For sixty-six hours in a former paint factory above the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, several hundred ordinary New Yorkers took turns speaking the words of a 1,162-page biography aloud, as if to test whether the city could still hear its own past. The book is Robert Caro's account of Robert Moses, the builder who gave the region its parkways, pools, beaches and housing, and who also uprooted nearly half a million people and left neighborhoods breathing harder for generations. Holding that double ledger in one room, the readers asked an old question that cities keep returning to: whether a commun
Four Days, 402 Readers, One Book: New York Marathon-Reads Robert Caro's 'The Power Broker'
"Couldn't people see what he had done?"
Why would hundreds of people read a 1974 biography aloud for 66 hours?
Partly it's a book people own and admire but haven't finished. Over 1,700 applied for 10-minute slots, and 402 got one.
Worth noting that's the count of applicants and readers. Nothing in the reporting says how many people simply sat in the pews.
What did listeners hear about Moses?
Both ledgers: 416 miles of parkways, 1,000 public housing buildings, 255 playgrounds, and nearly half a million people displaced.
Those figures come from the book, which is more than 50 years old. The borough historian Asad Dandia said scholarship has moved on.
So the event wasn't pure celebration?
No. Dandia still read and admired it, but argued public discourse has to evolve. He said people crave a grand narrative.
And Caro's view of the present?
He doesn't want a ruthless builder, but says the city needs someone who gets things built.
That's one interview remark. It doesn't say what policy should follow, and Mayor Mamdani admitted he hasn't read the book.
El Pulso
- Hundreds of readers rotated through a Gowanus arts venue in a relay that never paused for 66 hours, with volunteers managing naps and slots against a tight, exhausting clock.
- Thousands applied for a ten-minute place at the microphone, and those left out voiced disappointment, turning a literary marathon into a contested civic ticket.
- The reading forced a hard reckoning: 416 miles of parkways and 1,000 public housing buildings sit beside nearly half a million displaced residents and lasting asthma harms.
- Scholars push back that half a century of urban planning research has moved on, while the mayor waves the book as a prop, and the debate over whether the city needs a builder like Moses remains unsettled.
- The event closes on Caro's final pages, with an aging Moses bitter and unable to understand his fall, leaving the audience to judge what his legacy should now mean.
For sixty-six hours in a former paint factory above the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, several hundred ordinary New Yorkers took turns speaking the words of a 1,162-page biography aloud, as if to test whether the city could still hear its own past. The book is Robert Caro's account of Robert Moses, the builder who gave the region its parkways, pools, beaches and housing, and who also uprooted nearly half a million people and left neighborhoods breathing harder for generations. Holding that double ledger in one room, the readers asked an old question that cities keep returning to: whether a community should trade its own voice for a powerful hand that gets things built. The answer offered that weekend was less a verdict than a conversation, carried on by strangers who came to listen as much as to read.
On the third floor of a former paint factory in Gowanus, Brooklyn, a procession of readers took the stage over four days, each reading about 1,300 words of Robert Caro's "The Power Broker" aloud. Among them were a union organizer fresh from meetings in Manhattan, an Einstein biographer back from New Mexico, a Bronx "street librarian" who arrived after 1 a.m., a great-granddaughter of Mayor La Guardia, a subway announcer, and two teenagers, ages 13 and 16, who read near the end. More than 1,700 people had applied for a ten-minute slot, and 402 were chosen to take part.
The reading ran 66 hours and covered all 1,162 pages of the 1974 biography of Robert Moses. Visitors in the pews heard both the ledger of his achievements, 416 miles of parkways, 1,000 public housing buildings and 255 playgrounds, and the costs: nearly half a million people displaced, low overpasses meant to keep poorer residents away from the beaches, and the asthma rates that follow neighborhoods he carved apart. Christina Greer, a Fordham professor, spoke of Puerto Rican neighbors evicted in the 1950s to make room for Lincoln Center, and said that no matter where you live, Moses has touched it.
The organizer, Brad Vogel, kept the relay going with a careful nap schedule and volunteers who chose readers from many backgrounds and ZIP codes. By Friday night the room was flagging, and Vogel fought sleep to ring a bell at midnight. Not everyone was convinced. Asad Dandia, the Brooklyn borough historian, noted that decades of planning scholarship have followed the book and that public discourse "has to evolve."
The event ended with a video of Caro, 91, reading the final pages, in which an aging Moses is forgotten and bitter, asking why people were not grateful. Caro, now writing the last volume of his Lyndon Johnson biography, has said the city still needs someone who can get things built, even if that person is ruthless. The room was left with that question.
On the third floor of a former paint factory in Gowanus, Brooklyn, a procession of readers took the stage over four days, each reading about 1,300 words aloud from Robert Caro's "The Power Broker." Among them were a union organizer who had spent the day meeting with biology researchers in Manhattan, a biographer of Albert Einstein just back from a reporting trip to New Mexico, and a Bronx "street librarian" who reached Brooklyn by subway and Uber after 1 a.m. Others included a descendant of a Depression-era mayor, several current government officials, a few college professors and the voice of the subway announcements.
The reading ran 66 hours, from Thursday into Sunday afternoon, and covered all 1,162 pages of the 1974 biography of Robert Moses, the polarizing builder responsible for much of modern New York. In all, 402 readers took part. More than 1,700 people had applied for a 10-minute slot at Judgy Baby, a new arts venue in an industrial stretch of Gowanus that overlooks the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, a crumbling highway Moses built. Readers included a great-granddaughter of Mayor Fiorello H. La Guardia, Caro's editor Kathy Hourigan, and the subway announcer Bernie Wagenblast. Two of the last readers were Henry and Elias Jones, ages 13 and 16. Some who missed out were disappointed, including Marc Molinaro, a former Republican congressman who said he had read the book twice.
The event ended with a video of Caro, 91, reading the final two pages. He described an aging Moses "forgotten," living out his years in bitterness and rage, unable to grasp his fall from power. "Couldn't people see what he had done?" Caro read. "Why weren't they grateful?"
Visitors sat in pews and heard the builder's accomplishments: 416 miles of parkways, 11 swimming pools, 17 miles of beach, 1,000 public housing buildings, and 255 playgrounds built in the 1930s. They also heard the costs: nearly half a million people displaced, overpasses built low over Long Island parkways to keep out buses carrying poorer city dwellers, high asthma rates in neighborhoods he carved up, and rail projects never built because he preferred cars. Laurie Gwen Shapiro, the Einstein biographer, read about Moses's mother on the first night. Brandon Montes, the library evangelist, had a 1:40 a.m. Saturday slot covering the 6,800,000 pounds of steel used to cover rail tracks and build Riverside Park.
The organizer was Brad Vogel, an environmentalist known for canoeing the contaminated Gowanus Canal. He and a band of volunteers chose readers from varied backgrounds and ZIP codes, and set a nap schedule so that "someone has their hand on the tiller." By late Friday they were flagging: a volunteer dozed on a giant bean bag, and Vogel fought sleep to ring a bell at midnight. He said he had slept 2.5 hours the night before, plus a 10-minute cat nap, and that people kept buying him pizza.
Readers brought their own reasons. Ujji Bathla, 22, the union organizer, who lives near Washington Square Park, thought about how community opposition stopped Moses from running a highway through it, and said the book "reads almost like a novel." Christina Greer, a Fordham political science professor, spoke of Puerto Rican neighbors near Fordham's Manhattan campus evicted in the 1950s to make way for Lincoln Center. "No matter where you live and what neighborhood you're in," she said, it has been touched by Moses.
There was dissent too. Asad Dandia, the Brooklyn borough historian, noted on social media that more than 50 years of urban planning scholarship have appeared since the book, writing that public discourse "has to evolve." He still read on Thursday and said the book resonates because Caro framed it around "one titan, a Caesar."
Caro, a former Newsday reporter who lives on the Upper West Side, is at work on the fifth and final volume of his Lyndon B. Johnson biography. The book gained fresh attention in the pandemic as a backdrop in video calls, and Mayor Zohran Mamdani used it as a prop in a video on his plan to fix the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, while acknowledging he owns a copy and hasn't read it. Caro said in a recent podcast that he doesn't want someone ruthless and dismissive of public opinion, but that the city needs someone who will find a way to get things built.
Citas Notables
People are hungry for grand narratives.— Asad Dandia, Brooklyn borough historian
No matter where you live and what neighborhood you're in, it has somehow been touched by Robert Moses.— Christina Greer, Fordham political science professor