Far east of Jerusalem, on land that has waited more than twenty years for a decision, a stretch of open ground is moving from paper toward machinery. Israel's tender for the E1 project opens the door for developers to bid, and critics see in its geography a corridor that could sever the West Bank and make a contiguous Palestinian state hard to imagine. The same week brought a fragile contrast from Gaza, where food stocks had reached the level needed to meet minimum calorie standards for the first time in over two years, even as the flow of aid that would turn that stock into survival remained
Israel Advances E1 Settlement Tender That Critics Say Would Split the West Bank in Two
Another nail in the coffin of this dangerous idea
Why does a tender for one tract of land east of Jerusalem matter so much?
Because of where it sits. E1 runs from Jerusalem's outskirts deep into the West Bank, and critics say that would cut the territory in two and rule out a contiguous Palestinian state.
It's been discussed for over twenty years. What changed?
It was frozen under pressure from earlier US administrations. Israel gave final approval in August, and now the tender lets developers bid.
Careful with the timeline, though. The claim that work could start by the end of the month comes from Peace Now's Yoni Mizrahi. It's an anti-settlement monitor's reading, not a confirmed construction date.
Fair. But Smotrich has been open about his goals.
Very. He said the Palestinian state is being erased from the table with actions, and called each housing unit a nail in the coffin of the idea.
That's his stated intent, and it's on the record. What the reporting doesn't give us is how many units, which developers, or any Israeli government response to the monitor's account.
And Gaza appears in the same report. How does it connect?
Mostly as a parallel story about what Israel permits. The UN says January is the first round since October 2023 with enough stock to meet the full minimum caloric standard.
Yet the EU's Kallas is still urging Israel to lift restrictions to prevent deaths. The report doesn't say how much aid is entering, so enough stock on hand doesn't prove people are being reached.
The Pulse
- A tender notice has opened the way for developers to bid on E1, and monitors warn that bulldozers could arrive before the end of January.
- A stretch of land stalled for two decades under US pressure now looks set to move quickly, shifting the balance of a long-frozen dispute.
- Critics say the project's route from Jerusalem deep into the West Bank would cut the territory in two and block a contiguous Palestinian state.
- Finance Minister Smotrich, who has openly framed E1 as a blow to the idea of a Palestinian state, sits at the center of the push.
- In Gaza, food stocks have reached the minimum calorie level for the first time since the war began, yet the EU is urging Israel to lift aid restrictions before exposure, hunger and lack of medicine claim more lives among returning displaced families.
Far east of Jerusalem, on land that has waited more than twenty years for a decision, a stretch of open ground is moving from paper toward machinery. Israel's tender for the E1 project opens the door for developers to bid, and critics see in its geography a corridor that could sever the West Bank and make a contiguous Palestinian state hard to imagine. The same week brought a fragile contrast from Gaza, where food stocks had reached the level needed to meet minimum calorie standards for the first time in over two years, even as the flow of aid that would turn that stock into survival remained contested. Together these moments show how the question of land and the question of bread often arrive in the same news cycle, each asking whether promises made on paper will be honored on the ground.
A tender notice has gone out for open land east of Jerusalem, and Peace Now, the anti-settlement monitor, says it could mean construction machinery on the site by the end of January. The project, known as E1, has been discussed for more than twenty years and was held back for much of that time by pressure from earlier US administrations. Now, with the tender published, the freeze appears to have given way to a faster effort.
The heart of the dispute is geography. E1 would stretch from the edge of Jerusalem deep into the occupied West Bank, and critics argue it would split the territory in two and prevent a contiguous Palestinian state. Most of the international community considers Israeli settlement building in the West Bank illegal and an obstacle to peace.
The project's strongest advocate is Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who oversees settlement policy. When final approval was granted last August, he described the plan as a way of erasing the Palestinian state from the table through action rather than slogans.
The settlement news came alongside a difficult picture in Gaza. The UN said aid groups now hold enough food to meet the full minimum calorie standard for the first time since the war began. Yet the source reports that Israel has restricted the flow of humanitarian aid despite commitments in the October 10 ceasefire. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas urged Israel to lift those limits, warning of deaths from exposure, hunger and lack of medicine as displaced Palestinians return to ruined homes.
The coming weeks will show whether the tender becomes construction, and how governments that consider settlements illegal respond if work begins.
A tender notice has gone out for a stretch of open land east of Jerusalem, and the group that tracks such things says it could mean bulldozers by the end of January. Yoni Mizrahi, who runs the settlement watch division at the anti-settlement monitor Peace Now, said the new process opens the way for developers to submit bids on what is known as the E1 project.
E1 is not a new idea. The plan has been under consideration for more than two decades, and for much of that time it sat frozen, held back by pressure from previous US administrations. The tender suggests that the freeze has now given way to something faster. Peace Now describes the publication of the tender as reflecting an accelerated effort to advance construction in E1.
The location is the heart of the dispute. The project would run from the outskirts of Jerusalem deep into the occupied West Bank. Critics argue that this geography would effectively cut the territory in two, and that it would prevent the establishment of a contiguous Palestinian state. The international community overwhelmingly regards Israeli settlement construction in the West Bank as illegal and as an obstacle to peace.
The plan's most prominent champion is Bezalel Smotrich, Israel's far-right Finance Minister, who oversees settlement policy and has long pushed for E1 to become real. When Israel gave final approval to the plan in August of last year, he was explicit about what he saw it accomplishing. The Palestinian state, he said, was being erased from the table not with slogans but with actions. Every settlement, every neighbourhood and every housing unit, he said, was another nail in the coffin of what he called a dangerous idea.
The settlement news arrived alongside developments in Gaza. On Tuesday, the United Nations said aid groups now have enough food on hand to sustain people in the enclave for the first time since the war began more than two years ago. UN spokesperson Stephane Dujarric said the January round was the first since October 2023 in which partners had sufficient stock to meet 100 per cent of the minimum caloric standard.
That milestone sits uneasily beside the account of what has been allowed in. The Israelis have restricted the flow of much-needed humanitarian aid into Gaza despite commitments made in the ceasefire agreement that took effect on October 10, according to the source reporting. On Tuesday the European Union's foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, called on Israel to lift the restrictions to avert deaths from exposure, hunger and a lack of medicines, as thousands of displaced Palestinians return to what is left of their homes.
In a statement on behalf of the 27-nation bloc, Kallas said that to deliver aid rapidly, safely and at the required scale, international NGOs must be able to operate in a sustained and predictable way.
What to watch now is whether the tender actually turns into construction before the month is out, as Peace Now warns it might, and how governments that call settlements illegal respond once work on E1 begins.
Notable Quotes
The Palestinian state is being erased from the table not with slogans but with actions.— Bezalel Smotrich, Israeli Finance Minister, August
International NGOs must be able to operate in a sustained and predictable way.— Kaja Kallas, EU foreign policy chief