In a procedural vote that carried more weight as a signal than as a verdict, the House of Representatives sent impeachment charges against Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth to a Republican-led committee, where they are likely to stall. The charges, drawn up by Republican Thomas Massie with Democratic backing, accuse Hegseth of waging an Iran war without the approval the law requires and of overseeing strikes on alleged drug boats that legal scholars call extrajudicial killings. The decision follows a midterm rebuke in which voters, many of whom blame the war for higher prices, punished the party
House Republicans Block Impeachment Effort Against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth
Strikes on alleged drug trafficking vessels, which legal scholars describe as extrajudicial killings, are among the charges; the article gives no casualty figures.
Republicans can avoid a direct vote on the eight articles
Mark
Why does a procedural vote matter so much here?
Mimi
Because it decides whether Republicans ever have to vote on the articles themselves. Referring them to the Judiciary Committee, which Republicans lead, lets them avoid a direct vote on the Iran war charge.
Luke
Worth being precise: the source says they can slow-walk it. That is what the vote makes possible, not something that has happened yet.
Mark
Massie was the only Republican to vote against the referral. Does that tell us much?
Mimi
It shows how isolated the effort was inside his party, even though Democrats also supported it.
Luke
It tells us about this vote. It doesn't tell us what other Republicans privately think. Senator Joni Ernst's question about whether Hegseth is being truthful hints at some doubt, but it's one question from a departing senator.
Mark
How much did the election drive this?
Mimi
The framing is that voters were frustrated over the war and the prices they link to it, and the vote was a test of whether Republicans would respond.
Luke
The link to prices comes from polls saying voters partly blame the war. That's a perception, not a measured cause, and the article doesn't say how large it is.
Mark
And the drug-boat strikes?
Mimi
Legal scholars call them extrajudicial killings, and they're among the eight articles. No casualty figures are given.
Luke
Right, so we can't say how many people were killed. Also, the Senate math was against removal from the start: two-thirds needed, 53 Republican seats.
Le Pouls
- A 211-204 vote quietly redirected eight articles of impeachment away from the floor and into a committee controlled by the same party.
- Accusations of an unauthorized Iran war and lethal strikes on alleged drug vessels put the defence secretary's conduct under sharp scrutiny.
- Hegseth calls the effort 'sabotage' and a 'farce,' while Trump declares the attempt has 'miserably FAILED.'
- Massie stood alone among Republicans, and even Senator Joni Ernst's question about whether the war is being described truthfully hints at unease.
- Removal would need two-thirds of the Senate, where Republicans hold 53 seats, so the real test now is whether the Judiciary Committee acts or lets the articles sit.
In a procedural vote that carried more weight as a signal than as a verdict, the House of Representatives sent impeachment charges against Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth to a Republican-led committee, where they are likely to stall. The charges, drawn up by Republican Thomas Massie with Democratic backing, accuse Hegseth of waging an Iran war without the approval the law requires and of overseeing strikes on alleged drug boats that legal scholars call extrajudicial killings. The decision follows a midterm rebuke in which voters, many of whom blame the war for higher prices, punished the party in power, and it shows how reluctant that party remains to break with a president who continues to stand by his secretary.
On Tuesday the House of Representatives voted 211 to 204 to send impeachment charges against Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Republican-led Judiciary Committee. The procedural vote effectively paused, for now, an effort to remove him from office.
The push came from Republican Representative Thomas Massie, who filed eight articles of impeachment, with Democrats backing him. Massie was the only Republican to oppose the motion to refer, so his side lost the fight. The articles accuse Hegseth of launching an Iran war without the congressional approval the law requires, and of overseeing strikes on alleged drug vessels that legal scholars describe as extrajudicial killings. No casualty figures were given for those strikes.
The referral lets Republicans slow the process and avoid a direct vote on the charges, including the Iran war article. The vote came after a midterm election in which voters expressed anger over the war, which many blame in part for rising gasoline and grocery prices. It was seen as a test of whether Republicans would distance themselves from an unpopular war after that rebuke. Most did not.
Hegseth has called the resolution "sabotage" and a "farce." Trump has said the attempt "miserably FAILED" and called Massie a "major LOSER." Even so, not every Republican was reassuring: outgoing Senator Joni Ernst asked whether Hegseth was being truthful about how the war is going.
Removal was always a long shot, since conviction requires two-thirds of the Senate and Republicans hold 53 seats. What comes next is whether the Judiciary Committee acts on the articles or lets them sit.
On Tuesday, the US House of Representatives voted 211 to 204 to send the impeachment charges against Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth to the House Judiciary Committee, which is led by Republicans. The procedural vote effectively ended, for now, an effort to remove him from office.
The push was led by Republican Representative Thomas Massie, who filed a resolution containing eight articles of impeachment. Democratic representatives also backed the effort. Massie was the only Republican to vote against the motion to refer, so his side lost the procedural fight.
The articles accuse Hegseth of launching an illegal war against Iran without the congressional approval the law requires. They also accuse him of overseeing a campaign of strikes on vessels alleged to be carrying drugs, which legal scholars describe as extrajudicial killings. The source gives no casualty figures for those strikes.
The referral matters because of what it allows. Republicans can now slow-walk the process, and they can avoid a direct vote on the eight articles, including the one covering the Iran war. Sending the charges to committee leaves them in a body controlled by the same party that just voted to shelve them.
The vote came after a midterm election in which voters vented frustration over the Iran war. Polls suggest voters partly blame the war for rising prices of goods such as gasoline and groceries. Republicans suffered punishing losses in the election, and speculation about Hegseth's standing in the administration has grown stronger since. Tuesday's vote was seen as a test of whether Republican lawmakers would break with the Trump administration and distance themselves from an unpopular war after that rebuke at the polls. By this vote, most did not.
Hegseth has called the resolution "sabotage" and a "farce." President Donald Trump and prominent members of his administration have expressed continued support for him. After the vote, Trump posted on social media that the Democrats' attempt to impeach "Secretary of War Pete Hegseth" had "miserably FAILED," and that every Republican except Massie, whom he called a "major LOSER," had voted in favour of Hegseth.
Not every Republican voice was reassuring. Outgoing Republican Senator Joni Ernst asked on Tuesday whether Hegseth was being truthful about how the war is going.
Even if the House had moved forward, removal was always a long shot. Conviction in the Senate requires a two-thirds vote, and Republicans hold 53 seats there, so it was seen as unlikely regardless of Tuesday's outcome. What to watch now is whether the Judiciary Committee takes any action on the articles, or whether they simply sit.
Citations marquantes
Trump said the Democrats' attempt to impeach Hegseth had 'miserably FAILED' and that every Republican except Massie voted in favour of Hegseth.— President Donald Trump, social media post
Is he being truthful in the way the war is going?— Outgoing Republican Senator Joni Ernst, on Hegseth
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur Al Jazeera ↗