whether the fight will sharpen it.

On Monday, October 26, the Bharatiya Janata Party said it would hold protest rallies across India, some of them involving the burning of effigies. The cause was a sentence spoken a day earlier by Mallikarjun Kharge, president of the Indian National Congress, at a party event in the eastern state of Bihar.

Kharge was speaking about the national revision of voter rolls, which Congress has been campaigning against for a year. The party accuses Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government of using the process to steal votes. Reports of mass deletions of voter names, and of irregularities by India's election body, have drawn protests from opposition parties, political pressure groups and student organizations.

At the event, Kharge claimed that all officials responsible for the irregularities, Modi included, would be sent to jail. According to the Press Trust of India, an audience member then shouted that as long as there was no rebellion, Modi wouldn't go anywhere. Kharge answered: "Modi ka baap bhi jayega," which translates as "even Modi's father will go to jail." The phrase is common in India, but BJP leaders said that bringing in the prime minister's late father was deeply offensive.

Home Minister Amit Shah, regarded as Modi's right-hand man, called it an "indecent remark" and posted on X that Congress has a history of abusive language toward Modi and his family. He listed insults to Modi's revered mother, the label "merchant of death," and mockery of his poverty through the word "chaiwala." Shah said Congress under Rahul Gandhi crosses the limits of indecency daily, and claimed the party had turned to personal attacks out of desperation and frustration over losing its political base.

A BJP spokesperson asked on social media whether this was the language expected from the national president of a party that claims to uphold democratic values. The party's official handle urged opponents to oppose politically but not weaponize respect for late parents, adding that 140 crore Indians, or 1.4 billion people, would never forgive those who insult their elders. Congress leaders defended Kharge, saying the BJP has often made personal remarks about Congress members at rallies.

The row came on a day of other news. A court in Sultanpur, Uttar Pradesh, acquitted Rahul Gandhi in a defamation case brought by a BJP member over a 2018 state election speech in which he allegedly called Shah an "accused murder." The acquittal arrives as Gandhi leads a united opposition campaign against Modi and the Chief Election Commissioner over the voter list revision.

In Delhi, two people died when a large slab of an under-construction house in the northeast of the city fell on contractors on Sunday evening. Rescuers worked overnight and recovered the bodies of 60-year-old Chanderpal and his 36-year-old son Vijay Kumar on Monday morning. In September, a five-storey building housing paying-guest students collapsed in the capital, killing at least seven.

On the border, China's Foreign Ministry said it was carrying out normal patrol and control activities, answering India's claim that Chinese forces deviated from established patterns and caused a standoff in Arunachal Pradesh. Prince Alois of Liechtenstein, with Princess Sophie, reached Mumbai on the second day of a four-day state visit, with a banquet hosted by President Droupadi Murmu and talks with Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar ahead.

What to watch is whether the BJP protests grow beyond effigy burnings, and whether the quarrel over a single phrase pulls attention from the opposition's voter roll campaign or reinforces it.

Congress keeps crossing the limits of indecency every day under Rahul Gandhi's leadership.
— Amit Shah, Home Minister, on X
Oppose politically, but don't turn respect for late parents into a weapon of cheap politics.
— BJP's official social media handle
Contattaci Domande frequenti