In the quiet arithmetic of rugby, a defeat can still teach a lesson that a win would have hidden. Fiji fell 43-15 to Ireland in Dublin, yet their coach Jake White, a man who once led South Africa to the summit of the world game, looked past the scoreline toward the Springboks waiting a week away. His point was that Ireland had been given a comfortable hour they should not expect again, and that the difference between a nervous first half and a comfortable second is the difference between a team that has learned and one that has merely been spared. As Ireland prepare to meet South Africa in Dub
Jake White Says Fiji 'Did Ireland a Favour' Ahead of Springboks Clash in Dublin
"We probably did Ireland a favour today."
Mark
Why is the losing coach's view getting so much attention?
Mimi
Because Jake White knows South Africa from the inside. He won the 2007 World Cup with them, and he's describing what they would have done with Fiji's chances.
Mark
What's the core of his argument?
Mimi
That Fiji played like South Africa, defending and letting Ireland have the ball, and that Ireland looked sluggish against it. He thinks that won't work next week.
Luke
Worth saying that's White's reading. It's analysis from a coach on the losing side, not a fact about how Ireland will play.
Mark
What about the tap penalty?
Mimi
He was annoyed Fiji took it instead of the scrum. He says South Africa would have scrummed repeatedly to try to win a yellow card.
Luke
Again, that's his view of what they would do. He didn't say whether the scrum would have worked for Fiji.
Mark
Did Farrell push back?
Mimi
Not really. He said Ireland learned good lessons, admitted the scoreline flattered them, and credited Fiji's physicality.
Luke
And what we don't know is how much the second-half gap says about Ireland, or about Fiji tiring. The reporting doesn't settle that.
Mark
And McNabney?
Mimi
Two big carries in about three and a half minutes, then a head injury. He's out of the South Africa game, and Farrell says he's in good spirits.
The Pulse
- Ireland trailed by five points after 25 minutes, and a stubborn Fiji side made the Aviva Stadium nervous for long stretches.
- Then Ireland exploded, scoring 26 unanswered second-half points that turned a tight contest into a 43-15 rout.
- Jake White warns that Ireland's sluggish spells would be ruthlessly exploited by South Africa's tap penalties and five-metre set pieces.
- Andy Farrell's squad insists the lessons have been absorbed, but the Springboks, back-to-back world champions, arrive in Dublin on Saturday at 16:40 GMT to test that claim.
In the quiet arithmetic of rugby, a defeat can still teach a lesson that a win would have hidden. Fiji fell 43-15 to Ireland in Dublin, yet their coach Jake White, a man who once led South Africa to the summit of the world game, looked past the scoreline toward the Springboks waiting a week away. His point was that Ireland had been given a comfortable hour they should not expect again, and that the difference between a nervous first half and a comfortable second is the difference between a team that has learned and one that has merely been spared. As Ireland prepare to meet South Africa in Dublin, the lesson is less about tactics than about whether a team can carry its best intensity through a whole game against opponents who will punish every hesitation.
Fiji lost 43-15 to Ireland at the Aviva Stadium, but the talk afterwards belonged to a different opponent. Jake White, who has recently taken charge of Fiji and once led the Springboks to the 2007 World Cup, said his side had done Ireland a favour, a week before the Irish meet South Africa in Dublin.
The scoreline hid a closer game. Fiji frustrated Andy Farrell's team in a tight first half, and Ireland led only 17-15 at the break, after being five points down at the 25-minute mark. Then Ireland pulled away, scoring 26 unanswered points after the interval.
White argued that Fiji had been too passive, letting Ireland have the ball and happy to defend. He warned that South Africa would exploit that kind of patience. He also criticised his own side for taking a tap penalty instead of a scrum, and said the Springboks would back themselves to turn set-piece pressure into points.
Farrell accepted that the score flattered his team and credited Fiji for their collisions, aerial play and breakdown work. There was also a bright moment: Ulster back row James McNabney made his debut off the bench, produced two big carries, and then left with a head injury after about three and a half minutes. That injury rules him out of the South Africa match.
The question for Saturday is whether Ireland can keep their intensity for 80 minutes and cope with South Africa's set-piece pressure without McNabney.
Fiji lost 43-15 to Ireland at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday, but the man who coached them, Jake White, came away talking about a different team: South Africa. White, who took over Fiji last month and led the Springboks to the 2007 World Cup, said his side had "done Ireland a favour" in their Nations Championship match, one week before the Irish meet the Springboks in Dublin.
The scoreline was not how the game looked for long. Fiji frustrated Andy Farrell's team through a tight first half, and Ireland led only 17-15 at the break. After 25 minutes Ireland had been five points down. Then they pulled away, scoring 26 unanswered points in the second half.
White, 62, argued that Fiji's approach had made things easier than they should have been. "We were playing a little bit like South Africa to be honest," he said. By his account, Fiji let Ireland have the ball, were content to defend, and were happy for the Irish to try to outwork them. His warning was that Ireland, in his words, know deep down they will be up against it if they play like that against the Springboks, who are back-to-back world champions and won 24-13 in Dublin last year. The two sides meet on Saturday at 16:40 GMT.
White was also frustrated by a decision of his own team's in the second half, when the game was still in the balance. Fiji chose a tap penalty rather than a scrum. He said South Africa would have taken the scrum, backed themselves to win a yellow card from it, and gone back to scrum after scrum without worrying about a referee's call on collapsing or early engagement. He said the same applied to the five-metre lineouts Fiji did not take advantage of, and to the five-metre scrum and tap penalties, which he said South Africa would turn into points. He expected Farrell and his players to be aware of that.
He also pointed to the captain. With Malcolm Marx leading South Africa, White said, there is no chance he would say "we'll take the tap"; he would call for the scrum, or kick to the corner and take the lineout, because South Africa back themselves in those situations. White read Farrell's team selection as a deliberate choice too: Ireland know what is coming, he said, and keeping a settled side meant they would be more "gun-ready" next weekend, rather than being one game short of playing South Africa.
When White's comments were put to Farrell, the Ireland coach said the squad had been saying in the changing room that they had learned good lessons and would use them properly next week. He accepted that the scoreline flattered his side. You have to work for those points, he said, and being five points down after 25 minutes against a team playing well is not comfortable. He credited Fiji with winning collisions, being good in the air and on the floor, running physically through the line, and a solid breakdown. Wins under pressure, he said, are precious.
There was one clear bright spot, and one loss. Ulster back row James McNabney, 23, made his debut off the bench, produced two big carries, and was then forced off with a head injury after roughly three and a half minutes. The injury rules him out of the South Africa game. Farrell said McNabney was joking in the changing room, delighted with the shortest cameo of a first cap, and called it the best three-and-a-half-minute debut cameo in Irish history. McNabney remembers the two breaks he made, Farrell said, and seems in good spirits.
The question for Saturday is whether Ireland take White's advice: sustain their intensity for 80 minutes and handle South Africa's set-piece pressure without McNabney.
Notable Quotes
I think we probably did Ireland a favour today.— Jake White, Fiji head coach
The scoreline flattered us a little bit, but you've got to work for those points.— Andy Farrell, Ireland head coach
Want the full story?
Read the original at BBC News ↗