On a Wednesday night in Como, a Manchester United side that had barely begun to play was undone by a goal in the second minute and never found its footing again, falling 4-1 in the Champions League. In the quiet aftermath, the club's captain named what many had felt: a team that lacked the nerve to press and carried a mood of defeat onto the pitch. The manager accepted the blame and apologised, placing the failure in effort and purpose rather than in the shape of the side. Against a backdrop of winless league form, the defeat leaves the club to ask what it asks of itself each time it faces a h
Fernandes Questions Carrick's Tactics After United's 4-1 Como Collapse
Conceding early makes us go into the game with a mood of defeat.
Mark
Fernandes didn't exactly attack the manager, did he? Why is this getting so much attention?
Mimi
Because he said the decision not to press man-to-man came from the staff. That puts the tactic on the coaches, and he said it in public, to TNT Sports, right after a 4-1 loss.
Luke
But he also said it was for the manager and staff to judge, not him. He stopped short of calling it a criticism. The headline reading is an interpretation of his words.
Mark
Fair. What about Carrick's response?
Mimi
He took responsibility and apologised. He said it stops with him, and called the performance unacceptable as a supporter would.
Luke
Notably, he blamed intensity and motivation, not the tactical plan. That's a different diagnosis from Fernandes's, at least in emphasis.
Mark
So they disagree?
Luke
We can't say that from this. Fernandes talked about pressing and space. Carrick talked about effort. Those could overlap or not. The reporting doesn't tell us what was said in private.
Mimi
What is clear is the run: winless in seven, three Champions League points from three games.
Mark
And Roma next.
Luke
Whether that is a test of Carrick's position is the outlet's framing. Nothing here says any decision has been made about his job.
The Pulse
- Como struck in the second minute and Manchester United's shape and belief seemed to break at once.
- Captain Bruno Fernandes publicly questioned the decision not to press man-to-man, sending a ripple through the club.
- Michael Carrick took responsibility and apologised, absorbing the criticism rather than contesting it.
- With seven matches without a win and only three Champions League points, the pressure on Carrick is mounting.
- The next test at home to AS Roma will show whether United can press high, win back belief, and answer the doubts.
On a Wednesday night in Como, a Manchester United side that had barely begun to play was undone by a goal in the second minute and never found its footing again, falling 4-1 in the Champions League. In the quiet aftermath, the club's captain named what many had felt: a team that lacked the nerve to press and carried a mood of defeat onto the pitch. The manager accepted the blame and apologised, placing the failure in effort and purpose rather than in the shape of the side. Against a backdrop of winless league form, the defeat leaves the club to ask what it asks of itself each time it faces a hard test.
Como scored in the second minute, and Manchester United never recovered. By the end of Wednesday's Champions League match the visitors had lost 4-1, and only a stoppage-time goal from Joshua Zirkzee softened the scoreline.
Afterward, captain Bruno Fernandes did not hide what he had seen. United started on the wrong foot, he said, with too little pressure on the ball and too little good movement off it. He also questioned the staff's choice not to press man-to-man, warning that giving space to teams like this lets them grow in confidence. Asked whether this was criticism of Michael Carrick, he deferred the judgment to the manager, while insisting that sometimes a team must be braver and press high. An early goal, he added, leaves players with a mood of defeat.
Carrick did not push back. He called the performance more than disappointing, said everyone had to take responsibility, and said the buck stops with him. Speaking as a supporter of the club, he called such a display unacceptable, framed the failure as one of motivation and intensity rather than shape, and apologised.
The defeat deepens the pressure on Carrick. United are winless in seven matches and have three points from three Champions League games. Next comes home action against AS Roma, and with the captain's words now public, that match will be watched for both the result and how United set up to press.
Como scored in the second minute, and Manchester United never recovered. By the end of Wednesday's Champions League match, the visitors had lost 4-1, and the only thing softening the scoreline was a stoppage-time goal from Joshua Zirkzee.
Afterward, captain Bruno Fernandes spoke to TNT Sports and did not hide what he had seen. United, he said, started on the wrong foot and paid for it almost immediately. There was not enough pressure on the ball, he said, and not enough good movement off it. Many things, in his words, were not going United's way.
He was specific about the approach. Fernandes said the coaching staff had decided against pressing man-to-man. The idea was to leave some space behind, wait for Como, and try to win the ball. But he warned that giving space to teams like this one lets them grow in confidence. Asked whether that amounted to criticism of manager Michael Carrick's tactics, he did not quite say yes or no. That, he said, was for the manager and staff to judge, not him. Then he added that sometimes a team has to be braver under pressure, take the risk of pressing high, and make opponents uncomfortable.
Fernandes also pointed to what the early goal did to his teammates' heads. Conceding so soon, he said, sends United into a game with a mood of defeat.
Carrick, who is 45, did not push back. He called the performance more than disappointing and said everyone had to take responsibility. He would take it for the overall team and performance, he said, adding that it stops with him and that he was fine with that. Then he spoke as a supporter of the club, and said that watching a display like that was unacceptable.
The manager framed the failure as one of effort and purpose rather than shape. Motivation, purpose and intensity are what a team has to bring to a football match, he said, and United did not bring them. He apologised for the performance.
The defeat deepens the pressure on Carrick. United are now winless in seven matches. In the Champions League they have three points from their first three games. Their next fixture in the competition is at home against AS Roma, and with the captain's comments now public, that match will be watched for both the result and how United set up to press.
Notable Quotes
Conceding early makes us go into the game with a mood of defeat.— Bruno Fernandes, Manchester United captain, to TNT Sports
I'll take responsibility for the overall team and performance; it stops with me.— Michael Carrick, Manchester United manager, to TNT Sports
Want the full story?
Read the original at Al Jazeera ↗
Sports