On a wet Wednesday afternoon in Flatbush, Brooklyn, an old three-story apartment house on Flatbush Avenue folded into the excavation pit beside it, and by the time the search ended a day later, eight lives had been lost, two of them children. The loss lands in a neighborhood where many families have arrived from far away to build small, hard-won lives, and it asks a familiar question of any city that grows by digging: who was responsible for the ground beneath people's homes. The answer is still being pieced together from inspection records, permits, and the testimony of those who were there,
Eight Dead as Flatbush Building Collapses Beside Brooklyn Excavation; Stop-Work Order Issued
Eight people, including two children, were killed and 18 others were injured, and many nearby residents remain displaced.
Eight dead, 18 injured, and a crack noted in March
Mark
Eight people died. Why is the March inspection getting so much attention?
Mimi
Because it names the building that later fell. An inspection tied to the construction site described its north facade as in poor condition with noticeable cracks, and work appears to have continued.
Luke
"Appears" matters there. The reporting doesn't establish that anyone saw that report and decided to proceed, or that the cracks had anything to do with the collapse.
Mark
So what is actually known about the cause?
Mimi
Nothing official. Excavation was underway next door, but the Department of Buildings and police are still investigating.
Luke
And the complaint about over-excavation was anonymous, filed after the collapse. It's an allegation, not a finding. The sandy soil and high groundwater are the complainant's description.
Mark
Who were the victims?
Mimi
Two elementary-school-age cousins, construction workers from Ecuador and Guatemala, and a young man from Guinea. Eight in all, from 9 to 31.
Luke
Worth noting the names come from an internal police report and families and friends, not an official release. The mayor confirmed the count of six adults and two children.
Mark
What does the city say it will do?
Mimi
A full stop-work order, a look at five entities tied to the project, and sweeps of 100 other sites.
Luke
Those are plans. Whether any entity is found responsible is still unknown.
Der Puls
- A 911 call at 4:01 p.m. on Wednesday reported a three-story Flatbush building collapsing into a neighboring construction site, and the tension of a day-long search began.
- Rescuers worked through the night with dogs, drones, helicopters and excavators while rain flooded the pit, racing against time to reach anyone still buried.
- The rescue ended Thursday with eight dead and eighteen injured, and the site passed from firefighters to police and building investigators.
- A March inspection had flagged cracks in the collapsed building's facade, yet digging continued next door, and an anonymous complaint now alleges excess excavation.
- A stop-work order is in place, five linked entities are under scrutiny, and the city plans to sweep 100 related sites while displaced families wait for answers.
On a wet Wednesday afternoon in Flatbush, Brooklyn, an old three-story apartment house on Flatbush Avenue folded into the excavation pit beside it, and by the time the search ended a day later, eight lives had been lost, two of them children. The loss lands in a neighborhood where many families have arrived from far away to build small, hard-won lives, and it asks a familiar question of any city that grows by digging: who was responsible for the ground beneath people's homes. The answer is still being pieced together from inspection records, permits, and the testimony of those who were there, and the city has chosen to keep the question open rather than close it early.
At 4:01 on Wednesday afternoon, a 911 call reported that a three-story apartment building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue had collapsed, largely falling into the construction site next door. Built in 1930 and home to four apartments, it sheared open the wall of a neighbor, leaving a staircase and bedroom exposed to the sky. Rescuers searched through the night and into Thursday with dogs, drones, helicopters and excavators, under a heavy rain that filled the pit with water. When the Fire Department called off the search just before 4 p.m. Thursday, eight people were dead and eighteen were injured.
The dead included two children, elementary-school cousins, construction workers from Ecuador and Guatemala, and a young man from Guinea. Four firefighters were among the injured, and onlookers recalled a toddler being pulled from the rubble. A pregnant woman whose husband had been searching for her was lifted from a pit and taken to a hospital. Flatbush is home to many immigrants, and many neighbors remain displaced.
The paper trail is what troubles investigators. A March inspection of the collapsed building described its north facade as in poor condition with noticeable cracks, yet work at the neighboring excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue continued. After the collapse, an anonymous complaint said the subcontractor may have dug too much along the neighboring foundation in sandy, waterlogged soil. Mayor Zohran Mamdani said he was incredibly troubled that the work went on, and promised full accountability. A reception center has opened at the Flatbush Y.M.C.A., and the investigation into the excavation, the March warning and the five linked entities is only beginning.
At 4:01 p.m. on Wednesday, the Fire Department got a 911 call reporting a building collapse at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn. A three-story apartment building, built in 1930 and home to four apartments, had come down and largely fallen into the neighboring construction site. By the time the search ended the next afternoon, eight people were dead and 18 were injured, according to Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
The building stood in the Little Haiti section of Flatbush, on an avenue lined with shops. The collapse sheared off the adjoining wall of a neighboring building, leaving a staircase, a bedroom and closets open to the air. Rescuers worked through the night and into Thursday with canine units, drones, helicopters, fire trucks and excavation machinery. A heavy rainstorm left shin-high pools of water at the site. Just before 4 p.m. Thursday, after nearly 24 hours, the Fire Department announced at 3:37 p.m. that it had ended its rescue efforts and that no more victims were being sought. The site was handed to the Police Department and the Department of Buildings to investigate.
Mr. Mamdani confirmed that six adults and two children died. Six were killed when the building fell, and two more died of their injuries at nearby hospitals. The city had not officially released names, but an internal police report and relatives and friends identified the dead as Nicole Daniela Salvala Rodriguez, 9; Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10; Gabriel Siguencia, 22; Mamadou Bhoye Barry, 23; Mamadou Bhoye N'Diaye, 31; Edgar Santiago Sapón Gutierrez, 26; José Luis Caguana, 26; and Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, 31. They included elementary-school-age cousins, construction workers from Ecuador and Guatemala, and a young man from Guinea.
Eighteen people were injured, four of them firefighters, and at least one person remained in critical condition Thursday. Onlookers said they saw responders pull a toddler from the rubble. On Wednesday, a woman six months pregnant, whose husband had been searching for her, was lifted from a pit and taken to a hospital. Flatbush is home to many immigrants.
The cause is not yet known, but the paper trail raises questions. The building next door was an active excavation site at 2625 Bedford Avenue, where the city had approved plans for a three-story building. Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani told reporters workers were digging there when the collapse happened, and the developers held an active permit for excavation and foundation work.
City records show that an inspection tied to the construction site, filed with the Buildings Department in March, described the collapsed building's north facade as in "poor condition with noticeable cracks." Construction appears to have continued anyway. After the collapse, on Wednesday night, an anonymous complaint said the subcontractor "may have excavated too much of the area along the neighboring foundation," on a site with sandy soil and high groundwater. It is unclear who filed it, and the department said it is investigating. Engineers are also inspecting the stability of nearby buildings.
Mr. Mamdani said he was "incredibly troubled" that work went on despite the warnings, and a full stop-work order is in place at the site. The Buildings Department has identified five entities associated with the project, and officials plan to sweep 100 other sites those groups are involved with. "If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable," he said.
Many residents near the site remain displaced indefinitely, though some farther south on Flatbush Avenue have gone home. The city's emergency management agency and the American Red Cross opened a reception center at the Flatbush Y.M.C.A., 1401 Flatbush Avenue. People unable to reach someone they fear was affected can call 311, or 212-639-9675 from outside the city. The investigation into the excavation, the March inspection and the five entities is what to watch next.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable.— Mayor Zohran Mamdani
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei The New York Times ↗