On a hospital ward in Melbourne, a family waits for a woman whose life was upended on a regional Victorian street. Independent federal MP Helen Haines, who represents the Indi electorate, has been moved from critical to serious but stable condition after she was allegedly struck by a car near her office in Wangaratta, and both her legs were lost in the surgeries that followed. A man has been charged, and his case now begins its slow passage through the courts, while the people who work beside her, and the community that elected her, try to find their footing again. The event has made many Aust
Helen Haines's condition downgraded to serious but stable after alleged attack that cost her both legs
Federal MP Helen Haines lost both legs after an alleged attack, and her family and staff have been deeply affected.
Many of us witnessed the incident and some were among the first to come to her aid.
Mark
Why has the downgrade from critical to serious matter so much this week?
Mimi
It's the first formal sign things are moving the right way. She went from critical but stable to serious but stable, after losing both legs on Monday.
Mark
Her husband spoke about her heart and mind. Why that?
Mimi
He was telling people who she is beyond the injuries. Compassionate, supportive, the sharpest intellect, he said.
Luke
Worth noting that's a family statement, not a medical one. The hospital's only words are the spokesperson's line on her condition.
Mark
And the man charged?
Mimi
Brendan Nugent, 43, from Tarrawingee. Dangerous driving causing serious injury, intentionally causing serious injury, and harming a Commonwealth official, plus cannabis charges added later.
Luke
Those are allegations. He didn't apply for bail on Wednesday, but that's not a plea, and the reporting doesn't tell us a motive.
Mark
The debate about MP security seems to have taken off.
Mimi
It has, along with political tone and regional mental health. The Western Australia nunchucks case came days later.
Luke
I'd be careful linking the two. The report places them close in time, but it doesn't say they're connected.
Mimi
Fair. What's clear is the $730,000-plus for Save the Children and her staff reopening the offices next Thursday.
O Pulso
- A sitting MP was allegedly struck by a car outside her own electorate office, and the shock is still rippling through Canberra and Indi.
- Surgeons fought to save her right leg, but the damage forced amputation of both, turning a week of hope into a long, hard recovery.
- Charges of dangerous driving and intentionally causing serious injury have been laid, and the accused did not seek bail as the case begins.
- Her staff, many of whom saw the attack and rushed to help, are preparing to reopen the offices next Thursday while still reeling.
- Donations have surged past $730,000 for Save the Children, and debate over political temperature, MP security and regional mental health is intensifying.
On a hospital ward in Melbourne, a family waits for a woman whose life was upended on a regional Victorian street. Independent federal MP Helen Haines, who represents the Indi electorate, has been moved from critical to serious but stable condition after she was allegedly struck by a car near her office in Wangaratta, and both her legs were lost in the surgeries that followed. A man has been charged, and his case now begins its slow passage through the courts, while the people who work beside her, and the community that elected her, try to find their footing again. The event has made many Australians pause and consider how safe public service has become, and what it asks of the people who give it.
On Saturday morning, a hospital spokesperson at Melbourne's Alfred reported that Helen Haines was in serious but stable condition. Only days earlier she had been described as critically ill, after she was allegedly struck by a car in Wangaratta, near the electorate office she runs as the independent federal member for Indi.
The injuries were severe. Surgeons first tried to save her right leg, but the damage was too great, and both legs were amputated. Her husband, Phil, spoke from the hospital and painted a picture of the woman his family is waiting to bring home: compassionate, caring, deeply devoted to her family and community, and possessed of a sharp intellect. Her heart and mind, he said, were strong.
Police have charged Brendan Nugent, 43, of nearby Tarrawingee, with serious driving and assault-related offences, along with a Commonwealth charge of harming a public official. Two drug charges have since been added. Nugent did not apply for bail when he appeared in court, and the allegations remain untested.
Her staff, many of whom witnessed the incident and some of whom ran to her aid, have asked for patience as they look after one another and prepare to reopen the offices next Thursday. They have been moved by the generosity that followed, with more than $730,000 raised for Save the Children in her honour at her husband's request. A vigil in Wodonga drew her community together, and her predecessor, Cathy McGowan, spoke of the mixed emotions felt across Indi.
The case has also sparked wider conversation about the temperature of political debate, the safety of MPs, and mental health care in regional Victoria. Her recovery continues at the Alfred, and the courts will decide what comes next.
On Saturday morning, a spokesperson for Melbourne's Alfred hospital said Helen Haines was in a serious but stable condition. It was a step down in severity from the critical but stable description that had applied since Monday, when the independent federal MP for the Victorian seat of Indi was allegedly struck by a car in Wangaratta, near her electorate office in the state's north-east.
The injuries were grave. Surgeons initially tried to save her right leg, but the damage was too serious, and both legs had to be amputated. The news that she had lost both legs became public in the middle of the week.
Her husband, Phil Haines, spoke at the Alfred on Wednesday and offered a picture of the person his family is waiting to see recover. Her heart and her mind, he said, were in good shape, and those were the two most important parts of Helen for the family. He described her as compassionate, caring and loving, someone incredibly supportive of her family, her community and anyone she met, and as having the sharpest intellect.
On Tuesday, police charged Brendan Nugent, 43, of nearby Tarrawingee, with dangerous driving causing serious injury, intentionally causing serious injury, and the Commonwealth offence of causing harm to a Commonwealth public official. Court documents show two further charges have since been added: cultivating cannabis and possessing cannabis. Nugent appeared at Wangaratta magistrates court on Wednesday and did not apply for bail. The allegations have yet to be tested in court.
On Friday, a post on Haines's social media accounts said her staff were working to reopen her electorate offices next Thursday. The post made plain how close the staff were to what happened: many had witnessed the incident, and some were among the first to come to her aid. They said they would take time to look after themselves and one another as she recovers, and asked for understanding as they navigate the days and weeks ahead, adding that healing will take time.
The staff also said they had been overwhelmed by kindness from the Indi community, from across Australia and from around the world. More than $730,000 has been raised for Save the Children in Haines's honour, after her husband directed well-wishers to donate to the charity's appeal while his wife recovered. The staff said they were deeply moved by the generosity.
A community vigil was held in Wodonga on Wednesday evening, after it emerged that Haines had lost both legs. Cathy McGowan, Haines's predecessor as the member for Indi, spoke on the sidelines and said the community was grappling with mixed emotions.
The alleged attack has reverberated through Australian politics, prompting conversations about the temperature of political debate, security risks for MPs, and mental health services in regional Victoria. Days afterwards, in Western Australia, police charged a 56-year-old man for allegedly threatening staff and wielding nunchucks at the electorate office of the state's local government minister, Hannah Beazley.
The next markers are the reopening of Haines's offices next Thursday and Nugent's progress through the courts, while Haines continues her recovery at the Alfred.
Citações Notáveis
Both her heart and her mind are in good shape.— Phil Haines, husband of Helen Haines
The patient is in a serious but stable condition at The Alfred on Saturday morning.— Alfred hospital spokesperson
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em The Guardian ↗
Health & Medicine