Israel admits firing on car killing 5-year-old Hind Rajab, orders criminal probe

Five-year-old Hind Rajab and six family members killed in car attack; two paramedics killed in ambulance strike; 15 medics and humanitarian workers killed in Rafah incident; seven World Central Kitchen aid workers killed in airstrikes.
Ambulances 101 is not a target and they must be protected
A Palestinian paramedic who survived the Rafah shooting that killed fifteen of his colleagues speaks to what should be protected in conflict.
Mark

Why did it take more than two years for the military to admit what happened to Hind Rajab?

Mimi

The initial denial appears to have been tactical—claiming troops weren't in the area. Once investigations by journalists and others gathered enough evidence, that story became untenable. The admission came only when the cost of continuing to deny it exceeded the cost of acknowledging it.

Mark

What changes with a criminal investigation that didn't exist before?

Mimi

Technically, it opens the possibility of prosecution. But the pattern is clear: investigations rarely lead to convictions. It's a process that can look like accountability without necessarily delivering it.

Mark

Why did the military decide not to investigate the World Central Kitchen strikes?

Mimi

They argued the convoy deviated from the coordinated route and that soldiers mistook people for armed operatives. But the organization had coordinated with the military, the vehicles were marked, and the strikes were multiple and sustained. The decision not to investigate suggests the military found no criminal misconduct worth pursuing.

Mark

What does a "pervasive climate of impunity" actually mean in practice?

Mimi

It means that even when evidence is clear, even when incidents are documented, the likelihood of accountability is low. Soldiers know this. Commanders know this. It changes behavior.

Mark

Is there any indication this will change?

Mimi

The UN report used strong language. International pressure exists. But the military's statement frames these incidents as inevitable consequences of complex combat. Without external enforcement mechanisms, the pattern is unlikely to shift.

  • For over two years, Hind Rajab's name circled the world while the military that killed her insisted its soldiers were nowhere near — that denial has now formally collapsed.
  • The admission extends to the ambulance sent to rescue her: two paramedics who stayed on the line with Hind until they could reach her were killed in a second strike, their deaths now also acknowledged.
  • A criminal investigation into the killing of fifteen medics near Rafah — whose bodies and vehicles were buried by bulldozer in a mass grave — has been opened, but the sole survivor's hope for justice runs against a decade-long pattern of investigations that almost never yield convictions.
  • The military declined to prosecute in the deaths of seven World Central Kitchen workers and four Doctors Without Borders staff, concluding commanders showed no criminal misconduct despite striking clearly marked humanitarian vehicles in broad visibility.
  • Researchers and UN investigators warn that political pressure and a documented culture of impunity mean these investigations, however formally launched, may follow the same path as those before them — closing without consequence.

More than two years after a five-year-old girl named Hind Rajab spent her final hours calling for help from the wreckage of a car in Gaza City, the Israeli military has acknowledged what it long denied: its troops fired on the vehicle carrying her and six family members. The admission, released in August 2026 alongside a broader review of high-profile civilian casualty incidents, arrives in a conflict that has now claimed more than 73,000 lives in Gaza — and it arrives alongside decisions not to prosecute in several other cases, including the killing of seven clearly marked aid workers. Accountability, as it so often does in war, remains a question the living are left to answer for the dead.

On a Wednesday in August 2026, the Israeli military ended more than two years of denial, confirming that its troops had fired on a white car carrying five-year-old Hind Rajab and six members of her family as they fled Gaza City in January 2024. All seven were killed. But Hind did not die immediately — for three hours she remained alive in the wreckage, calling the Palestinian Red Crescent, pleading for rescue. Paramedics stayed on the line with her. When an ambulance finally attempted to reach her, it too was struck. Two medics died. The bodies were not recovered for twelve days, after Israeli forces withdrew.

The military's statement, which announced a criminal investigation into Hind's killing, was part of a broader review of five high-profile incidents involving civilian deaths. In one, the military said it would also investigate the killing of fifteen Palestinian medics and humanitarian workers near Rafah in March 2025. According to the sole survivor and phone footage, soldiers lying in ambush had opened fire on a slow-moving ambulance convoy — emergency lights flashing, logos clearly visible — and afterward used a bulldozer to bury the bodies and vehicles in a mass grave. The military's initial claim that the vehicles had been advancing suspiciously without lights or markings fell apart when footage contradicted it directly. Paramedic Munther Abed, who survived and lost fifteen colleagues, said he hoped those responsible would face justice.

But the review also contained decisions not to prosecute. The military concluded no criminal investigation was warranted in the April 2024 airstrikes that killed seven World Central Kitchen workers in clearly marked vehicles, saying commanders had mistaken them for armed operatives and that the convoy had deviated from a coordinated route. Two officers were removed; three were reprimanded. World Central Kitchen rejected the account entirely, stating the military had full visual clarity on their humanitarian vehicles throughout the strikes. The military similarly declined to pursue criminal action over the deaths of four Doctors Without Borders workers — an organization Israel later effectively barred from operating in Gaza.

The pattern is not new. Researchers at Yesh Din note that over the past decade, only a tiny fraction of investigations into Israeli military conduct have led to indictments, and that growing political pressure further discourages accountability even when evidence is clear. A UN report from February described a pervasive climate of impunity in relation to violations that may constitute war crimes. The war, which began in October 2023, has killed more than 73,000 people in Gaza — mostly women and children — and since a fragile ceasefire took effect in October 2025, more than 1,200 additional Palestinians have been killed.

On a Wednesday in August 2026, the Israeli military released a statement acknowledging what it had denied for more than two years: its troops had fired on a white Kia Picanto carrying a five-year-old girl named Hind Rajab and six members of her family as they tried to escape Gaza City in January 2024. The admission came with an announcement that the military would open a criminal investigation into the killing.

Hind's death had become one of the most visible casualties of the early months of the Gaza conflict, a name that circled the world. On January 29, 2024, as Israeli forces launched a new offensive into Gaza City, the Rajab family attempted to flee. The car was struck. All seven occupants were killed. But Hind's death was not immediate. For three hours, she remained alive in the wreckage, calling the Palestinian Red Crescent on her phone, pleading for someone to come and rescue her. Paramedics stayed on the line with her, listening, unable to reach her in time. When an ambulance finally attempted to get to her, it too came under fire. Two medics were killed in that strike. The bodies of everyone in the car—Hind and her six relatives—were not recovered until twelve days later, after Israeli troops had withdrawn from the area.

For years, the Israeli Defense Forces had insisted its soldiers were not in the vicinity when the car was hit. Journalists and investigators had gathered evidence suggesting otherwise: nearby Israeli tanks appeared to be responsible. The military's Wednesday statement effectively ended that denial. It also confirmed that troops had fired on the ambulance.

The acknowledgment of Hind's death was part of a broader review the military released that day, examining four other high-profile incidents involving civilian casualties. In one case, the military announced it would launch a criminal investigation into the killing of fifteen Palestinian medics and humanitarian workers near Rafah in March 2025. According to phone footage and accounts from the sole survivor, Israeli troops lying in ambush for Hamas militants had opened fire on an ambulance attempting to retrieve casualties from an Israeli offensive. As more emergency vehicles approached, soldiers fired on them repeatedly. Afterward, troops used a bulldozer to bury the bodies and vehicles in a mass grave. UN and rescue workers did not reach the site for a week. The military initially claimed the vehicles were advancing suspiciously without headlights or emergency signals. That account collapsed when footage emerged showing the Red Crescent and civil defence teams driving slowly, emergency lights flashing, logos clearly visible on their vehicles. Munther Abed, a Palestinian paramedic who survived the shooting and lost fifteen colleagues, said he hoped those responsible would face justice. "I want to say to the whole world, ambulances 101 is not a target and they must be protected," he said, referring to the speed dial number for the Red Crescent service.

But the military's review also contained decisions not to prosecute. It announced it would not open a criminal investigation into airstrikes in April 2024 that killed seven humanitarian workers from World Central Kitchen, a US-based aid organization. The vehicles, clearly marked with the group's logo and visible from the air, had been hit in a series of strikes that left them incinerated and mangled. The military said it had mistaken individuals in the vehicles for armed Hamas operatives and that the convoy had deviated from a previously coordinated route. It concluded that "the decisions of the commanders did not raise reasonable suspicion of criminal misconduct." Two officers were removed from their positions; three others were reprimanded. Among the dead was Zomi Frankcom, an Australian aid worker. The Australian government called the deaths a tragedy and an outrage, pressing for accountability. World Central Kitchen rejected the military's account entirely. "There has never been any excuse or justification for the attacks," the organization said. "At the time of the lethal attacks, the IDF knew that our team in Gaza was unarmed and posing a threat to nobody. It had full visual clarity on our clearly marked humanitarian vehicles during the extended, multiple airstrikes."

The military also declined to pursue criminal action in the deaths of four humanitarian workers from Doctors Without Borders, killed in two separate incidents in November 2023 and February 2024. Israel later effectively barred the medical charity from operating in Gaza.

Historically, investigations into Israeli military conduct over the killing of Palestinians have rarely resulted in convictions. Dan Owen, a researcher at Yesh Din, an Israeli rights organization, noted that over the past decade only a tiny fraction of investigations had led to indictments. Growing political pressure, he said, further discouraged Israeli law enforcement from holding those responsible accountable, even when clear evidence existed. A UN report published in February had described "a pervasive climate of impunity" by Israel in occupied Palestine in relation to gross violations of human rights law and serious violations of humanitarian law, some potentially constituting war crimes.

The military said it examined "exceptional incidents that occurred during combat" as part of its obligations under international law and Israeli domestic law. "For more than a thousand days, the IDF has been conducting intensive combat across numerous fronts, carrying out a wide range of military missions in an exceptionally complex operational reality," it said. The war that began in October 2023 with a Hamas attack killing 1,200 people in southern Israel has, according to current counts, killed more than 73,000 in Gaza, mostly women and children. Since a fragile ceasefire took effect in October 2025, more than 1,200 additional Palestinians have been killed.

There has never been any excuse or justification for the attacks. At the time of the lethal attacks, the IDF knew that our team in Gaza was unarmed and posing a threat to nobody.
— World Central Kitchen, in response to military decision not to prosecute World Central Kitchen strikes
I want to say to the whole world, ambulances 101 is not a target and they must be protected.
— Munther Abed, Palestinian paramedic who survived the Rafah incident
Contact Us FAQ