France accuses Iran's Revolutionary Guard of hacking supermarket fridges, spoiling tons of food

The first large-scale sabotage cyber-attack on French soil
Foreign Minister Barrot's characterisation of the October attack on supermarket refrigeration.
Mark

Why does a spoiled-food story get a foreign minister and a summoned ambassador?

Mimi

Because of what was touched. Not data, but physical systems. Hackers reached software that runs refrigeration in hundreds of stores, and food was destroyed. Barrot called it the first large-scale sabotage-aimed cyber-attack on French soil.

Luke

Worth separating what's established from what's alleged. The attack itself and the stores affected are reported facts. The IRGC attribution is the French government's claim.

Mark

And France hasn't said how it got there?

Mimi

No. It named the Shahid Kaveh unit through the Paris prosecutor, who opened an investigation into its head and two deputies, but no evidence has been shown publicly.

Luke

Attribution in cyber is notoriously hard because attackers can hide their locations. So an investigation being opened is not the same as a finding.

Mark

Two Russian-aligned groups claimed it too.

Mimi

They did, on Wednesday, but few believe them.

Mark

What about the later attacks in Belgium, Sweden and elsewhere?

Luke

Unknown whether they're linked to the French incident. The same goes for the August incidents at US bases, which Reuters says are being investigated as deliberate, citing sources.

Mimi

And Iran hasn't officially responded, though some of its media call the claim baseless.

Luke

Also, whether this was deterrence strategy, even if Iran is responsible, is unclear. Anything beyond that is speculation.

  • A software takeover on 11 October pushed fridges in more than 280 supermarket stores toward dangerous temperatures, forcing tons of food into the bin.
  • Paris has summoned Iran's ambassador and Foreign Minister Barrot is calling the attack unprecedented, promising sanctions and further measures.
  • Prosecutors have opened an investigation into the alleged leadership of the IRGC-linked Shahid Kaveh unit and its two deputies.
  • Tehran has not formally responded and some Iranian outlets dismiss the charges, while Paris has yet to explain how it reached its attribution.
  • A similar wave across Europe and fridge failures at US bases raise the question of whether these incidents form one campaign, and the answer is still open.

On a single October night, the quiet machinery that keeps a nation's food cold was seized from afar, and by morning shelves of chilled and frozen goods had warmed beyond saving across much of France. Now the government has named a suspect in the shadows of a hostile state, the Revolutionary Guard Corps of Iran, and summoned its ambassador to answer for it. Yet the story still rests on a foundation that has not been shown: the reasons for the accusation remain unexplained, the accused have not spoken, and the hidden hands of cyberspace make every such claim hard to prove. It is a reminder of how fragile ordinary comforts have become, and how easily a dispute between governments can reach into a refrigerator.

On the night of 11 October, hackers took control of refrigeration software made by the Danish firm Danfoss, which lets supermarkets manage their cold units remotely. By morning, temperatures in some fridges and freezers had reportedly climbed as high as 50C, and tons of chilled and frozen food had to be destroyed. More than 100 Coopérative U stores were hit, along with 180 Intermarché and Netto stores, and Carrefour, Monoprix and E.Leclerc were also affected.

This week the French government named Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps as the likely culprit. Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot called it the first large-scale cyber-attack aimed at sabotage on French soil, an unprecedented assault on the nation's interests and its people. Paris has summoned the Iranian ambassador to lodge a strong protest, and Barrot has promised sanctions and other measures to deter any repeat. The Paris prosecutor, Laure Beccuau, has opened an investigation into the head of the alleged IRGC-linked unit, Shahid Kaveh, and his two deputies.

Tehran has not responded officially, and some Iranian media have dismissed the allegations as baseless. The government has not explained how it reached its conclusion, and attributing cyber-attacks is notoriously hard because attackers can hide where they operate from. Two Russian-aligned hacktivist groups have also claimed responsibility, though few believe them.

The case is not isolated. Earlier this month a second wave of hacks hit more than 100 stores across Europe, including Belgium and Luxembourg, and a separate set of fridge failures struck US military bases in August. Whether these events are linked is not yet known. What comes next will be watched closely: the promised sanctions, whether evidence is made public, and whether investigators can connect the dots.

On the night of 11 October, the software that controls refrigeration in many of France's supermarkets was taken over by hackers. By morning, in some stores, temperatures in fridges and freezers had reportedly climbed as high as 50C (120F). Tons of chilled and frozen food had to be destroyed.

The scale of it is now clearer. More than 100 Coopérative U supermarkets were hit, along with 180 stores from Intermarché and its Netto brand. Carrefour, Monoprix and E.Leclerc were also affected. The attackers targeted software from the Danish engineering firm Danfoss, which lets retailers manage their cold units remotely.

This week the French government named who it believes is responsible: Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot called the attack unprecedented in both its scale and its level of aggression. He said it was the first large-scale cyber-attack aimed at sabotage on French national territory, and described it as a major attack on the nation's interests and the security of the French people. Paris has summoned the Iranian ambassador to lodge what Barrot called a very strong protest against an extremely grave act, and he promised that those responsible would face sanctions. France, he added, will take any other necessary and proportionate measures to deter anyone who might try to repeat it.

The judicial side is moving too. Paris prosecutor Laure Beccuau said an investigation has been opened into the head of an offensive cyber unit associated with the IRGC, and into his two deputies. She named the unit as Shahid Kaveh, which she said is affiliated with the IRGC's electronic and cyber centre. The name refers to a cluster of hackers thought to be directly employed by the Iranian regime.

Iran has not responded officially. Some Iranian media outlets have dismissed the allegations as baseless.

The French incident was not the last. Earlier this month a second wave of hacks hit more than 100 stores across Europe. Supermarkets in Belgium and Luxembourg were affected, and a smaller number of shops in Sweden, Ireland, the Netherlands, Estonia and Finland. It is not known whether the two waves are linked. Separately, in August a small number of US military bases saw fridges mysteriously malfunction and food spoil; Reuters, citing sources familiar with the matter, reports that this too is being investigated as deliberate cyber-attack.

The context is a tense one. In recent weeks, commentators and politicians in Iran have argued that any retaliation should extend beyond the Middle East if the US and Israel resume the war they began earlier this year. If the IRGC did carry out the attacks, it is unclear whether they were part of an Iranian deterrence strategy.

The attribution itself rests on thin public ground. The French government has not said how it concluded Iran was responsible, and pinning down the source of cyber-attacks is extremely difficult because hackers can hide their locations. Two Russian-aligned hacktivist groups claimed responsibility on Wednesday, though few believe them. What to watch now: the sanctions Barrot has promised, whether any evidence is made public, and whether investigators connect the French attack to the European wave and the US base incidents.

The attack was unprecedented in both its scale and its level of aggression.
— Jean-Noël Barrot, French Foreign Minister
France will take any necessary and proportionate measures to deter anyone who might seek to repeat it.
— Jean-Noël Barrot, French Foreign Minister
Quieres la nota completa? Lee el original en BBC News ↗
Contáctanos FAQ