Fans Push Back on Slant's Mixed Ocarina of Time Remake Review, Which Trims Metascore From 96 to 95

The only mixed score among 116 reviews
Slant's 3.5/5 review of the Switch 2 Ocarina of Time remake stands alone on Metacritic.
Mark

Why is a single 70 getting this much attention?

Mimi

Because everything around it is so high. Out of 116 critic scores, it's the only mixed one, and it moved the Metascore from 96 to 95.

Luke

Worth saying that a point is a small move. The game is still the top-rated 2026 title on Metacritic.

Mark

Did the timing matter?

Mimi

Fans noticed that Slant published a week after the embargo lifted and after release, when the consensus was already set.

Luke

Fans are accusing the site of chasing attention, but that's an accusation. Nothing in the reporting shows Slant's motive.

Mark

Is this a pattern for Slant?

Mimi

Yes. A 60 for Breath of the Wild, a 70 for Red Dead Redemption 2, a 40 for Sekiro.

Luke

Those show the magazine often diverges from consensus. They don't prove this score was strategic.

Mark

And the remake argument?

Mimi

The critic asked whether another version was necessary, yet he praised the graphics, combat, controls and pace.

Luke

Redditors say he's penalizing the game for industry trends. That's their reading of the review, not something Kronman stated.

  • A lone 70 from Slant Magazine stands apart from a wall of near-universal praise on Metacritic.
  • Fans on Reddit are angry, accusing the critic of marking the game down for a wider industry habit of remaking old titles.
  • The reviewer admits the graphics, combat, controls and pacing are strong, which makes his doubt about whether the game is worth buying feel contradictory.
  • Readers have answered back with a 9.6 user score, which keeps the game at the top of the site despite the criticism.
  • The critic-side Metascore has dipped by only a single point, so the controversy is loud but its numerical effect is small.

A single dissenting note has appeared in an otherwise jubilant chorus around a beloved childhood memory reborn on new hardware. Slant Magazine's 70 stands alone among 116 reviews of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for Switch 2, and it nudged the Metascore from 96 to 95, which remains the year's highest. The disagreement is less about one game than about a familiar question that gathers around every return to a classic: whether a faithful revival earns its place when the original already lives on in other forms, and whether a critic may ask that question aloud without being accused of bad faith.

On Metacritic, one number among the reviews for the Switch 2 remake of Ocarina of Time looks out of place. Slant Magazine gave the game 3.5 out of 5, or 70, the only mixed score on the page, and it lowered the Metascore from 96 to 95. The game's reviews are still overwhelmingly positive, and the 95 is the highest Metascore of any 2026 release on the site. Some fans nonetheless suspect the low score was chosen for attention.

Timing makes the review more conspicuous. Slant published a week after the embargo lifted and after release, when 116 scores had already formed a consensus. The score moved the average only slightly, but some Nintendo supporters were irritated that it cost the game a point.

Slant has a history of scoring against the grain, including a 60 for Breath of the Wild and a 40 for Sekiro. On Reddit, commenters argue that this time the magazine is punishing the Switch 2 game for a broader industry reliance on remakes. The reviewer, Cole Kronman, asks whether another version of the N64 original was needed, noting that it already appeared on 3DS and on Switch Online.

Yet the review is not a pan. Kronman praises the revamped visuals, smoother combat, modern controls and brisker pacing, and calls the remake faithful. His doubt about whether it is worth buying sits uneasily beside that praise, and his claim that the original is only occasionally fun angered longtime fans.

Readers have responded on Metacritic, where the Switch 2 version has survived review bombing and holds a 9.6 user score, the highest on the site. The critic score fell by a single point, and the user score was unaffected.

On Metacritic, one number among the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake reviews looks out of place. Slant Magazine rated the Switch 2 game 3.5 out of 5, which converts to 70 out of 100. It is the only mixed score on the page, and it pulled the game's Metascore down from 96 to 95.

A 95 is still the highest Metascore of any 2026 release on the aggregator, and the reviews overall are near universally positive. Even so, some fans have accused Slant of posting a low score to get attention.

Timing is part of why the review stands out. Slant published a week after the review embargo lifted, and after the game had already been released. By then 116 scores were on Metacritic and a consensus had formed. A 70 landing against that backdrop moved the average only slightly, but it irritated some Nintendo supporters that the number slipped a point.

Slant has a record of scoring against the grain. It gave Zelda: Breath of the Wild a 60, where the Metacritic average is 97. Red Dead Redemption 2 got a 70 from the magazine, still well under its 97 Metascore. The most striking case was a 40 for Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, the 2019 Game of the Year.

On Reddit, commenters argue that Slant is marking the Switch 2 game down for a wider industry habit. Nintendo has leaned more heavily on remakes, as other publishers have. In the review, the writer, Cole Kronman, asks whether another version of the N64 original was needed. The game already came to the 3DS as a 2011 port, and it was later added to the Switch Online catalog on the current-generation console.

The review is not a pan, though. Kronman praises the revamped graphics, the smoother combat and the modernized controls, and calls the remake a faithful adaptation of the classic. He also credits its snappier pace. That makes his skepticism about whether it is worth buying seem at odds with much of what he says about the game itself.

He also angered longtime Zelda fans by describing the original as only occasionally fun.

Metacritic lets readers answer critics with their own ratings, and they have. The Switch 2 version of Ocarina of Time survived review bombing and holds a 9.6 user score, ahead of every other game on the site. The critic score is down a single point from where it started, and the user score is unaffected.

Questioned whether another version of the N64 original was necessary, while praising the graphics, controls and pace.
— Cole Kronman, Slant Magazine (paraphrased)
Contattaci Domande frequenti