In the aftermath of an inconclusive election, Israel's political life has reached a moment where the old question of who belongs in the national story is being argued in public speech. Gadi Eisenkot, a former military chief now tasked with forming a government, has accused Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of stoking a racist campaign against the country's Arab citizens, who make up roughly a fifth of the population. The dispute grew from a Knesset opening speech in which Netanyahu cast Arab lawmakers as supporters of terror, and it touches the founding promise of equal citizenship that Israel
Eisenkot Accuses Netanyahu of Fueling 'Racist' Campaign Against Israel's Arab Citizens
A profound violation of the principles of statesmanship
Why does this statement matter, given that Eisenkot was already endorsed to form a government?
Because it's the strongest language he's used about Netanyahu's attacks on Arab citizens, and it came days after the Knesset speech calling Arab lawmakers "terror supporters." He framed it around the Declaration of Independence.
And the numbers behind it?
Arab citizens are about 20 percent of the population, Arab parties got more than 835,000 votes, and 67 of 120 lawmakers endorsed Eisenkot.
Let me separate things. Is the 67 a coalition?
No. It's an endorsement that gave him a mandate. He has up to six weeks to actually build a ruling coalition.
Then the statement isn't a promise to govern with Arab parties.
Correct. Nadav Eyal said as much, pointing to their refusal to call Hamas a terrorist group.
So who was the statement really for?
Eyal's reading is that it was partly for Arab voters, a signal that he sees what's being done to them. That's one columnist's interpretation.
Right, and Eisenkot hasn't said that himself. Also, Netanyahu's claim that Arab voters stole the election is described as without basis. What's unknown is whether the Hamas condition can be bridged.
Nothing in the reporting says it can. That's the thing to watch.
Der Puls
- A Knesset speech branding Arab lawmakers 'terror supporters' and 'haters of Israel' has ignited fierce condemnation across the political spectrum.
- Gadi Eisenkot, holding a mandate to form a government, has publicly accused Netanyahu of fueling a racist campaign and violating the Declaration of Independence.
- Arab parties, which drew more than 835,000 votes and back Eisenkot's bid to unseat Netanyahu, now sit at the center of a fierce fight over who can govern with whom.
- Eisenkot's demand that any partner label Hamas a terrorist group collides with the Arab parties' refusal, and the clock is running down toward a six-week deadline.
In the aftermath of an inconclusive election, Israel's political life has reached a moment where the old question of who belongs in the national story is being argued in public speech. Gadi Eisenkot, a former military chief now tasked with forming a government, has accused Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of stoking a racist campaign against the country's Arab citizens, who make up roughly a fifth of the population. The dispute grew from a Knesset opening speech in which Netanyahu cast Arab lawmakers as supporters of terror, and it touches the founding promise of equal citizenship that Israel's Declaration of Independence set down. Whether a new coalition can be built across that divide, within six weeks and without the Hamas question being resolved, remains an open and heavy question.
On Friday, Gadi Eisenkot, the former military chief now charged with assembling Israel's next government, posted a statement accusing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of fueling a "racist" campaign against Arab citizens. It was among the sharpest public rebukes he has delivered to his rival on the issue, and it followed days after Netanyahu addressed the new Knesset and described Arab lawmakers as "terror supporters" and "haters of Israel." Diplomats and analysts condemned the speech as incitement. Arab citizens, about 20 percent of the population, voted in large numbers in last month's inconclusive elections.
Eisenkot wrote that Arab citizens are an integral part of the Israeli story and that trying to vilify them collectively betrays the statesmanship and the values of the Declaration of Independence, which promises equal rights regardless of religion, race or sex. His words came after President Isaac Herzog gave him a mandate to form a government, backed by 67 of 120 Knesset members. He now has up to six weeks.
Netanyahu and his allies have claimed, without basis, that Arab voters stole the election. The Arab parties, Raam and the Joint List, which together won more than 835,000 votes, have backed Eisenkot and vowed to remove Netanyahu. Yet a sticking point remains: both parties have condemned the killings of October 7 but refuse to call Hamas a terrorist group, a condition Eisenkot has set for any party joining his government.
A columnist for Yedioth Ahronoth read the statement as a message to Arab voters that their concerns are seen, but cautioned that it does not mean Eisenkot intends to govern with them. The question now is whether he can build a coalition while both sides hold their positions.
On Friday, Gadi Eisenkot, the former military chief now charged with assembling Israel's next government, posted a statement on social media accusing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of fueling a "racist" campaign against the country's Arab citizens. It was among the sharpest public rebukes he has delivered to his rival over the issue.
The statement came days after Mr. Netanyahu addressed the opening session of the new Knesset and described Arab lawmakers as "terror supporters" and "haters of Israel." Diplomats and analysts condemned the speech as a brazen display of hatred and incitement. Arab citizens make up about 20 percent of Israel's population, and they voted in large numbers in last month's elections, which were inconclusive.
Mr. Eisenkot wrote that since the start of the campaign, Arab citizens had been subjected to a racist and aggressive effort at delegitimization, "fueled by the outgoing prime minister and those around him for political purposes." He said Arab citizens are an integral part of the Israeli story and that it was wrong to malign a whole community. Trying to marginalize and vilify them collectively, he said, is a profound violation of the principles of statesmanship and dishonors the Declaration of Independence and the values of a Jewish and democratic state. That document promises all citizens equal social and political rights regardless of religion, race or sex.
The political stakes are immediate. On Sunday, President Isaac Herzog gave Mr. Eisenkot a mandate to try to form a government, after 67 of the Knesset's 120 members endorsed the opposition leader as prime minister. He has up to six weeks to build a ruling coalition.
Mr. Netanyahu and his allies have claimed, without basis, that Arab voters stole the election, after his bloc won fewer seats than his opponents. The Arab parties have backed Mr. Eisenkot's effort and said they are determined to remove Mr. Netanyahu from power. In his speech, Mr. Netanyahu targeted those parties, which together received more than 835,000 votes. "To those thinking about establishing a government with those people, I say — are you ready to be dependent on those whose goal is the destruction of the Jewish state?" he asked.
Two Arab parties cleared the threshold to enter the Knesset. Raam is a pragmatic Islamist party that has tried to broaden its acceptance by focusing on issues facing Arab citizens, such as violent crime and discriminatory housing policies, more than on the situation of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. The Joint List is an alliance of three factions that includes leftists and Palestinian nationalists. It also campaigns for Arab citizens' rights, but it frequently criticizes Israel's treatment of Palestinians and has called itself "a genuine democratic alternative to the racist Zionist consensus."
A sticking point remains. Mansour Abbas, Raam's chairman, has described the Hamas-led attack of Oct. 7, 2023, as "saddening, heartbreaking," and Joint List officials have denounced the killing of civilians that day. But neither party will call Hamas a terrorist group, which Mr. Eisenkot has said is a condition for any party that wants to join a government under his leadership.
Nadav Eyal, a leading columnist for the centrist newspaper Yedioth Ahronoth, read the statement as a pushback against Mr. Netanyahu's attempts to delegitimize any cooperation with Arab parties. He also saw a message aimed at Arab voters: "He's telling them, 'I see you and I see what they're trying to do you and your representatives.'" Mr. Eyal cautioned, however, that the remarks did not mean Mr. Eisenkot intends to govern with Arab parties' support, especially when "they have trouble saying Hamas is a terrorist organization."
With six weeks on the clock, the question is whether Mr. Eisenkot can assemble a coalition while holding to his Hamas condition and the Arab parties holding to their position.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
Arab citizens of Israel are an integral part of the Israeli story.— Gadi Eisenkot
Eisenkot's statement pushed back on efforts to delegitimize cooperation with Arab parties, but does not mean he plans to rely on them.— Nadav Eyal, Yedioth Ahronoth columnist (paraphrase)