On a Thursday in a Miami courtroom, a federal judge gave the sitting president a deadline of December 11 to answer questions from the lawyers of the British broadcaster he has sued. It is a small procedural moment with an old and familiar shape: a powerful man who brings a claim must also submit to the scrutiny that claim invites. The lawsuit grows out of a documentary that spliced together fragments of his January 6, 2021 speech, a speech whose aftermath still sits heavily in the national memory, and the question of whether those edits misled. Whether he will sit, and what he will say, now re
Judge Orders Trump to Sit for Deposition by Dec. 11 in BBC Defamation Suit
Nearly eight months into discovery, the BBC has not yet spoken with Trump.
Mark
Why does a scheduling fight matter so much in this case?
Mimi
Because discovery ends Dec. 18, and the BBC says it still hasn't questioned the plaintiff. Judge Lett's Dec. 11 date leaves only a week of cushion.
Mark
And the penalty is serious, isn't it?
Mimi
Per the AP, it could include dismissal of his suit, unless discovery is extended. So the order has teeth, at least on paper.
Luke
"Could include" is doing work there. We know what the AP reported the judge said, not what she'd actually do. Nothing says dismissal is likely.
Mark
Why did the deposition get canceled?
Mimi
His lawyers cited "other matters of national importance." The BBC told the court he was in Georgia with candidates and then at an RNC event at Mar-a-Lago that day.
Luke
Keep in mind that's the BBC's account in a filing. The source doesn't give us the president's side on those details, and his team's statement didn't address the order.
Mark
What about Jack Smith?
Mimi
The BBC wants to know whether Mr. Trump understood his Jan. 6 remarks could lead to violence. Smith doesn't object to the subpoena, but Trump's lawyers say he has no personal knowledge and would be duplicative.
Luke
And we don't know yet how the judge ruled on that. The hearing was set to discuss it, but the reporting here doesn't say what came of it.
Mark
Anything else unresolved?
Mimi
The Mar-a-Lago membership and fee records. The BBC wants them; the president's lawyers say there's no legitimate purpose.
Luke
Right, and the BBC's stated reason for those records isn't spelled out in this reporting, so I wouldn't guess at it.
Der Puls
- A federal judge has set a hard December 11 deadline, and the president's suit could be dismissed if he refuses to answer the BBC's questions.
- The president cancelled an October 16 deposition citing 'matters of national importance,' leaving the BBC nearly eight months into discovery without his testimony.
- The BBC is pressing to compel the president, subpoena former special counsel Jack Smith, and obtain Mar-a-Lago membership records, while Trump's lawyers call those demands irrelevant and duplicative.
- Discovery closes December 18, so the outcome hinges on whether the deadline holds or the schedule is extended.
- The president's team has answered with combative rhetoric about holding the BBC accountable rather than a concrete scheduling commitment.
On a Thursday in a Miami courtroom, a federal judge gave the sitting president a deadline of December 11 to answer questions from the lawyers of the British broadcaster he has sued. It is a small procedural moment with an old and familiar shape: a powerful man who brings a claim must also submit to the scrutiny that claim invites. The lawsuit grows out of a documentary that spliced together fragments of his January 6, 2021 speech, a speech whose aftermath still sits heavily in the national memory, and the question of whether those edits misled. Whether he will sit, and what he will say, now rests on a clock that is quietly running out.
On a Thursday morning in Miami, Judge Enjolique Lett told the President of the United States that he has until December 11 to sit for questioning by lawyers for the BBC. The order came at a hearing in the defamation suit Mr. Trump brought against the broadcaster in December, over a documentary that aired weeks before the 2024 election. The film used spliced portions of his January 6, 2021 speech, and he contends it misled viewers and misrepresented what he told his supporters before they marched on the Capitol. The BBC has said it sincerely regrets how the clip was edited, but it denies there is any basis for defamation.
The deadline follows a canceled date. Trump was due to be deposed on October 16, but his lawyers pulled out, citing other matters of national importance. The BBC says that on that day he was in Georgia campaigning with Republican candidates and then at Mar-a-Lago for a party event. He reportedly offered to appear in January. If he does not answer by December 11, the court warns that his own suit could be dismissed, unless the discovery period is extended.
The wider fight is over evidence. The BBC wants testimony from Jack Smith, the former special counsel who once charged Trump over efforts to overturn the 2020 election, arguing Smith could speak to whether the president knew his words could incite violence. Trump's lawyers call that testimony duplicative. The BBC also seeks Mar-a-Lago membership and fee records, which the president's team says serve no legitimate purpose. Discovery ends December 18, and the BBC notes that after nearly eight months it has not yet questioned the central figure in its own case. What comes next is whether the deadline holds and how the court rules on those requests.
On Thursday morning in a Miami courtroom, a federal magistrate judge told the President of the United States that he has until Dec. 11 to sit for questioning by lawyers for the BBC. U.S. Magistrate Judge Enjolique Lett set the deadline at a hearing, according to the Associated Press, in the defamation lawsuit Mr. Trump brought against the British broadcaster.
The order carries a warning. According to the AP, if Mr. Trump does not answer questions by that date, he faces penalties that could include dismissal of his own suit. The one exception is if the period for both sides to collect information in the case is extended.
The deadline follows a canceled date. Mr. Trump was due to be deposed on Friday, Oct. 16, but late last month his lawyers told the BBC he would no longer be available "due to other matters of national importance." The BBC told the court that on the day of the scheduled deposition, the president was in Georgia with Republican candidates for Senate and governor. He then traveled to Mar-a-Lago, his South Florida resort, for a Republican National Committee event. According to the BBC, he said he could be available in the second or third week of January. BBC lawyers asked the judge to compel him to confirm a date and answer their questions.
A spokesman for the president's legal team did not address the judge's demand in a statement. He said the president's "powerhouse lawsuit is holding the BBC accountable for its defamation and reckless election interference just as he has held other fake news mainstream media responsible for their wrongdoing."
Mr. Trump sued the BBC in December over a documentary that aired in October 2024, just weeks before the presidential election. The film used spliced-together portions of the speech he gave outside the White House on Jan. 6, 2021. He alleges it misled viewers and falsely portrayed his remarks to supporters. After that speech, a crowd of his backers marched to the U.S. Capitol and breached it, where lawmakers and then-Vice President Mike Pence had gathered to reaffirm the 2020 election results. In November 2025, the BBC said it "sincerely regrets" how the clip was edited, but it disagreed that there was any basis for a defamation claim.
The hearing was also set to take up the network's subpoena for deposition testimony from Jack Smith, the former special counsel who brought a case against Mr. Trump in 2023 over alleged efforts to subvert the transfer of power after the 2020 election. Those charges were dismissed after Mr. Trump won a second term in 2024. The BBC argues in a court filing that Smith could shed light on matters surrounding the Jan. 6 speech, including whether the president knew his remarks could lead to violence. The network says Smith does not object to the subpoena. Mr. Trump's lawyers dispute that Smith has personal knowledge of the speech or of the president's state of mind, and call his testimony "duplicative," since he has already spoken about his investigation, including to Congress.
The BBC is also seeking Mar-a-Lago documents on membership and initiation fees, which the president's lawyers say serve no legitimate purpose.
The clock is the backdrop to all of it. Discovery began in February and is set to end Dec. 18. In a filing, BBC lawyers said that nearly eight months in, they have not spoken with Mr. Trump and have no schedule to question him, calling him "the most central figure in this case." In a motion earlier this month they wrote that a plaintiff's unwillingness to sit for a deposition "can be perilous to his claim."
What to watch now is whether Dec. 11 holds or the discovery period is extended, and how the court rules on the Smith subpoena and the Mar-a-Lago records.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
There is hardly a more crucial and relevant piece of discovery in a defamation lawsuit than the deposition of the Plaintiff.— BBC lawyers, in a motion filed earlier this month
His powerhouse lawsuit is holding the BBC accountable for its defamation and reckless election interference.— Spokesman for President Trump's legal team
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei CBS News ↗
Politics & Governance