In the civil hospitals of Rohtak and Jhajjar, a March morning brought silence where there is usually the hum of diagnosis and care. Doctors in Haryana walked off their outpatient duties to demand accountability after a colleague was allegedly assaulted by police while on duty in Karnal — a reminder that those who tend to the vulnerable are themselves vulnerable. The strike, organized by the Haryana Civil Medical Services Association, placed patients in an unwilling middle ground, their appointments and surgeries suspended by a dispute not of their making. What unfolds next will test whether in
Haryana doctors strike over alleged police assault, disrupting OPD services
Shut down emergency services if police are not charged
So a doctor was assaulted by police in Karnal, and the response was a strike in Rohtak and Jhajjar—two different cities. Why the geographic spread?
The Haryana Civil Medical Services Association represents doctors across the state. When one of their members is allegedly assaulted, they mobilize collectively. It's a show of solidarity and a way to apply pressure where it matters—at the hospitals where services can actually be disrupted.
But we should note: the source says "alleged assault." We don't have details about what happened, whether charges have been filed, or what the police say about the incident. We're working from the doctors' account.
Fair point. But from the doctors' perspective, the lack of an FIR—a formal police report—is exactly the problem. That's why they're threatening to escalate.
The patients who showed up that day—did they have any warning?
Not really. Ajay came for a follow-up and didn't know about the strike. Ram Mehar came with joint pain. Lalit brought his sick daughter. They just arrived and found the doors functionally closed for outpatient care.
Though we should be careful here: the hospital officials said they deployed additional doctors and issued OPD slips. The doctors said the strike was total. Those accounts don't quite match. We don't know the actual capacity or how many patients were turned away versus treated.
What about Rajender's surgery?
Postponed. He had hernia surgery scheduled for that day and it didn't happen. He has to book another date.
That's a concrete harm. But we don't know how many surgeries were actually postponed or rescheduled. The source gives us one example.
And the threat to expand to emergency services—how serious is that?
Very serious. Emergency services are the lifeline. If doctors stop working there, people in acute distress have nowhere to go. It's the nuclear option.
But it's also a threat, not an action. We don't know if they'll actually do it or if the administration will move to prevent it by addressing the doctors' demand.
Il Polso
- A doctor allegedly assaulted by police while on duty became the flashpoint for a coordinated walkout across two major Haryana hospitals, halting outpatient services for an unknown number of patients.
- Patients arrived expecting care and left without it — surgeries postponed, consultations cancelled, and some forced to choose between private hospitals they may not be able to afford and returning home untreated.
- Doctors drew a hard line: register an FIR against the accused police personnel, or watch the strike expand into emergency and casualty services — the last layer of care that cannot be deferred.
- Hospital administrations pushed back with competing numbers, claiming additional staff had been deployed and services largely maintained, while medical association leaders insisted the action was total and effective.
- The standoff remains unresolved, with the threat of a full hospital shutdown looming and no clear signal that police accountability — the doctors' central demand — is forthcoming.
In the civil hospitals of Rohtak and Jhajjar, a March morning brought silence where there is usually the hum of diagnosis and care. Doctors in Haryana walked off their outpatient duties to demand accountability after a colleague was allegedly assaulted by police while on duty in Karnal — a reminder that those who tend to the vulnerable are themselves vulnerable. The strike, organized by the Haryana Civil Medical Services Association, placed patients in an unwilling middle ground, their appointments and surgeries suspended by a dispute not of their making. What unfolds next will test whether institutions can protect those who serve within them, or whether the cost of that failure will continue to fall on the people who need care most.
On a March morning in Haryana, the outpatient departments at Civil Hospitals in Rohtak and Jhajjar sat nearly empty. The Haryana Civil Medical Services Association had called a strike after a doctor on duty at a Community Health Centre in Gharaunda, Karnal, was allegedly assaulted by police. Emergency services continued, but routine diagnosis and follow-up care came to a halt.
The disruption landed immediately on ordinary people. Ajay arrived at Jhajjar for a follow-up he hadn't known was cancelled and left without being seen. Ram Mehar found no one to treat his persistent joint pain. Lalit brought his ill daughter only to learn that OPD slips weren't being issued, forcing him to weigh private care against going home. Rajender, who had come for a scheduled hernia surgery, was told to return on another day.
Dr. Akriti, district president of the medical association in Jhajjar, confirmed all 42 outpatient doctors had joined the strike and issued a clear warning: if an FIR is not filed against the officers who allegedly assaulted their colleague, the association would not hesitate to shut down emergency services as well. In Rohtak, Dr. Vishvajit echoed the resolve, insisting participation had been complete.
Hospital administrators offered a different picture, saying additional doctors had been deployed and that services had largely continued. The competing accounts reflect a deeper conflict — doctors asserting their right to safety and institutional protection, administrators managing optics, and patients absorbing the cost of a dispute they had no part in creating.
Whether police will face charges, and whether the doctors will hold or escalate their action, remained open questions. The threat to extend the strike into emergency care — the irreducible core of any hospital — kept the situation on edge, while patients continued arriving, unaware the care they expected was no longer guaranteed.
On a March morning in Haryana, the outpatient departments at Civil Hospitals in Rohtak and Jhajjar sat nearly empty. Doctors had stopped work. The strike was called by the Haryana Civil Medical Services Association in response to what they described as a police assault on one of their colleagues—a doctor who had been on duty at a Community Health Centre in Gharaunda, a town in Karnal district. Emergency and casualty services continued, but the routine work of diagnosis and follow-up care simply halted.
The disruption rippled outward immediately. Ajay arrived at the Jhajjar hospital expecting a follow-up consultation. He had not heard about the strike. He left without being seen, knowing he would have to return the following week. Ram Mehar, who had been dealing with joint pain in his leg and knee for days, found no doctors available in the outpatient ward. Lalit brought his daughter, who had been ill for three days, only to learn that OPD slips—the paperwork that initiates treatment—were not being issued. He faced a choice: pay for private care or go home. Rajender, a resident of Dadri Toa village, had scheduled hernia surgery for that day. The operation was postponed. He would have to wait for another date, another appointment, another trip to the hospital.
At the Jhajjar Civil Hospital, Dr. Akriti, the district president of the medical association, confirmed that all 42 doctors engaged in outpatient services had participated in the strike. She made clear this was not a temporary action. "If an FIR is not registered against the police personnel who allegedly assaulted a doctor in Karnal, we will not hesitate to shut down emergency services as well," she said. The threat was direct: expand the strike to include casualty and emergency care—the services that cannot be postponed, the ones that keep a hospital functioning as a safety net.
The hospital administration offered a different account. Dr. Gurjeet Sidhu, the Senior Medical Officer in Jhajjar, said additional doctors had been deployed to the OPD to minimize inconvenience to patients. In Rohtak, a hospital official reported that 1,656 patients had visited that day, and that OPD slips had been issued to all of them. The official also noted that 37 doctors at the Rohtak Civil Hospital had participated in the strike, but that additional staff had been brought in to maintain continuity. Dr. Vishvajit, the district president of the medical association in Rohtak, countered this narrative, insisting the strike had been successful and that all doctors at the hospital had participated.
The disagreement over numbers and impact reflects a deeper tension. The doctors were making a statement about their safety and their standing. A colleague had allegedly been assaulted by police while performing his duties. From their perspective, the institution—the hospital, the state—had a responsibility to protect them and to hold the police accountable. The strike was a lever, a way to force attention and action. The patients caught in the middle had no role in this dispute, yet they bore its cost: delayed diagnoses, cancelled appointments, surgeries moved to unknown future dates, and the difficult decision of whether to seek care elsewhere or wait.
What remained unclear was whether the police would face charges, whether the hospital administration would formally support the doctors' demand, or how long the doctors would maintain their action. The threat to expand the strike to emergency services hung in the air—a line that, if crossed, would transform a disruption into a genuine crisis. For now, the outpatient departments remained quiet, and patients continued to arrive, unaware that the care they expected was not available.
Citazioni salienti
If an FIR is not registered against the police personnel who allegedly assaulted a doctor in Karnal, we will not hesitate to shut down emergency services as well.— Dr. Akriti, district president of the Haryana Civil Medical Services Association in Jhajjar