INDIA Bloc Postpones 'Public Impeachment' of CEC Gyanesh Kumar to October 31 Over Rain

The rain moved the date; the demand for Kumar's removal stayed where it was.
The bloc kept the format and venue and shifted its symbolic impeachment of the CEC by one day.
Mark

Why does a rain delay matter enough to be news?

Mimi

Mostly it shows how the event is built. It's an outdoor gathering of senior leaders at Kharge's home, and Rahul Gandhi said they didn't want seniors sitting in the rain.

Mark

And the venue wasn't the first choice.

Mimi

No. They tried the Constitution Club of India and Talkatora Stadium and didn't get them. Congress said on Tuesday that it was denied permission.

Mark

So what is a 'public impeachment' actually?

Luke

Symbolic is the key word. The source describes it as a protest expression, not a legal process. The motion would be adopted by the bloc itself.

Mimi

Right, Meira Kumar chairs, Kharge introduces the motion, Rahul Gandhi closes.

Mark

Rahul Gandhi accuses Modi, Shah and Kumar of demolishing democracy. Is that established?

Luke

No, that's his characterisation. The same goes for 'vote chori'. The report calls it alleged, and nothing here proves it.

Mark

What is the one independent fact underneath?

Mimi

The Indian Express report last month of a rift in the poll panel, with Commissioners Sandhu and Joshi objecting to the SIR.

Luke

Though I'd note that the report 'indicated' a rift. We don't have their objections in detail here, and the Election Commission's response isn't included.

Mark

And the timing?

Luke

Saturday is reported via sources, though Gandhi himself said 'tomorrow.' That part is firm.

  • Rain forced the bloc to push its symbolic impeachment of the Chief Election Commissioner back a single day, to Saturday October 31.
  • The venue itself is a fallback: after the Constitution Club and Talkatora Stadium fell through, and permission was reportedly denied, the bloc settled on Kharge's residence.
  • Rahul Gandhi accuses Modi, Amit Shah and Kumar of 'demolishing' democracy, while the bloc was denied an audience with the Chief Justice.
  • Meira Kumar will chair the session, Kharge will move the motion, and Gandhi will deliver closing remarks before adoption.
  • All eyes now turn to the November 1 Ramlila Maidan march, the real test of whether the opposition can draw people beyond its own party ranks.

On a rain-soaked Friday in Delhi, the opposition INDIA bloc found its carefully planned act of protest slipping out of its grasp, and so it moved the symbolic 'public impeachment' of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar to Saturday, October 31, at the Delhi residence of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge. The gesture belongs to a longer and quieter human struggle over who speaks for the voter, and whether the institutions that count votes can still be trusted to count them fairly. Set against a dispute over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls and accusations of 'vote chori,' the postponement reads less as a mere scheduling change than as a test of whether a coalition of parties can turn grievance into a public gathering.

Rain over Delhi on Friday forced the INDIA bloc to change its plans. The planned 'public impeachment' of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, due at Mallikarjun Kharge's residence on Rajaji Marg, has moved to Saturday, October 31. Rahul Gandhi explained that the bloc chose by consensus to hold the same programme at the same time, since it would be uncomfortable for senior leaders to sit through the rain.

The venue was never the first choice. The bloc had tried the Constitution Club of India and Talkatora Stadium, and the Congress says it was refused permission, accusing the government of silencing ordinary people after 'destroying' the electoral system. The gathering is symbolic, a public demand for Kumar's removal over alleged 'vote chori' and the handling of the Special Intensive Revision of voter rolls. Meira Kumar is set to chair, Kharge to present the motion, and Gandhi to close.

Earlier this month the bloc had marched under the banner 'Chalo Delhi – March for Democracy,' and sought a meeting with Chief Justice Surya Kant, which was not granted. An Indian Express report last month hinted at a rift inside the poll panel itself, with Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi raising objections.

Next comes the November 1 march to Ramlila Maidan, open to political and non-political people, civil society and journalists alike. Whether it draws a crowd beyond party loyalists will show how far the opposition's grievance can travel.

Rain over Delhi on Friday changed the schedule for the INDIA bloc's planned "public impeachment" of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The event was meant to take place that day at Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge's official residence at 10, Rajaji Marg. It has been pushed back one day, to Saturday, October 31, according to sources cited by PTI.

Rahul Gandhi, Congress MP and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, explained the decision to reporters. The bloc decided by consensus to hold the same programme at the same time the next day, he said, because it would be uncomfortable for senior leaders to sit through the rain. Nothing else about the event is changing.

The proceedings are symbolic. They are meant as a public expression of the opposition's demand for Kumar's removal, and they accuse the poll panel of failing to address concerns over alleged "vote chori" (vote theft). Leaders and representatives of INDIA bloc parties were to gather to discuss the charges against Kumar and the opposition's demand for action. ANI, citing sources, reported that former Lok Sabha Speaker Meira Kumar will chair the session. Kharge will introduce the motion against Kumar, and Rahul Gandhi is expected to give closing remarks before it is adopted.

The venue itself was a fallback. The bloc chose Kharge's residence after failing to secure other locations, including the Constitution Club of India and Talkatora Stadium. On Tuesday, the Congress claimed it had been denied permission for the event. It accused the government of trying to silence ordinary people after "destroying" the electoral system.

On Thursday, bloc leaders met at Kharge's residence to finalise the plans. Those present included Congress general secretaries Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, Jairam Ramesh and K. C. Venugopal, and senior Congress leader Meira Kumar. Also there were TMC's Derek O'Brien, the Samajwadi Party's Harendra Malik, JMM's Mahua Maji and CPI(M)'s John Brittas, among others.

The impeachment is followed by a larger event. On November 1, the bloc plans a march to Ramlila Maidan against Kumar and the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Gandhi said it is open to everyone who wants to come: political and non-political people, social and service workers, civil society figures and journalists. He described both programmes as being about the "demolition of Indian democracy" by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Home Minister Amit Shah, and Kumar and his crew in the Election Commission.

This follows earlier action this month. The bloc held a "Chalo Delhi – March for Democracy" after staging demonstrations and seeking Kumar's removal. Gandhi and Kharge asked to meet the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, but were not granted an audience. The bloc then marched toward the Supreme Court to submit a petition seeking Kumar's removal.

The SIR controversy sharpened after an Indian Express report last month. It indicated an internal rift within the poll panel, with Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi raising objections to the exercise.

What to watch now is Saturday's proceedings at Kharge's residence and then the Ramlila Maidan rally, which will show how far the opposition can draw support beyond party ranks.

By consensus, we have decided to postpone today's program to tomorrow at the same time because of rain; it would be uncomfortable for seniors to sit in the rain.
— Rahul Gandhi, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei Livemint ↗
Kontakt FAQ