In a New York courtroom, a federal judge has declined to let FIFA's American subsidiaries shield their president from a legal inquiry launched by European soccer's governing body. The question at stake is whether a plan to sell slices of the world's most watched sporting spectacle to private investors was a legitimate commercial strategy or something closer to a personal ambition pursued at the expense of the institution. For now the evidence-gathering can proceed, and the answer will shape how a century-old body balances its commercial appetite against the people it claims to serve. Its next
FIFA Loses Bid to Block UEFA Evidence Gathering Against President Infantino
UEFA can now seek documents from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital
Mark
What actually changed on Thursday?
Mimi
A judge refused to let FIFA's two US subsidiaries block UEFA's evidence gathering. She said they had no legally protectable interest, because the case targets Infantino personally.
Mark
So UEFA gets documents now?
Luke
Not yet. FIFA's lawyers point out the court didn't rule on the merits and no documents are required to be produced. UEFA can now request the right to seek records from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital.
Mimi
Right, it clears a procedural hurdle. The subsidiaries just aren't the right parties to object.
Mark
Why does the judge's reasoning about criminal proceedings matter?
Mimi
She found nothing suggesting FIFA or its US arms would be defendants in a criminal case. That separates the organization from the man, which is what UEFA has been arguing.
Luke
But that's a statement about who could be a defendant, not a finding of wrongdoing. UEFA says it will file in Switzerland only if it finds evidence of financial wrongdoing. None has been presented.
Mark
What about the Kushner connection?
Mimi
Thrive is owned by Joshua Kushner, and UEFA wants to know how it was picked to lead the investor group.
Luke
The source raises the family ties but doesn't allege anything improper about them. The question of how Thrive was chosen is still unanswered.
Mark
And the election?
Mimi
Candidates must declare by November 18. Only Kohzo Tashima has so far, and UEFA is reportedly trying to get Arsene Wenger to run.
Luke
Reportedly is the key word. Wenger hasn't declared, and Infantino still has to clear the integrity check.
El Pulso
- A federal judge in New York has allowed UEFA to pursue evidence about FIFA President Gianni Infantino's abandoned plan to sell World Cup investment stakes.
- UEFA is pressing for Infantino's removal and has said it may file a criminal complaint in Switzerland if the evidence shows financial wrongdoing.
- Documents tied to the FIFA Forward Enterprise deal may now be sought from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital, whose ties to the Kushner family have drawn scrutiny.
- FIFA has called UEFA's legal campaign harassment, while Infantino signals he intends to seek reelection.
- The race tightens toward a November 18 deadline, with UEFA reportedly courting Arsene Wenger as a challenger.
In a New York courtroom, a federal judge has declined to let FIFA's American subsidiaries shield their president from a legal inquiry launched by European soccer's governing body. The question at stake is whether a plan to sell slices of the world's most watched sporting spectacle to private investors was a legitimate commercial strategy or something closer to a personal ambition pursued at the expense of the institution. For now the evidence-gathering can proceed, and the answer will shape how a century-old body balances its commercial appetite against the people it claims to serve. Its next decisive moment arrives on November 18, when challengers must step forward or the old order will have chosen its own successor.
On Thursday, a federal judge in New York turned away an attempt by FIFA's American subsidiaries to block European soccer's governing body from gathering evidence about FIFA President Gianni Infantino. Judge Jeannette Vargas ruled that the subsidiaries had no legally protectable stake in a request aimed squarely at Infantino and his dealings. Her reasoning was that nothing in the record suggested those parties would face criminal proceedings themselves.
At the center of the dispute is the FIFA Forward Enterprise, a proposal to sell minority stakes in the World Cup and other tournaments to private investors. It provoked fierce backlash when it surfaced in July. Three continental confederations rejected it, UEFA threatened to boycott future tournaments, and Infantino was forced to abandon the plan in August. UEFA has since pressed for his ouster, and it can now seek documents from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital, the firm connected to the Kushner family.
Infantino shows no sign of stepping aside and intends to run again. So far only one challenger has declared, and UEFA is reportedly trying to recruit Arsene Wenger, a former Arsenal coach now working under Infantino. Anyone wishing to challenge him must declare by Wednesday, November 18.
On Thursday, a federal judge in New York turned aside an effort by FIFA's American subsidiaries to stop European soccer's governing body from collecting evidence about FIFA President Gianni Infantino. Judge Jeannette Vargas of the Southern District of New York ruled in an eight-page decision that the two subsidiaries had no "direct, substantial and legally protectable interest" in the matter, which is aimed specifically at Infantino and his dealings.
The evidence in question concerns Infantino's attempt to sell stakes in the World Cup and other FIFA tournaments to private investors. UEFA filed for discovery in August, with the stated aim of removing him from office. It has also said that if it finds evidence of financial wrongdoing, it will file a criminal complaint against him in Switzerland.
UEFA is seeking material from Infantino's partners in what was called the FIFA Forward Enterprise, or FFE, a proposal that drew fierce backlash the moment it became public in July. Under the ruling, UEFA can now ask to obtain documents tied to the deal from the US bank JP Morgan and from Thrive Capital. Thrive is owned by Joshua Kushner, the brother of Jared Kushner, who is President Donald Trump's son-in-law, and the son of Charles Kushner, the US ambassador to France. Trump pardoned Charles Kushner, a convicted felon, before appointing him to that post.
Vargas reasoned that nothing in the record showed the US FIFA parties, or FIFA itself, would be parties to any criminal proceedings. In her words, those parties had not alleged facts suggesting they would be defendants. FIFA's lawyers responded that the court had not addressed the merits of UEFA's application and that no documents are required to be produced.
The FFE would have managed FIFA's commercial interests in the World Cup and other competitions, with private investors buying minority stakes. Three continental confederations rejected it, and UEFA threatened to boycott future FIFA tournaments unless it was scrapped. FIFA's 211 member federations, which effectively own the Zurich-based not-for-profit, were each offered $20 million (€18.1 million) to approve the project. Infantino initially pushed back but was forced to abandon the plan in August.
UEFA has not let the matter drop. It has pressed for his ouster and demanded answers about the scheme's details, including how Thrive was chosen to lead the investor group. It has filed discovery requests in multiple states, in what is the biggest challenge Infantino has faced in his 11 years running FIFA. Infantino has been accused of seeking retribution against those who oppose his leadership. In September, FIFA told a judge in Florida, where it has offices in a Miami suburb, that UEFA's legal pursuits amount to harassment of him.
Infantino shows no sign of stepping aside and plans to run for reelection. To do so he must pass an eligibility and integrity check by a FIFA-appointed panel. So far only one person has declared a candidacy: Kohzo Tashima of Japan, who has sat on FIFA's 37-member ruling council since 2016. UEFA is expected to put forward another challenger and is trying to persuade Arsene Wenger, the former Arsenal coach who is now FIFA's head of global development, and thus Infantino's subordinate, to stand against him. Anyone wishing to challenge Infantino must declare by Wednesday, November 18.
Citas Notables
The court has not addressed the merits of UEFA's application and no documents are required to be produced.— FIFA lawyers
Nothing in this record indicates that the US FIFA parties, or even FIFA itself, will be parties in the contemplated criminal proceedings.— Judge Jeannette Vargas
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en Deutsche Welle ↗