Fruit Juice and Puree on Food Labels May Hide Part of the Free Sugar Load, Brazil Study Finds

About one in six packaged foods listed a fruit-based free sugar ingredient
A Brazilian survey of 5,276 packaged foods found 15.7% declared such ingredients, which added-sugar labels exclude.
Mark

What's the headline finding here?

Mimi

About one in six of 5,276 packaged foods in a Brazilian supermarket listed a processed fruit ingredient, such as juice, puree, pulp, or powder, that counts as free sugar under the broader Public Health England definition.

Mark

And why does that matter on a label?

Mimi

Brazil's added-sugar definition excludes those ingredients. So the added-sugar number could be lower than the total free sugar in the product.

Luke

Could be. The study didn't measure how much lower. It only looked at ingredient lists.

Mark

But in nearly two-thirds of those products the ingredient sat in the first three positions.

Mimi

Right, and ingredients are listed by weight, so that hints at a substantial amount.

Luke

A hint, not a measurement. Position is an indirect proxy, and the authors say they couldn't determine quantity or sugar contribution.

Mark

Does this show manufacturers swapping sugar for fruit ingredients?

Luke

No. The authors suggest the rule could encourage that, but they didn't examine whether it happens. And the data predate the new labeling rules, so we don't know what changed afterward.

Mimi

There's also judgment involved. Nearly a quarter of fruit declarations didn't specify processing, so the team classified some by product type.

Mark

Is any of this a health finding?

Luke

Not at all. Health effects weren't examined, and the evidence on fruit-derived sugars is limited and mixed. It's also a single supermarket chain in November 2020.

  • Roughly one in six packaged foods in a Brazilian supermarket sample lists processed fruit ingredients that a broader definition would classify as free sugars.
  • Brazil's added-sugar labels leave out fruit juice, puree, pulp, and powder, so the sugar figures on packages may fall short of the real total.
  • Fruit juice and puree appear everywhere from drinks and yogurts to vinegar and meat products, turning a natural-sounding ingredient into a widespread labeling blind spot.
  • The study was a single supermarket snapshot taken before the new rules, so it cannot yet show whether manufacturers swapped sugars or changed formulas.
  • Health effects remain unmeasured, leaving researchers to suggest that sugar labeling rules may need revisiting.

Somewhere between the orchard and the supermarket shelf, fruit is transformed into juices, purees, and powders that carry sugar in forms the law does not yet count. A team of Brazilian, Uruguayan, and Australian researchers, drawing on a 2020 snapshot of thousands of packaged foods, found that roughly one product in six declares such processed fruit ingredients. Their finding raises a quiet question about whether Brazil's definition of added sugar, written before its new labeling rules took effect, still tells consumers the whole story of what is sweet in what they eat.

In November 2020, researchers gathered label details from 7,828 packaged foods and drinks at one of Brazil's largest supermarket chains, using a mobile app developed through the George Institute's FoodSwitch program. The survey landed in a narrow window: Brazil had approved new food labeling rules but had not yet enforced them, so the data serves as a baseline. Scientists from several universities in Brazil, Uruguay, and Australia have now asked what the fruit ingredients on those labels say about sugar.

The question hinges on definitions. Brazil's added-sugar category covers sweeteners put in during manufacturing or cooking, but the WHO's broader idea of free sugars also includes sugars in fruit juices and purees, where the fruit's cell structure has been broken down. The team applied that wider lens, removing single-ingredient foods, plain water, fresh produce, and baby formula, which left 5,276 products. They found that 15.7% listed at least one such processed fruit ingredient, often among the first three on the list, which suggests a meaningful amount, though not how much sugar it adds.

Juice was the most common form, followed by puree and pulp. Every sampled juice and fruit drink contained them, while savory snacks rarely did. The practical concern is that a package's added-sugar figure may understate its total free sugar content, and manufacturers might shift toward these ingredients to avoid the label. The authors did not test that, nor did they measure health outcomes. Their single-store, pre-rule snapshot leaves open how the labels will look once the new rules take hold, and they suggest the findings may help shape future revisions.

In November 2020, researchers collected label details from 7,828 packaged foods and beverages at one of Brazil's 15 largest supermarket chains. They used a mobile phone app built through the George Institute's FoodSwitch program. The survey came after Brazil approved new food labeling rules but before they took effect, which makes it a baseline. A study in Nutrition Bulletin has now analyzed that data and asks what the fruit ingredients on those labels say about sugar.

The work came from scientists at the Federal University of Santa Catarina in Brazil, Universidad de la República in Uruguay, and the University of New South Wales and Deakin University in Australia, including researchers from the George Institute for Global Health.

The question turns on definitions. Added sugars are those put in during manufacturing, cooking, or eating. Free sugars, as the World Health Organization defines them, also include sugars naturally present in fruit juices, syrups, and honey, and the WHO recommends keeping them under 10% of daily energy. Public Health England uses a wider definition that also covers purees, pastes, and similar products in which the fruit's cell structure has been broken down. Dried and chopped fruit are excluded. The team applied this broader definition to flag processed fruit ingredients as potential sources of free sugars.

To get a usable sample, the researchers removed single-ingredient foods, alcohol, plain water, raw meats, fresh produce, and dried teas, herbs, and spices. They also dropped foods for children up to age 3 and baby formula, which fall under separate rules. That left 5,276 products, sorted into 24 food groups. The team recorded each fruit-derived ingredient and grouped extracts, puree and pulp, powdered fruit, and juices as fruit-based free sugar ingredients. Dried and chopped fruits formed separate groups. Because 23.7% of fruit declarations did not state how the fruit was processed, some classifications required judgment. Yogurts, jams, and ice creams were treated as puree and pulp, infusion teas as powdered fruit, and cookies and cereal bars as dried or chopped fruit.

Overall, 15.7% of the products, about one in six, listed at least one such ingredient, and the researchers found 398 distinct terms for fruit-related ingredients. In nearly two-thirds of those products, the ingredient was among the first three listed. Since ingredients are listed by descending weight, position served as an indirect indicator of quantity, but the study could not determine how much of the ingredient was present or how much sugar it contributed.

Fruit juice was the most frequently declared category, closely followed by puree and pulp. Powdered fruit and extracts were far less common. Juices dominated in beverages, meats, oils and nuts, and food additives, with examples such as lemon juice in meat products and grape must in vinegar. Puree and pulp led in yogurts, sweet spreads, and plant-based dairy substitutes.

Prevalence varied widely. Every sampled juice, nectar, and fruit drink contained these ingredients. So did about 62% of fruit pieces, jams, and similar items, 52% of dairy drinks, yogurts, and dairy desserts, and 48% of sweet spreads. At the low end were savory snacks at 1.3% and gravies, sauces, and ready-to-eat dishes at 1.7%.

The practical issue is that Brazil's definition of added sugars leaves out fruit juice, puree, pulp, and powdered fruit. A label's added-sugar figure may therefore report less than a product's total free sugar content, though the study did not measure by how much. The authors suggested the distinction could encourage manufacturers to swap conventional added sugars for processed fruit ingredients, but they did not test whether that happens. They also noted that systems such as Nutri-Score and the Health Star Rating can give positive nutritional value to some of these ingredients.

The limits are plain. This is one supermarket in one month, taken before the new rules applied, so it cannot show whether manufacturers changed their formulas afterward. It did not assess health effects, and the evidence on sugars from fruit remains limited and contradictory. The authors say the findings may inform revisions to sugar labeling rules.

Brazil's current added-sugar definition excludes fruit juice, puree, pulp, and powdered fruit, so labels may report less than total free sugar content; the study did not measure by how much.
— Study authors, Nutrition Bulletin (paraphrased)
Quieres la nota completa? Lee el original en News-Medical ↗
Contáctanos FAQ