A government adviser on rape, Prof Katrin Hohl, has used the public storm around Russell Brand's conviction to ask a harder question of England and Wales: what actually happens to people who report sexual offences once their case leaves the police station and enters the courtroom. Reforms that reoriented police and prosecutors toward suspects' conduct have made progress, but the courts have not kept pace, and much of the process remains unseen by the public it is meant to serve. In the wake of a conviction that drew both celebration and bitter defence, the moment asks the society to look at th
Government Rape Adviser Calls to 'Pull Back the Curtain' on How Sexual Assault Victims Are Treated in Court
"It is time to pull back the curtain" on how rape cases play out in court
Why does Hohl's point about courts matter so much?
Because police and prosecutors have been reformed under Operation Soteria, and she says cases then hit a "cliff edge" at trial. The work upstream may not survive the courtroom.
Worth noting that's a "potentially." Her report suggests rape myths may be used by defence barristers, but she herself says we know very little about what happens in these trials. That's the point of her call for research.
What's being proposed in the meantime?
Waxman wants a legal duty on judges to direct juries when myths come up. Norris has asked the Bar Standards Board to set standards for defence lawyers in these cases.
Those are calls and requests, not changes. Nothing says the Board will agree or that the duty will be legislated.
And the helpline surge?
Bergman says calls to the support line have quadrupled since the start of the month, and some people are questioning their own past experiences.
That figure comes from Rape Crisis itself, and the source doesn't say how it was measured. The link to the Brand and Walliams coverage is Bergman's reading of why people call. Walliams denies wrongdoing, and the Met is only looking at allegations.
What about the age-of-consent idea?
McFadden said it will be discussed, but he gave no conclusion.
Il Polso
- Cases built under the new police and prosecution system appear to hit a cliff edge when they reach trial, where defence tactics may draw on rape myths.
- Brand's conviction has ignited fierce argument, with his barrister's remark that accusers did not resist or scream landing as a flashpoint.
- Ministers are weighing a rape-myths jury direction duty, a Bar Standards Board review, and a possible staggered age-of-consent law.
- Rape Crisis calls have quadrupled since the start of the month, with survivors reliving trauma and others re-examining their own past experiences.
- Policymakers are racing to turn outrage into firm rules, and it remains unclear which proposals will survive into law.
A government adviser on rape, Prof Katrin Hohl, has used the public storm around Russell Brand's conviction to ask a harder question of England and Wales: what actually happens to people who report sexual offences once their case leaves the police station and enters the courtroom. Reforms that reoriented police and prosecutors toward suspects' conduct have made progress, but the courts have not kept pace, and much of the process remains unseen by the public it is meant to serve. In the wake of a conviction that drew both celebration and bitter defence, the moment asks the society to look at the machinery behind the verdict, and to decide whether the myths that still shape trials will be named and corrected or quietly left to persist.
Professor Katrin Hohl, the government's independent adviser on rape, believes the debate set off by Russell Brand's conviction should be used to pull back the curtain on what happens to people who report sexual offences. Her concern is that too much goes wrong inside the system, and too little of it is ever seen. Most people never learn what unfolds during an investigation or a trial.
Under Operation Soteria, police and the Crown Prosecution Service have been directed to focus on suspects' behaviour rather than victims'. Hohl says both have made real progress, but the courts are being left behind. Her recent report found that cases built under the new approach appear to hit a cliff edge at trial, where defence barristers may still rely on rape myths. She is calling for proper research into barristers, judges and juries, because we currently know very little about how these cases play out.
Others are pressing the same point. The victims commissioner wants judges to direct juries whenever myths are raised, and the justice secretary has asked the Bar Standards Board to set standards for lawyers defending rape cases. Brand himself was sentenced to more than ten years after being found guilty of raping one woman and sexually assaulting three others. Ministers are also weighing a staggered consent law, prompted by a campaign from a woman who says she was in an abusive relationship with Brand at 16.
For the people who answer the phones, the effects are immediate. Rape Crisis England & Wales reports calls have quadrupled, with some callers retraumatised by coverage and others questioning experiences they had long carried. Whether any of these proposals becomes firm policy is still an open question.
Professor Katrin Hohl, the government's independent adviser on rape, has told the Guardian that the debate set off by Russell Brand's conviction should be used to "pull back the curtain" on how people who report sexual offences are treated in the criminal justice system of England and Wales. In her view, too much goes wrong and too little of it is ever seen. "Most of the time no one ever finds out what has happened during the investigation process or during a trial," she said.
Hohl has advised ministers on an overhaul of how police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service handle rape. Under a system known as Operation Soteria, they have been directed to focus investigations on the behaviour of suspects rather than that of victims. She said both had made "significant progress." The courts, she argued, were being left behind.
A report she published last month found that cases prepared under the new system appeared to hit "a cliff edge" on reaching trial. They were potentially meeting practices such as defence barristers using rape myths. She said we know very little about how rape and sexual assault cases play out in court, and called for proper research into the actions of barristers, judges and juries so that victims can get the justice the law says they should.
Others are pushing in the same direction. Claire Waxman, the victims commissioner, has called for a new legal duty on judges to direct juries whenever rape myths have been raised during a trial. "Justice must be grounded in evidence, not misconceptions," she said. The justice secretary, Alex Norris, has written to the Bar Standards Board, which supervises barristers, asking it to set standards for lawyers who represent defendants accused of rape and sexual offences. According to the Times, he called it "unacceptable" for the profession to "perpetuate myths" about victims in court.
At Brand's trial, the comedian was sentenced to more than 10 years in prison after being found guilty of raping one woman and sexually assaulting three others. His barrister, Ian Winter, told the court that his accusers had not "resisted or screamed or even tried to leave." Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, will warn on Monday that the entertainment industry must "get its house in order" and stamp out bullying and sexual abuse or face a government crackdown. Writing in the Times, she said: "It should not cost you your career, your mental health and your future to report harassment, sexual abuse or rape."
The case has also revived a question about the law on consent. Ministers are understood to be weighing a "staggered" consent law that would make it illegal for adults above a certain age to have sex with 16- and 17-year-olds. Mia Latter, who says she was in an abusive three-month relationship with Brand when she was 16 and he was 30, has launched a campaign for the change. On the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Pat McFadden said the issue "has been raised and will be discussed." He could not say what the conclusion would be, but added that "the last week has certainly put that up in lights."
Support services describe a surge in demand. Ciara Bergman, chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, said calls to the 24/7 rape and sexual abuse support line have quadrupled since the start of the month, and local centres report "very significant demand." She said some callers are reminded of their own experiences by the news, and some are retraumatised. Others, who experienced predation or exploitation at vulnerable times in their lives, are now questioning those experiences. Many women are doing so, she said, after separate allegations that David Walliams preyed on young women for sex. The Metropolitan police are looking at a series of "serious" sexual offence allegations against him following a Guardian and ITV News investigation. One woman described an alleged encounter at 15 as "sexual assault." Walliams denies any wrongdoing.
Bergman also backed greater transparency in trials, saying the coverage had exposed a gap in public knowledge about going to trial and about consent. Her centres, she said, are under very significant pressure and need more support and more rape crisis centres.
A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said the government is changing the law to stop irrelevant evidence relying on myths from being weaponised against victims, rolling out specialist courtrooms for rape and serious sexual offences, and improving support backed by a record £550m investment in support services. What remains open is whether any of the proposals on jury directions, barrister standards or consent law will become firm policy.
Citazioni salienti
We need proper research into the actions of barristers, judges and juries during trials so that victims can actually get the justice the law says they should achieve.— Prof Katrin Hohl, government independent adviser on rape
Justice must be grounded in evidence, not misconceptions.— Claire Waxman, victims commissioner