A minister in Jakarta has claimed that some of the liquefied natural gas Indonesia ships to Singapore is being quietly resold abroad, a charge offered without evidence or a stated time frame. It arrives amid a smaller but real squeeze on pipeline gas and older quarrels over haze and contracts, the kind of friction that neighbours with tightly knotted energy and investment ties have always had to absorb. For now the wider tone is one of managed restraint, with officials on both sides reaching for diplomacy rather than retaliation, though whether that patience will outlast the cargoes and the sm
Indonesia Accuses Singapore of Reselling LNG as Officials Urge Calm Over Gas and Haze Tensions
Not all of the 148 cargoes, he believes, stay in Singapore.
Why does a claim about LNG resales matter so much right now?
Because it arrives days after Indonesia trimmed pipeline gas to Singapore. Bahlil is suggesting Singapore doesn't need all the gas it gets, which cuts against the idea that the reductions hurt.
But he gave no evidence and no time period. Right now it's a belief, stated by a minister, not an established fact.
Is reselling LNG wrong?
Not inherently. It depends on what the supply agreements allow, and the reporting doesn't say what these contracts permit.
Right, so we can't say whether anything improper happened. We only know the allegation was made.
How big was the pipeline cut?
Singapore's Energy Market Authority says 17 billion BTU a day over 18 days, under 2 per cent of daily demand. Indonesia's regulator framed it as 31 million standard cubic feet per day.
Those are two sources using different units and framings. The 17 billion figure comes from importers via Singapore's authority, so it's one side's accounting.
And the calmer voices?
Rosan, Luhut, Shinta and Meutya all urged restraint, and a joint haze task force was agreed.
Worth noting that's de-escalation in words and one agreement. Whether gas or investment actually changes is unknown.
Der Puls
- Indonesia's energy minister alleges Singapore re-exports some of 148 LNG cargoes, offering no proof and no timeframe.
- Jakarta trimmed pipeline gas to Singapore by 17 billion BTU a day over 18 days, a cut under 2 per cent of demand, and insists contracts were respected.
- Prime Minister Wong's demand that commitments be honoured drew a sharp reply that Indonesia should not be lectured on contracts.
- Ministers in Jakarta are pulling the temperature down, with investment commitments declared intact and a joint haze task force agreed.
- The dispute is landing in diplomacy, but the gas flows and Singapore's US$17.4 billion investment stake remain exposed to any further escalation.
A minister in Jakarta has claimed that some of the liquefied natural gas Indonesia ships to Singapore is being quietly resold abroad, a charge offered without evidence or a stated time frame. It arrives amid a smaller but real squeeze on pipeline gas and older quarrels over haze and contracts, the kind of friction that neighbours with tightly knotted energy and investment ties have always had to absorb. For now the wider tone is one of managed restraint, with officials on both sides reaching for diplomacy rather than retaliation, though whether that patience will outlast the cargoes and the smoke remains an open question.
On October 29, Bahlil Lahadalia left the Presidential Palace in Jakarta and told reporters that Singapore may be reselling some of the 148 LNG cargoes it has taken from Indonesia. He gave no evidence and no time period for the claim. Trading LNG onward is not improper in itself, but it depends on the terms of each supply agreement, and the accusation has landed in a moment already crowded with grievances.
The larger quarrel began with pipeline gas. On October 24, Indonesia started cutting exports to Singapore to free up supply for its own power plants in Batam, Bintan and Sumatra. Singapore's regulator later measured the reduction at 17 billion British thermal units a day over 18 days, a little under 2 per cent of its daily demand. Jakarta says it has stayed above the minimum volumes in its contracts, and Bahlil has said there are no immediate plans to cut LNG exports, though domestic needs will come first.
Words have been sharp. Prime Minister Lawrence Wong asked that commercial commitments be honoured, and Bahlil answered that Indonesia had met its obligations and did not need lessons on contracts. Other voices have tried to lower the heat. Investment Minister Rosan Roeslani said Singapore's investment commitments remain intact, and welcomed Singapore's summoning of executives from 10 companies over possible links to haze. Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan asked why the two countries would fight at all, and Communications Minister Meutya Hafid urged restraint after a Singapore commentator raised the prospect of cutting internet links, pointing out that much of Singapore's undersea cable traffic runs through Indonesian waters.
Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan's visit from October 27 to 29 produced a joint haze task force and a meeting with President Prabowo. Whether these steps hold, and whether gas and investment ties keep their steadiness, is what both capitals will be watching next.
On Oct 29, Bahlil Lahadalia walked out of the Presidential Palace in Jakarta after a meeting with President Prabowo Subianto and told reporters what he believed about Singapore's gas imports. Indonesia has shipped 148 cargoes of liquefied natural gas to the city-state, he said, and not all of them are being used there. Some, in his view, are traded and then exported on to other countries.
Bahlil is Coordinating Minister for Downstreaming and Energy Transition, Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, and chairman of the Golkar Party. He offered no evidence for the claim and did not say over what period the 148 cargoes were shipped. His remarks concerned LNG moved by sea, which is separate from the pipeline gas that flows to Singapore from Indonesia's Natuna and Sumatra fields. Trading and re-exporting LNG is not inherently improper, though such deals are bound by the terms of the supply agreements behind them.
The accusation lands in the middle of a dispute over pipeline gas. On Oct 24, Indonesia began cutting its pipeline exports to Singapore, citing domestic energy needs. The upstream regulator SKK Migas announced reductions totalling 31 million standard cubic feet per day, with the gas redirected to power generation in Batam, Bintan and Sumatra. Singapore's Energy Market Authority later put the actual cut, based on information from importers, at 17 billion British thermal units per day over 18 days, less than 2 per cent of Singapore's daily gas demand.
Bahlil said Indonesia has not breached its agreements, because the reduced deliveries remain above the minimum supply limits in existing contracts. He added that Jakarta has no immediate plans to reduce LNG exports to Singapore, though it will keep putting domestic demand first.
Contracts were already a point of friction. On Oct 25, Prime Minister Lawrence Wong said Singapore expected parties to honour their commercial commitments. Bahlil replied on Oct 26 that Indonesia had met its obligations and should not be lectured about respecting contracts.
Other Indonesian figures have worked to lower the temperature. Investment Minister Rosan Roeslani said on Oct 29 that Singapore's investment commitments remain intact despite the disagreements over haze and gas. He welcomed Singapore's decision to summon executives from 10 companies over possible links to the haze, calling it a positive step toward tackling forest fires. He said he had met Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan during the latter's Jakarta visit and that both sides reaffirmed their commitment to investment cooperation. Singapore has been Indonesia's largest source of foreign direct investment since 2014, with US$17.4 billion (S$22.3 billion) in 2025.
Shinta Kamdani, deputy chairman of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry and chair of the Indonesian Employers Association, said she was confident Prabowo's meeting with Balakrishnan a day earlier would lead to a solution. She had seen no decline in Singaporean interest in the real economy, she said, though tensions could affect financial market sentiment.
On Oct 27, National Economic Council chairman Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan asked why Indonesia would fight with Singapore, saying there was no reason to; he had spoken with Bahlil about the matter. Communications and Digital Affairs Minister Meutya Hafid called for restraint after former Singapore nominated MP Calvin Cheng suggested Singapore could cut Indonesia's internet connectivity. She noted that much of Singapore's submarine cable connectivity passes through Indonesian waters, and said digital infrastructure should be protected jointly.
During Balakrishnan's Oct 27 to 29 visit, the two countries agreed to set up a joint task force on haze to strengthen information-sharing and enforcement cooperation. What to watch now is whether that task force and the leaders' talks hold, and whether gas and investment ties stay steady.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
I believe that not all of the 148 cargoes we send are used for Singapore's own needs, but some are traded and subsequently exported to other countries.— Bahlil Lahadalia, Indonesian energy minister
Why would we fight with Singapore? There's no reason to.— Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan, National Economic Council chairman