Jet may have broken apart before Florida crash that killed nine, including a family of four

All nine people aboard died, including a tech entrepreneur, his wife, their two young children, friends, a nanny and two pilots; one man on the ground was injured.
"She loved the freedom," her mother said of the 20-year-old co-pilot
Camila Corteleti spoke to the New York Times about her daughter, Nathalia Filgueiras, who died in the crash.
Mark

The headline says the jet may have broken apart before the crash. How firm is that?

Mimi

Fairly cautious. The NTSB's Tom Chapman said they have some evidence of breakup before impact, and that parts may turn up some distance from the crater.

Luke

Worth noting that's "some evidence," not a finding. Nobody has said what broke or why.

Mark

What do the air traffic recordings add?

Mimi

A sequence. Moderate turbulence, managing ice, picking up precipitation, a need to climb, then a descent of 10,000 feet per minute and later 20,000, with an overspeed call.

Luke

Those are words on a recording. They show what the crew reported, not what caused it. Whether the breakup came before or after the overspeed is not established.

Mark

Why is the crater such a problem?

Mimi

It's where the major wreckage is, and storms have partly filled it with water. Monville called recovering it the biggest obstacle.

Luke

And we don't yet know whether a cockpit voice recorder was on board. That's still an open question.

Mark

Who were the people aboard?

Mimi

Adam Robinson, Helen Sharp, their children Emma and Charlie, friends Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr, nanny Anita Maria Cetina, and two pilots.

Luke

The pilot and co-pilot names come from media reports, not an official release, so I'd hold those a little more loosely.

  • A Learjet 60 slammed into a six-lane Palm Beach road in a thunderstorm, leaving a crater beside a mobile home park and killing all nine people aboard.
  • Air traffic audio captures a crew battling turbulence and ice, then a frantic call of overspeed as the jet plunged toward the ground.
  • Investigators believe the aircraft broke apart in the air, so debris may be scattered well beyond the impact site.
  • Storm water has partly filled the crater, and recovering the wreckage and finding the cockpit voice recorder remain the NTSB's most urgent tasks.

On a Sunday afternoon in Palm Beach, Florida, a Learjet 60 that had left Austin, Texas for the Bahamas came down onto a busy road in a storm and killed all nine people aboard, a reminder of how quickly ordinary routes can turn into fatal ones. Investigators now face the slow work of reading what the sky did to the aircraft, a task complicated by the water-filled crater where the wreckage lies. The families' grief, the lives of a young couple and their children, a nanny, friends, and two pilots, gives weight to a question the National Transportation Safety Board must answer patiently: why a plane in trouble fell apart before it reached the ground.

A little before 1 p.m. on Sunday, a Learjet 60 bound for the Bahamas came down on Military Trail in Palm Beach, Florida, a busy six-lane road lined with restaurants and shops. The jet had left Austin, Texas, and it exploded on impact in heavy rain and thunderstorms. All nine people aboard died, and a man in a car on the road was injured in the leg. Debris fell across sports fields, businesses and homes, and the crater it left sits close to a mobile home park.

The National Transportation Safety Board has early signs that the plane broke apart before it struck the ground, so parts may lie some distance away. Storm water has partly filled the crater, making recovery of the main wreckage the hardest task ahead. Air traffic recordings capture the crew reporting turbulence and ice, then climbing requests and an overspeed descent, with the voice saying they were going to crash.

The dead included tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson, his wife Helen Sharp, and their children Emma, four, and Charlie, two, along with family friends Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr and the children's nanny, Anita Maria Cetina. Their families remembered a devoted couple and a nanny who was truly part of the family. The pilots were Jeffrey Gregory, 55, and co-pilot Nathalia Filgueiras, 20, who had earned her licence at 17 and once joked about being able to fly planes but not drive a car. Her mother said, "She loved the freedom."

What the investigation can learn now depends on raising the wreckage from the water, finding any parts that fell away, and determining whether the voice recorder survived.

A little before 1 p.m. on Sunday, a Learjet 60 came down onto Military Trail in Palm Beach, Florida, a six-lane road lined with businesses and restaurants. It hit at about 12:50 local time (17:50 GMT) and exploded on impact. All nine people aboard died. One man in a car on the ground suffered a leg injury.

The jet had left Austin, Texas, bound for the Bahamas. Heavy rain and thunderstorms were reported in the Palm Beach area when it fell. Debris landed across sports fields, businesses and homes nearby, and the plane left a large crater in the road close to the entrance of a mobile home park.

That crater is now the central problem for investigators. Tim Monville, the lead investigator for the US National Transportation Safety Board, told a news conference on Monday that recovering the major wreckage from it would be the biggest obstacle. Severe storms have partly filled the crater with water. The NTSB says weather will be a major focus of its inquiry.

The board also has early evidence that the aircraft did not arrive in one piece. "We do have some evidence that there was some breakup of the aircraft before impact," said the NTSB's Tom Chapman, who added that parts might be found some distance from the impact site. Officials are also trying to establish whether a cockpit voice recorder was aboard and, if so, whether it can be recovered. Flight analysis indicates the jet was falling at hundreds of feet per second before it hit the ground.

Air traffic control recordings capture the crew's last minutes. Someone in the cockpit reported moderate turbulence and said the crew was managing the ice. The same voice then said the plane was picking up precipitation and that they needed to climb. Moments later, the voice reported a descent of 10,000 feet (3,048m) per minute. An emergency was declared, and the voice can be heard shouting that they were in an overspeed condition, descending at 20,000 feet per minute, before saying they were going to crash into the ground.

Seven of the dead were passengers. A joint statement named them as tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson, his wife Helen Sharp, and their children Emma, four, and Charlie, two, along with family friends Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr, and the children's nanny, Anita Maria Cetina. Robinson's LinkedIn page describes him as founder and CEO of RB2B and Retention.com, and CEO of Moltsets, all technology companies. He previously worked at Lehman Brothers and Barclays. Media reports describe Sharp as an artist. Their families called them devoted parents whose children were the light of their lives, and said of the couple: "Helen and Adam were the love affair that will last forever." The statement said Cetina cared for the children with tenderness and devotion and was truly part of the family. Reed and Fehr were described as full of joy and adventure.

Media reports named the pilot as Jeffrey Gregory, 55, who was married with two children. East Coast Jets, where he used to work, said it was deeply saddened by the loss of Capt Jeff Gregory. The co-pilot, reported to be Nathalia Filgueiras, was 20 and had earned her pilot's licence at 17. Her mother, Camila Corteleti, confirmed her death to US media and told the New York Times: "She loved the freedom." In a 2023 interview with a local CBS affiliate, while still a high school senior, Filgueiras said she liked being different, and joked that people found it odd she could fly planes but not drive a car.

What the NTSB can learn now depends on getting the wreckage out of the water-filled crater, finding any parts that fell away in the air, and determining whether a voice recorder survived.

We do have some evidence that there was some breakup of the aircraft before impact.
— Tom Chapman, NTSB
The biggest obstacle that we're going to have is recovering the major wreckage from the impacted crater on the roadway.
— Tim Monville, NTSB lead investigator
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei BBC News ↗
Kontakt FAQ