Three years after Hamas gunmen crossed into southern Israel on the morning of October 7, 2023 — killing more than 1,200 people and seizing 251 hostages in the deadliest day in Israeli history — the nation paused again at 6:29 in the morning to hold its grief in silence. Across more than 400 memorial sites, survivors and bereaved families gathered not only to mourn but to demand answers, pressing for a formal state inquiry that Prime Minister Netanyahu has resisted throughout three years of war. With elections just weeks away and allegations surfacing that advance warnings went unheeded, the an
Israel marks three years since October 7 with nationwide memorials amid calls for accountability
Three years of loss and pain. Three years of a basic demand for accountability.
What does a state commission of inquiry actually do? Why is it so important that families keep asking for one?
It's the most powerful investigative mechanism in Israeli law. It can examine national-level disasters and the decisions that led to them. It has real authority. For three years, families have been asking for one because they want to know what happened, what warnings were missed, what decisions failed. Right now there's no official investigation with that kind of power.
But we should note—Netanyahu has resisted it, but we don't have a detailed public accounting of exactly what he's said his reasons are. The reporting tells us he's resisted; it doesn't tell us his stated justification.
The article mentions warnings from the UAE and Egypt. How solid is that?
Those are media reports, not confirmed findings. The reporting says "preliminary warnings allegedly received." So it's in the public conversation now, especially because it's an election year, but it's not established fact.
Right. And that's important because it shapes the political narrative. If those warnings are confirmed, it changes the accountability question entirely. If they're not, it's a different story.
What about the scale of what happened? 1,200 killed, 251 taken hostage—does that number sit in context for people in Israel?
It's described as the deadliest single day in Israeli history. So yes, it's unprecedented for them. But the war that followed has killed over 73,000 Palestinians in Gaza. Both numbers matter.
And that's where the story gets complicated. The memorial is about October 7 specifically, but the war's consequences are much larger. The reporting holds both, which is right, but it's worth naming that tension.
The election is three weeks away. Is accountability actually going to shift votes?
It's become a central campaign issue, which means it matters to voters. Netanyahu's challengers are using the anniversary to press their case. Whether it changes the outcome—that's still unknown.
We should be careful not to assume the election outcome. The reporting shows accountability is a campaign issue; it doesn't tell us how decisive it will be.
Il Polso
- At the exact minute the attack began three years ago, Israel fell silent — a nation still carrying wounds that have not closed and questions that have not been answered.
- More than 400 grassroots ceremonies erupted across the country, organized not by the government but by survivors, victims' families, and protest movements demanding accountability from the ground up.
- Reports that Israel received advance warnings from the UAE and Egypt before the attack have sharpened public fury and given Netanyahu's political rivals fresh ammunition just weeks before elections.
- Netanyahu has blocked a state commission of inquiry for three years, and his opponents — including a challenger whose own son died in Gaza — are using the anniversary to argue he is hiding from the truth.
- With elections set for October 27, the commemoration has transformed into a campaign battleground, where grief and political reckoning are now inseparable.
Three years after Hamas gunmen crossed into southern Israel on the morning of October 7, 2023 — killing more than 1,200 people and seizing 251 hostages in the deadliest day in Israeli history — the nation paused again at 6:29 in the morning to hold its grief in silence. Across more than 400 memorial sites, survivors and bereaved families gathered not only to mourn but to demand answers, pressing for a formal state inquiry that Prime Minister Netanyahu has resisted throughout three years of war. With elections just weeks away and allegations surfacing that advance warnings went unheeded, the anniversary has become something larger than remembrance — a reckoning with the question of who bears responsibility when a nation fails to protect its own.
At 6:29 on the morning of October 7, 2023, Hamas-led gunmen crossed into Israeli communities along the Gaza border and killed more than 1,200 people — children, elderly, entire families — in the deadliest single day in the country's history. Two hundred and fifty-one others were taken hostage into Gaza. Three years later, Israel stopped at that same moment for a national silence, with ceremonies unfolding at more than 400 locations. At the Nova festival site in the Re'im Forest, where over 370 people were murdered, mourners gathered alongside protest convoys moving through the streets.
Most of the day's events were organized not by the state but by survivors and victims' families — groups like the October Council and the Kumu movement, which hosted a national memorial in Tel Aviv that evening attended by tens of thousands. A single demand ran through all of it: establish a state commission of inquiry, the most powerful investigative tool in Israeli law. For three years, Prime Minister Netanyahu had refused. He had appointed no special inquiry into what went wrong.
Shir Mathias, whose parents were killed in Kibbutz Holit, called publicly for new leadership. Einav Zangauker, mother of a freed hostage and one of the government's most vocal critics, wrote of three years of loss and a basic demand for accountability. Their voices joined a growing chorus shaped by recent media reports alleging that Israel had received advance warnings from the UAE and Egypt before the attack.
The anniversary arrived less than three weeks before October 27 elections, where accountability has become a defining issue. Netanyahu's main challenger, Gadi Eisenkot — whose own son was killed in Gaza — accused the prime minister of running from the truth. Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett spent the day visiting border communities. Netanyahu, for his part, spoke of the attack as something seared into the nation even as he signaled the war was not over, claiming thousands of October 7 militants had been killed with more still to be found. Since the war began, more than 73,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza. Three years of memorials, three years of unanswered questions — and now three weeks for voters to decide whether to demand a reckoning.
At 6:29 on the morning of October 7, 2023, Hamas-led gunmen crossed into Israeli communities along the Gaza border and killed more than 1,200 people in what became the deadliest single day in the country's history. They took 251 hostages into the enclave. The dead included children, women, elderly people, and entire families. Three years later, on October 7, 2026, Israel stopped at that same moment—6:29 in the morning—for a national silence. Across the country, at more than 400 locations, ceremonies and memorials began. By noon, bereaved families and grassroots protest groups held a minute of reflection, joined by hospitals, municipalities, universities, and businesses. At the Nova festival site in the Re'im Forest, where over 370 people were murdered and 44 were abducted, mourners gathered. Protest convoys and displays moved through the streets all day.
Shir Mathias, whose parents Shachar and Shlomi were killed during the attack on Kibbutz Holit, used the anniversary to call for political change. "Everyone who had their hand on the wheel, those in uniforms and suits alike—must go home," she wrote on social media, urging Israelis to demand new leadership. That evening, a national memorial ceremony in Tel Aviv drew tens of thousands, organized by the Kumu movement, which represents survivors and victims' families, and hosted by former hostage Eli Sharabi and actress Shani Cohen.
The official state memorials had taken place on Monday. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spoke of the attack as something that remained "seared within us" even as the state grew stronger. But at a cabinet meeting the following day, he signaled that the war was far from over. He claimed Israel had killed "4,000 out of 6,000" militants who infiltrated on October 7, 2023, and said, "We will reach all of them." Israeli strikes in Gaza continued nearly every day. Since the war began, more than 73,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza, according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health.
Unlike the official ceremonies, most of Wednesday's events were organized from the ground up—by survivors, by families of the dead, by groups like the October Council and Kumu. A demand ran through all of them: establish a state commission of inquiry, the most powerful investigative tool in Israeli law, capable of examining national disasters and the decisions that preceded them. For three years, Netanyahu had resisted such calls. He had appointed no special inquiry to investigate what went wrong that day.
Einav Zangauker, mother of freed hostage Matan Zangauker and one of the government's most vocal critics, wrote on social media: "Three years since the day that changed my life and our lives as a people. Three years of loss and pain. Three years of a basic demand for accountability." She spoke for those who were lost, those who returned changed, and for a country that she said deserved hope and repair.
The timing of the anniversary was not incidental. Elections were scheduled for October 27—less than three weeks away—and accountability had become a central campaign issue. Netanyahu's rivals seized on the moment. Gadi Eisenkot, polling as Netanyahu's main challenger, called the failure "very deep" and accused the prime minister of dodging the inquiry. "Netanyahu knows better than anyone why he is running from the truth, why he wants to bury the truth," Eisenkot said at a recent conference. His own son had been killed in Gaza during the war. He and former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, another Netanyahu rival, spent the day visiting communities along the Gaza border.
The political pressure had sharpened in recent weeks after media reports alleged that Israel had received preliminary warnings from the United Arab Emirates and Egypt before the attack. The anniversary had become a focal point for challengers to press their case that the government had failed in its most fundamental duty: to protect its people. Three years of memorials, three years of unanswered questions, and now three weeks until voters would decide whether to demand a reckoning.
Citazioni salienti
Everyone who had their hand on the wheel, those in uniforms and suits alike—must go home.— Shir Mathias, whose parents were killed during the October 7 attack
Three years of loss and pain. Three years of a basic demand for accountability.— Einav Zangauker, mother of freed hostage Matan Zangauker