Israel Votes in Pivotal Election as Netanyahu and Eisenkot Face Tight Race and Possible Deadlock

The 7 October 2023 Hamas-led attacks killed nearly 1,200 people and took 251 hostages to Gaza; Israeli strikes on Gaza have continued almost daily since a ceasefire.
Neither bloc is projected to reach the 61 seats needed for a majority
Polls show Netanyahu and Eisenkot nearly level, leaving the outcome to coalition bargaining.
Mark

Why is this election being called pivotal, when Israel has voted so often?

Mimi

The mix of issues. The 7 October failure, the corruption trial, judicial reform and the draft are all on the ballot at once, and 70,000 people reportedly flew home to vote.

Luke

That 70,000 figure is reported, not confirmed. Worth holding it loosely.

Mark

The polls show a near tie. Is that the real story?

Mimi

The tie matters less than the arithmetic. Neither bloc is projected to reach 61 seats, so the bargaining afterwards decides things.

Luke

And polls are projections. Exit polls at 22:00 can vary significantly, and soldiers' ballots counted from Wednesday may shift the picture.

Mark

What about the Arab parties?

Mimi

About a fifth of the population is Arab, and in theory they could be kingmakers. But all but one of the leading Jewish parties have ruled out working with them.

Luke

Speculation about them informally backing Eisenkot is just that. Lieberman has already said he won't be part of it.

Mark

Do the two men differ on Gaza?

Mimi

Less than you'd expect. Eisenkot's position is broadly similar, with an 18-month pledge to end Hamas rule.

Luke

The Iran reports are the weak point. Channel 12 and CNN reported them, Netanyahu denied both, and we don't know which account holds.

  • Polls show Netanyahu and Eisenkot almost tied, yet neither bloc is likely to reach the 61 seats needed to govern alone.
  • Security dominates every rally: the failures of 7 October, the unresolved demand for an independent inquiry, and the stalled draft of ultra-Orthodox men.
  • Netanyahu's late-campaign claims about Iran and a provocative AI image have sharpened the sense of crisis, while he and his opponents trade accusations of hysteria and deception.
  • Coalition talks could drag on for weeks or months, with late-counted soldiers' ballots possibly tipping the balance toward the right and a deadlock threatening yet another election.
  • Almost-daily strikes on Gaza continue after the ceasefire, and whoever forms the next government will inherit a war that has not ended.

On a day when some seventy thousand Israelis had flown home from abroad and half a million were voting for the first time, a nation that has long organised itself around conflict faced a choice that feels larger than any single ballot. Benjamin Netanyahu, who has shaped Israeli politics for decades, and Gadi Eisenkot, a former military chief who now leads the Yashar Party, stand nearly level, yet neither can easily assemble a majority. The questions beneath the contest are old ones in new form: how a democracy answers for a catastrophe it did not prevent, how a leader balances his own legal trials against public trust, and whether a people divided over war and justice can agree on who should lead them through it.

By the time polls opened, around 70,000 Israelis had flown home from abroad just to vote, and half a million were casting a ballot for the first time. Many regard this as one of the most pivotal elections in the country's history, and the sense of stakes is hard to overstate.

The contest pits the incumbent, Benjamin Netanyahu, against Gadi Eisenkot, a former military chief whose Yashar Party was formed only last year. Polls put them nearly level, but neither bloc is projected to reach the 61 seats needed for a majority. Israel's proportional system has always produced coalitions, and the bargaining that follows could take weeks or months. Eisenkot leads a change bloc united mainly by its wish to remove Netanyahu, bringing together figures as different as Naftali Bennett, Avigdor Lieberman and the left-leaning Yair Golan.

Security has framed the campaign. The opposition presses Netanyahu over the failures that allowed the 7 October attacks, which killed nearly 1,200 people and took 251 hostages to Gaza, and it wants an independent inquiry he has long resisted. Critics also point to his corruption trial, which he denies, and to judicial reforms that sparked mass protests. In the final days, reports that he had pushed for action against Iran, and had been refused by Washington, added to the tension; he denied both, and Eisenkot called him hysterical.

On Gaza, Eisenkot's stance is not far from Netanyahu's, and the two-state solution has all but vanished from mainstream Israeli politics. Strikes continue almost daily since the ceasefire, and whoever governs will inherit that unfinished war.

The results will emerge slowly. Exit polls arrive at 22:00 local time, but soldiers' votes, which may favour the right, will mostly be counted on Wednesday. The outcome many fear most is deadlock, which would mean another election, with Netanyahu serving as interim prime minister.

By the time polls opened, an estimated 70,000 Israelis had reportedly flown home from abroad just to vote, and half a million more were casting a ballot for the first time. Many in the country regard this as one of the most pivotal elections in its history, and the numbers help explain why.

The contest is between the incumbent, Benjamin Netanyahu, and Gadi Eisenkot, a former military chief. Polling published on Friday had them close to level. Neither man's bloc, though, is projected to reach the 61 seats needed for a majority in the Knesset. Israel's proportional system has always produced coalition governments, and this time the bargaining that follows could take weeks or months.

Eisenkot leads the Yashar Party, formed only last year, and is the main figure in what is called the change bloc. Its members disagree on a lot but share the aim of removing Netanyahu. They include two former right-wingers with hardline security views, ex-prime minister Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Lieberman, along with Yair Golan, a left-leaning former general. Netanyahu, who first became prime minister in 1996, needs to rebuild his current coalition of far-right and ultra-Orthodox parties, the most right-wing government in Israel's history.

About a fifth of Israelis are Arab, and many describe themselves as Palestinian citizens of Israel. Two Arab party blocs are running, and on paper they could decide who governs. But all but one of the leading Jewish parties have ruled out working with them. Some have speculated that Arab parties might informally prop up a minority government led by Eisenkot, yet Lieberman, a key prospective partner, has said he will not take part in such an arrangement.

Security has shaped the campaign. The opposition has pressed Netanyahu over the failure that allowed the 7 October Hamas-led attacks, in which nearly 1,200 people were killed and 251 taken to Gaza as hostages. It wants an independent commission of inquiry, which Netanyahu has resisted for years, arguing it would be biased against him. Opponents also cite threats to democracy: his ongoing corruption trial, which he denies, and his continued push for judicial reforms that drew mass protests before 7 October. A further flashpoint is conscription. His government has not enforced a Supreme Court ruling that ultra-Orthodox men in full-time religious study must be drafted, while thousands of others have been called up for recent wars.

Netanyahu has again cast himself as "Mr Security", pointing to strategic wins in Israel's regional wars and his close tie to US President Donald Trump. In the final days, Israel's Channel 12 reported that he had pushed for military action that might provoke a confrontation with Iran before the vote, and that his military chief Eyal Zamir opposed it. CNN then reported that he had tried to get Trump to approve new strikes on Iran and been refused. Netanyahu denied both reports. He also posted an AI-generated image of a nuclear bomb hitting Tel Aviv, saying only he could protect Israel if Iran obtained nuclear weapons. Eisenkot called him "hysterical".

On Gaza, Eisenkot's position is broadly similar to Netanyahu's. He has pledged to end Hamas rule within 18 months, through a US-led peace plan or by force if necessary. Israel has struck the territory almost daily since last year's ceasefire, saying it targets Hamas operatives. Eisenkot largely backs West Bank settlements, which are illegal under international law, but wants to act against extremist settlers, whose attacks are at a record high according to UN figures. He has spoken of "autonomy or a state-minus" for Palestinians under ultimate Israeli security control. The two-state solution has all but vanished from mainstream Israeli politics.

Exit polls will be published by Israeli broadcasters at 22:00 local time (20:00 GMT) on Tuesday, though they can be well off the final result. Likud will gather in Jerusalem and Yashar in Tel Aviv. Votes from hundreds of thousands of soldiers and reservists will mostly not be counted until Wednesday, a delay that may help right-wing parties, which are thought to be strong with that group.

The race is often framed as Eisenkot against Netanyahu, but another leader could take the top job by withholding their party's support from a coalition unless given it. The outcome many dread is deadlock: no bloc reaching a majority and no minority government possible. That would mean fresh elections, with Netanyahu staying on as interim prime minister. Israel held five elections between 2019 and 2022 as parties repeatedly failed to cooperate.

Eisenkot called Netanyahu's AI-generated image of a nuclear bomb striking Tel Aviv "hysterical".
— Gadi Eisenkot
Netanyahu denied reports that he pushed for pre-election action against Iran.
— Benjamin Netanyahu
Quer a matéria completa? Leia o original em BBC News ↗
Fale Conosco FAQ