In the House of Representatives, a Republican majority on the eve of a changing Congress chose to quietly shelve an impeachment resolution aimed at Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, sending it to a committee it controls. The effort, brought by a dissenting Republican who accuses the Pentagon chief of waging the Iran war without congressional consent, was blocked by a narrow margin, a reminder of how easily accountability can be deferred when power is still in the hands of those it would constrain. The question it leaves open is not whether the war will be examined, but when, and by whom, as the
House Republicans Shelve Massie's Bid to Impeach Hegseth, Sending Measure to Judiciary Committee
They know it's a sinking ship but committed to stay on board.
Mark
Why does a referral to committee matter so much? It sounds procedural.
Mimi
It is procedural, and that's the point. Massie himself warned it would effectively kill the resolution. Sending it to the Republican-led Judiciary Committee means it can sit there rather than reach a direct vote.
Mark
The margin was 211 to 204. Is that close?
Mimi
Seven votes. Not a landslide, but enough, and Trump claimed it as a clear win.
Luke
Careful, though. The reporting gives us the tally, not who voted which way or why. We can't say how many Republicans defected or whether any Democrats joined in.
Mark
What are the actual charges against Hegseth?
Mimi
Massie says the Iran war is being fought illegally, without congressional approval. The resolution also questions the Houthi strikes in Yemen and operations in Venezuela.
Luke
Those are Massie's accusations. Hegseth calls them slander and a stunt. Nothing in this reporting establishes the legal question one way or the other.
Mark
And Massie's Titanic line?
Mimi
It's about a party that just lost the midterms choosing to stay with the administration. It's his characterization, not a finding.
Luke
And the forecast about Democrats reviving impeachment is an expectation, not a plan anyone has announced.
Le Pouls
- House Republicans voted 211-204 to send Rep. Thomas Massie's impeachment resolution against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee, a move that effectively halts it.
- Massie charges that Hegseth waged the Iran war without congressional approval, and the resolution also questions strikes in Yemen and Venezuela.
- Hegseth dismissed the charges at a Pentagon press conference as slander, sabotage, and a stunt, while President Trump declared the impeachment push had miserably failed.
- Massie warned colleagues that committee referral would kill the measure, and compared his party to Titanic passengers who know the ship is sinking yet stay aboard.
- With Democrats poised to control both chambers next year, renewed pressure and a possible fresh impeachment effort loom as the Iran war questions wait for January.
In the House of Representatives, a Republican majority on the eve of a changing Congress chose to quietly shelve an impeachment resolution aimed at Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, sending it to a committee it controls. The effort, brought by a dissenting Republican who accuses the Pentagon chief of waging the Iran war without congressional consent, was blocked by a narrow margin, a reminder of how easily accountability can be deferred when power is still in the hands of those it would constrain. The question it leaves open is not whether the war will be examined, but when, and by whom, as the balance of authority prepares to shift.
On Tuesday, the House voted 211 to 204 to send an impeachment resolution against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Republican-led Judiciary Committee. The move was widely read as a way to bury the effort, and it gave President Trump a welcome boost just a week after his party lost the midterm elections.
The resolution came from Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican and one of the few prominent members of his party who openly criticizes Trump. He introduced it hoping to force a vote before the new Congress convenes in January. His central charge is that Hegseth waged the war with Iran illegally, without congressional approval, and the text also questions his conduct in strikes on Houthi rebels in Yemen and in operations in Venezuela.
Hegseth rejected the accusations at a Pentagon press conference, calling them slander and sabotage and dismissing the effort as "a farce" and "a stunt." Trump praised him as a "Great American Patriot."
Massie had warned that referral would effectively end the measure, and it did. Afterward he likened his colleagues to Titanic passengers who know the ship is sinking but stay aboard. For now Hegseth is safe from this challenge, but the reprieve may be brief, as Democrats prepare to take both chambers and renewed pressure over the Iran war is expected in January.
On Tuesday, the House of Representatives voted 211 to 204 to send an impeachment resolution against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee, which is led by Republicans. The procedural move was widely understood to be a way of ending the effort, and it handed President Donald Trump a win at an awkward moment: a week earlier, his party had lost the midterm elections.
The resolution came from Thomas Massie, a Republican from Kentucky and one of the few prominent members of his party who speaks openly against Trump. He introduced it on Monday, apparently hoping to force a vote before the new Congress convenes in January. His central charge is that Hegseth has waged the war with Iran illegally, without approval from Congress. The text also raises questions about Hegseth's conduct in the strikes on Houthi rebels in Yemen and in military operations in Venezuela.
Hegseth answered the accusations before the vote. At a Pentagon press conference on Tuesday, he called them slander and sabotage. "It's a farce, and it's a stunt, and everybody knows it," he said. He has been under growing political pressure over the Iran war.
Massie had warned his colleagues beforehand that referring the resolution to committee would in effect kill it. The vote went ahead anyway, and it passed by seven votes.
Trump responded online. He called Hegseth a "Great American Patriot" and said the push to impeach the hawkish Pentagon chief had "miserably FAILED!"
After the vote, Massie turned to the outgoing Republican majority and compared his colleagues to passengers on the Titanic. "They know it's a sinking ship but committed to stay on board," he said. The line referred to the party's midterm losses and its decision to stand by the administration regardless.
For now, Hegseth appears safe from this particular challenge. The reprieve may be short. Democrats are set to take control of both the House and the Senate next year, and Hegseth is expected to face renewed pushback, possibly including a fresh impeachment effort. Whether a new Congress takes up the questions about the Iran war is the thing to watch in January.
Citations marquantes
It's a farce, and it's a stunt, and everybody knows it.— Pete Hegseth, at a Pentagon press conference
They know it's a sinking ship but committed to stay on board.— Rep. Thomas Massie, after the vote
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur Deutsche Welle ↗
Politics & Governance