In the southern Japanese city of Nagasaki, a member of the Bank of Japan's board, Toichiro Asada, made a case for patience: that lifting borrowing costs too quickly could blunt a fragile recovery and weaken the very inflation the bank is trying to secure. His caution rests on a reading of the moment in which rising prices are driven more by costly energy and a weak yen than by genuine demand, and in which Japan's policy rate is entering the band where it neither cools nor heats the economy. It is a familiar tension in the long human effort to tame prices without strangling growth, now playing
Dovish BOJ Board Member Asada Urges Caution on Rate Hikes, Warns of Growth Risks
Price increases "not necessarily driven by demand factors"
Mark
Asada has dissented twice already. Why does this speech matter now?
Mimi
Because it explains the dissents in public. He's saying recent price rises aren't driven by demand, and consumption is lacking momentum, so hiking quickly risks hurting growth.
Luke
Worth noting that's his reading of the data. The speech doesn't show the other board members are wrong, only that they weigh it differently.
Mark
And the other side?
Mimi
October's summary of opinions showed some members wanted faster hikes to fight price pressures. The bank also declared victory on its 14-year price target and flagged upside risks.
Mark
So there's a real rift.
Luke
A rift in views, yes. How deep it runs, we don't know. The summary says "some" policymakers, not how many.
Mark
What about the neutral rate range?
Mimi
Staff estimate 1.1 to 2.5 per cent. Asada says the risk of cooling growth rises once policy is inside it, and that earlier hikes take at least a year to show up.
Luke
That's a wide range, and the lag is his estimate. Also, analysts polling at 1.5 per cent in December is a forecast, not a decision.
Mark
And the politics?
Mimi
Prime Minister Takaichi nominated Asada and Sato, and she has warned against hike plans before.
Luke
The nominations are fact. Any link between her views and their votes isn't established in this reporting.
Der Puls
- A dovish voice on the Bank of Japan board is pushing back against the momentum toward further rate hikes, and the disagreement is now out in the open.
- Asada has dissented on both the June and September increases, and his speech signals he will keep questioning the pace.
- Governor Kazuo Ueda must hold a divided board together while inflation pressures from energy costs and a weak yen remain stubborn.
- Markets expect a December hike to 1.5 percent, with a terminal rate near 1.75 to 2 percent, so the tightening path looks set to continue and the board's unity is the open question.
In the southern Japanese city of Nagasaki, a member of the Bank of Japan's board, Toichiro Asada, made a case for patience: that lifting borrowing costs too quickly could blunt a fragile recovery and weaken the very inflation the bank is trying to secure. His caution rests on a reading of the moment in which rising prices are driven more by costly energy and a weak yen than by genuine demand, and in which Japan's policy rate is entering the band where it neither cools nor heats the economy. It is a familiar tension in the long human effort to tame prices without strangling growth, now playing out among officials who must act on effects that will not fully arrive for another year.
On Thursday in Nagasaki, Bank of Japan board member Toichiro Asada told business leaders that raising interest rates too soon could hurt growth and push underlying inflation back down. He is one of the board's doves and has voted against both the June and September hikes. In his view, consumption lacks momentum, and recent price increases stem more from costs than from strong demand, so any tightening should be paced carefully.
Asada also argued that policy has now entered the 1.1 to 2.5 percent range that staff consider neutral, where the risk of slowing growth grows larger. Financial conditions remain supportive, but that support is gradually fading, and the effects of earlier hikes will take at least a year to show.
His speech points to a split on the board that could complicate Governor Kazuo Ueda's work. Some members want faster increases to counter mounting price pressure, and the bank has recently declared victory over its long fight to reach its price target. Markets, however, expect continued tightening, with a hike to 1.5 percent in December. Whether Ueda can keep the board aligned on that pace, and whether Asada's dissents multiply, will shape what comes next.
On Thursday, in the southern Japanese city of Nagasaki, Bank of Japan board member Toichiro Asada stood before a room of business leaders and argued against moving too quickly on interest rates. Raising them prematurely, he said, could hurt growth and push down underlying inflation.
Asada is one of the board's doves. He dissented when the BOJ raised rates in June and again in September. His speech laid out why. The economy, he said, is growing moderately, and underlying inflation is hovering around the bank's 2 per cent target. But recent data, in his reading, show consumption lacking momentum.
His central argument concerned the nature of the price rises. "I believe the recent price increases have not necessarily been driven by demand factors," he told the audience. From that he drew a conclusion about timing: the bank, he said, needs to give due consideration to the pace of any policy rate hikes, and avoid cooling growth by going too fast.
He also pointed to where policy now sits. The BOJ's policy rate has entered the range of 1.1 per cent to 2.5 per cent, which bank staff estimate as Japan's neutral rate, where policy is seen neither cooling nor overheating growth. Asada said the risk of hikes dampening growth becomes larger once rates are inside that band. Financial conditions remain accommodative, he said, but the degree of monetary support appears to be gradually diminishing. The effects of earlier hikes, he added, will likely show up with a lag of at least a year.
The speech exposes a split on the policy board that could complicate Governor Kazuo Ueda's task of building consensus on how fast to proceed. At its review last month the BOJ held rates steady, but a summary of opinions from that meeting showed some members wanted to raise borrowing costs faster to counter mounting price pressures. In October the bank also declared victory in its 14-year fight to hit its price target and flagged upside risks to prices, reinforcing a hawkish lean.
The pressures behind the hawks are real. Stubbornly high energy costs and rising import prices from a weak yen have added to inflation. The BOJ raised rates in September, only a few months after June, a shorter gap than the rough pace of two hikes a year seen across 2024 and 2025.
Asada joined the board this year, as did fellow dove Ayano Sato, who also voted against the September increase. Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi nominated both. She has in the past warned against the BOJ's rate-hike plans.
Markets are leaning toward continued tightening. Analysts polled by Reuters expect the BOJ to lift its policy rate to 1.5 per cent in December and keep to a quarterly rhythm. Most of them see the terminal rate at 1.75 per cent or 2 per cent. What to watch is whether Ueda can hold the board together on that pace as rates climb into the neutral range, and whether Asada's dissents grow in number.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
I believe the recent price increases have not necessarily been driven by demand factors.— Toichiro Asada, BOJ board member
I consider it necessary for the Bank to give due consideration to the pace of any policy rate hikes.— Toichiro Asada, BOJ board member
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei CNA ↗