A political coalition that set out to publicly call for the removal of the country's chief election official now finds its venues closing one after another, and what it does next will say something about how a democracy hears its own dissent. The INDIA bloc has moved its planned 'public impeachment' of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar from the Ashok Hotel and Ramlila Maidan to the residence of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on October 30, after saying permission was refused at both. The accusation of silencing critics belongs to the opposition, and the reasons for the refusals
INDIA bloc moves CEC 'public impeachment' to Kharge's residence after alleged permission denials
How many permissions will you deny, Mr Amit Shah?
Mark
Why does a change of venue matter here?
Mimi
Because the event was meant to be a curtain raiser for the November 1 rally. Moving it to Kharge's residence at 10, Rajaji Marg changes how it will look, and the Congress is presenting the move itself as evidence of its charge.
Mark
What is the sequence of the alleged denials?
Mimi
Venugopal says the Ashok Hotel first agreed, then backed out after police intervention. The party then planned to use Ramlila Maidan, which he says was booked from October 25 to November 3, but he says police stopped workers building infrastructure there two days earlier.
Luke
Let me separate what's established. All of this is Congress's account. Has any police or government statement confirmed a denial or given a reason?
Mimi
Not in this report. Venugopal himself said they don't know the reason.
Luke
Then his claim that Modi and Shah made the decision is an inference, not a finding.
Mimi
Yes, he stated it as an allegation, and the report carries no response from the Home Ministry or Delhi Police.
Mark
And the venue at Kharge's residence?
Luke
That comes from unnamed sources, not an official announcement, so it's worth treating as likely rather than final.
Mark
What's the larger demand?
Mimi
Opposition parties want Gyanesh Kumar to resign over the SIR and alleged electoral irregularities. The Congress says 21 INDIA bloc parties are behind the effort, though that figure is Venugopal's.
El Pulso
- The INDIA bloc's plan to publicly impeach Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has been pushed out of its first two venues, with permission reportedly denied at both.
- Congress leaders say the Ashok Hotel reversed its agreement after police intervention, leaving the coalition scrambling for space.
- Preparations for the November 1 Ramlila Maidan mega rally were halted when workers building the infrastructure were stopped by police, with no stated reason.
- Venugopal has vowed the party will not rest until Kumar is removed and threatened a massive dharna at the homes of Amit Shah and Modi if blocked.
- The October 30 gathering at Kharge's residence is being positioned as a curtain raiser, and whether police and permissions escalate the standoff will decide what follows.
A political coalition that set out to publicly call for the removal of the country's chief election official now finds its venues closing one after another, and what it does next will say something about how a democracy hears its own dissent. The INDIA bloc has moved its planned 'public impeachment' of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar from the Ashok Hotel and Ramlila Maidan to the residence of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on October 30, after saying permission was refused at both. The accusation of silencing critics belongs to the opposition, and the reasons for the refusals have not been publicly explained by police or government, so the episode remains a contest of claim and silence in the larger story of electoral trust.
The INDIA bloc's planned 'public impeachment' of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has been moved again. According to PTI sources, the event will now take place on October 30 at 10, Rajaji Marg, the residence of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge. The coalition first tried the Ashok Hotel and then Ramlila Maidan, and says it was refused at both. These are the party's claims, and the police and government have not publicly given reasons.
K C Venugopal, the Congress General Secretary (Organisation), described the sequence. He said the government-run Ashok Hotel agreed to host the event and then reversed after police intervention. The party then booked Ramlila Maidan from October 25 to November 3, but on Tuesday he said workers sent to build infrastructure there were stopped by police two days earlier. "We don't know what the reason is," he said, though he alleged the decision came from Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah, who he claimed were protecting Kumar.
Venugopal warned on X that the party would not rest until Kumar is removed, and that if blocked at Ramlila it would stage a massive dharna outside Shah's and Modi's homes. He asked how many permissions would be denied and how many people would be stopped.
Twenty-one INDIA parties had planned the October 30 event as a curtain raiser for a November 1 rally at Ramlila Maidan, built around the 'vote chori' charge. Both gatherings are part of a wider opposition campaign demanding Kumar's resignation over the SIR and alleged electoral irregularities. What happens at Kharge's residence and whether the Ramlila permissions are resolved will show whether this dispute grows.
The venue for the INDIA bloc's planned 'public impeachment' of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has changed. According to sources cited by PTI, the event will now be held on October 30 at 10, Rajaji Marg, the official residence of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge. The bloc first tried the Ashok Hotel and then Ramlila Maidan, and says it was refused permission at both.
The Congress made the claim publicly on Tuesday. It accused the government of trying to silence the voice of ordinary people after, in its words, destroying the electoral system. Those are the party's allegations. The reasons for any denial have not been publicly confirmed by the police or the government, according to the reporting.
K C Venugopal, the Congress General Secretary (Organisation), laid out the sequence. He said the government-run Ashok Hotel had at first agreed to host the event but reversed itself after police intervention. The Congress then turned to Ramlila Maidan, which he said the party had booked from October 25 to November 3, and decided to move the event there.
Venugopal visited the Ramlila grounds on Tuesday with leaders of the Delhi Congress to oversee preparations for the November 1 rally. He said that two days earlier, people sent to build the infrastructure had been stopped by police. "We don't know what the reason is," he said. From that he drew a conclusion: it was not Delhi Police's own decision, he alleged, but one made by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah, who he said were protecting Kumar.
In a post on X, Venugopal said the Congress would not rest until Kumar is removed, and that if the party were stopped at Ramlila Maidan it would go to Amit Shah's house and the Prime Minister's house and stage a massive dharna. He also asked, "How many permissions will you deny, Mr Amit Shah? How many people will you stop?" He said the government wants to shut down criticism of itself.
The scale of the effort is considerable. Venugopal said 21 parties of the INDIA bloc had planned the October 30 'public impeachment' as a curtain raiser for a November 1 rally at Ramlila Maidan, centred on the 'vote chori' charge. Sources say the Kharge residence event is meant to set the tone for that 'mega rally'.
Both events belong to a wider series of protests by the Congress and other opposition parties. They are demanding Kumar's resignation over the SIR and alleged electoral irregularities.
What to watch next is the October 30 gathering at Kharge's residence, then the November 1 rally. Whether the Ramlila Maidan permissions are sorted out, and whether police respond, will decide if this dispute over venues grows further.
Citas Notables
We don't know what the reason is.— K C Venugopal, Congress General Secretary (Organisation)
How many permissions will you deny, Mr Amit Shah? How many people will you stop?— K C Venugopal, in a post on X
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en ThePrint ↗
Politics & Governance