For the third time in as many weeks, Johor has chosen to keep its children indoors rather than send them into air that science and medicine have deemed too dangerous to breathe. The extension of school closures through October 19–23 reflects not a failure of policy but a confrontation with a deeper truth: that the health of the most vulnerable members of a community is the measure by which all other decisions must be weighed. With nearly 31,000 respiratory cases recorded in a single month and no meteorological relief in sight, the state's leaders have found themselves caught between the rhythm
Johor extends school closures another week as haze persists, API remains critical
Respiratory health crisis affecting children and vulnerable groups, with 30,648 asthma and upper respiratory tract infection cases recorded in Johor in October.
30,648 respiratory cases in one month, climbing 20.7% week-on-week
Mark
Why extend closures again? Couldn't they have waited to see if the air improved?
Mimi
The API readings showed no significant improvement, and they were looking at the forecast for the next few days. It wasn't getting better—it was staying dangerous.
Luke
But who made that forecast? Is that a meteorological agency prediction, or an estimate from the state?
Mimi
The statement doesn't specify. It just says they considered weather forecasts and wind movement.
Mark
What about the asthma numbers—30,648 cases. That's a lot. Is that the total for the month, or new cases this week?
Mimi
It's the total for October so far. And it's up 20.7 percent week-on-week, which means the trend is getting worse.
Luke
But we don't know if that's because of the haze or if it's seasonal. Respiratory infections spike in certain months anyway.
Mimi
True. The statement doesn't isolate the haze as the cause. It just presents the numbers as part of the reasoning.
Mark
So students can still take exams. How does that work if schools are closed?
Mimi
They coordinate with the Education Department. Exams happen under health protocols—probably in controlled settings with masks and distancing.
Luke
And private schools can stay open if they want. So some kids are in enclosed classrooms with masks, others are at home. That's a patchwork.
Mimi
It is. But the state can't force private institutions to close. They can only set guidelines.
El Pulso
- Air Pollutant Index readings across Johor remain at hazardous levels with no meaningful improvement forecast for the coming days, leaving officials with little room to reopen safely.
- Asthma and upper respiratory tract infections have surged 20.7% in a single week, with 30,648 cases recorded in Johor this October alone — a medical emergency unfolding alongside the environmental one.
- Children, the elderly, and those with pre-existing conditions face the gravest risk, and it is their vulnerability that has repeatedly tipped the scales toward closure over continuity.
- Home-based learning continues to bridge the educational gap, while limited exam exemptions offer a narrow path forward for students with unavoidable assessments.
- Private schools and childcare centers may remain open under strict conditions — enclosed spaces, mandatory masks, full health compliance — creating a fragmented landscape of access and risk.
For the third time in as many weeks, Johor has chosen to keep its children indoors rather than send them into air that science and medicine have deemed too dangerous to breathe. The extension of school closures through October 19–23 reflects not a failure of policy but a confrontation with a deeper truth: that the health of the most vulnerable members of a community is the measure by which all other decisions must be weighed. With nearly 31,000 respiratory cases recorded in a single month and no meteorological relief in sight, the state's leaders have found themselves caught between the rhythms of education and the rhythms of the body — and have, again, chosen the body.
Johor's schools will remain closed for a third consecutive extension, shuttered from October 19 through 23 as hazardous air quality continues to grip the state with no significant relief expected. The decision was made Saturday at a state Haze Management Coordination Meeting, where officials reviewed wind patterns, weather forecasts, and a deeply concerning rise in illness among children.
The numbers behind the decision are stark. Johor recorded 30,648 cases of asthma and upper respiratory tract infections in October alone — a 20.7 percent increase from the previous week. State education and information committee chairman Dr Muhammad Naqib Md Ghazali cited both the persistently dangerous Air Pollutant Index readings and the medical data as the twin pillars of the closure, noting that a three-to-four day outlook offered no promise of improvement.
The closure is not without exceptions. Students facing specific examinations may be exempted under strict health protocols, coordinated between the state Education Department and individual schools. Exams and assessments will be rescheduled in collaboration with the Education Ministry and religious school authorities. Home-based learning will continue throughout, ensuring instruction does not stop even as physical gatherings do.
Private schools and childcare centers retain the choice to remain open, but only under tightly controlled conditions — fully enclosed spaces, mandatory face masks, and full compliance with state health guidelines. This marks the third time since October 7 that schools have been shuttered, each closure driven by the same calculation: the air outside remains too dangerous for children to spend a full school day breathing it.
Johor's schools will stay shuttered for another week. On Monday, October 19, through Friday, October 23, every school and educational institution across the state will remain closed—an extension of closures that began October 7 and have already stretched through two previous rounds. The decision came Saturday morning at a state Haze Management Coordination Meeting, where officials weighed wind patterns, weather forecasts, and a troubling spike in respiratory illness among children.
Dr Muhammad Naqib Md Ghazali, the state's education and information committee chairman, laid out the reasoning plainly: Air Pollutant Index readings have not improved significantly, and the air quality remains at levels officials consider dangerous. The state looked ahead three to four days and saw no relief coming. But the numbers that drove the decision were medical. Johor recorded 30,648 cases of asthma and upper respiratory tract infections this month alone—a jump of 20.7 percent from the previous week. Children and elderly people, along with others with existing health vulnerabilities, face the greatest risk from prolonged exposure to polluted air.
The closure is not absolute. Students who must sit for specific examinations or assessments can be exempted, but only with coordination between the state Education Department and individual schools, and only if they follow strict health protocols. The Education Ministry and Johor's religious schools will work together to reschedule exams and assessments. Throughout the week off, students will continue learning from home—instruction will not stop, only the physical gathering will.
Private schools and childcare centers operate under different rules. They are permitted to stay open or close as they choose, but if they remain open, they must operate in fully enclosed spaces and require everyone inside to wear face masks. These facilities must also comply with other health guidelines set by the state.
This is the third extension in as little than three weeks. Schools first closed on October 7 and 8, then reopened briefly before closing again from October 12 through 16. Each time, the decision has hinged on the same calculation: the air outside is too dangerous for children to breathe for a full school day. Dr Muhammad Naqib framed the decision as deference to Johor Regent Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim, who has consistently prioritized the health and safety of people in the state. The regent's position has effectively set the threshold for when schools must close—and so far, that threshold keeps being crossed.
Citas Notables
We took into account wind movement towards the north, weather forecasts for the next three to four days and health concerns over prolonged exposure to air pollution, particularly among children and vulnerable groups.— Dr Muhammad Naqib Md Ghazali, state education and information committee chairman
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en The Star ↗
Climate & Environment