Do You Really Need Laundry Sanitiser? Experts Say Only in Specific Situations

Unless the oil is removed, the smell tends to come back
RMIT's Saniyat Islam on why sanitiser alone doesn't solve persistent laundry odours.
Mark

So the headline is that most people don't need laundry sanitiser. Why not, if it kills 99.9 per cent of germs?

Mimi

Because the wash and the drying already remove most microbes, especially if the clothes dry in the sun. Islam says the sanitiser adds cost, chemicals and residue with little extra health benefit for most people.

Luke

Worth noting the 99.9 per cent figure is the marketing claim. The experts don't verify it in this piece.

Mark

What does the residue actually do?

Mimi

Quats stick to fabric like softener. Towels get less absorbent and sportswear loses moisture-wicking. Fragrance and residue can irritate skin or aggravate eczema.

Luke

Those effects are described as happening over time. No rates or study figures are given, so we can't say how quickly or how often.

Mark

And when is it worth using?

Mimi

Infection in the house, immunocompromised, elderly or newborn members, bodily-fluid soiling, cold-only fabrics, and shared machines. Not gastro, though. Hot wash beats it there.

Mark

Does it fix smells?

Mimi

Partly. It kills bacteria like Moraxella behind the wet-towel smell, but it doesn't remove oils and sweat, so the smell can come back.

Luke

The antimicrobial resistance point is stated as a concern from Islam, not quantified. How much household use contributes is left unexplained.

  • A popular rinse-cycle product is being questioned as it spreads through Australian homes, promising to kill 99.9 per cent of bacteria.
  • Experts warn that repeated use leaves residue that can make towels less absorbent, dull sportswear's moisture-wicking, and irritate sensitive skin.
  • Concern is mounting over the role of regular low-level antimicrobial use in the growing problem of antimicrobial resistance.
  • Hot washes at 60 degrees, enzyme detergents, oxygen bleach and prompt drying are being pushed as the reliable route to clean and fresh-smelling fabrics.
  • The advice is settling on a clear boundary: save sanitiser for illness, vulnerable household members, soiled items and shared machines.

In many Australian laundries, a bottle of sanitiser waits beside the detergent, promising to strip away bacteria with every rinse. Two university experts now gently suggest that the promise is narrower than it sounds: most households do not need it for everyday washing, and its residue and contribution to resistance carry quiet costs. Their counsel, that sanitiser belongs to the particular moments of illness, vulnerability and shared use, returns an ordinary chore to a familiar wisdom about using the strongest tools only when they are truly called for.

Many Australian households pour laundry sanitiser into the softener compartment or the drum without a second thought. The products are sold on a simple promise: they remove 99.9 per cent of bacteria and viruses, including the bacteria behind stubborn odour. Their popularity is growing, but two university experts say they should not be part of a regular routine.

RMIT's Associate Professor Saniyat Islam explains that most sanitisers rely on quaternary ammonium compounds, which bind to bacterial membranes and break them open. They work against flu, coronavirus and most bacteria, but not against bacterial spores or norovirus. That same chemistry leaves a film on fabric, much like softener does. Towels grow less absorbent, sportswear loses its wicking, and fragrance or residue can aggravate sensitive skin and eczema.

For most loads, the experts say, sanitiser adds cost and chemicals with little real benefit, since washing and drying already remove most microbes. Islam also warns that routine low-level antimicrobial use feeds antimicrobial resistance. The product earns its place in specific cases: when someone in the home is unwell or immunocompromised, when items are soiled with bodily fluids, when machines are shared, or when delicate fabrics must be washed cold. After gastro, a hot wash is the better choice.

For odour, which is the main reason many people buy sanitiser, UTS's Associate Professor Cindy Gunawan notes that bacteria such as Moraxella can survive ordinary washing and cause the wet-towel smell. Sanitiser can help with those, but it does not remove oils, sweat or dirt, and the smell often returns. Hot washes, enzyme detergents, half a cup of vinegar or baking soda, oxygen bleach pre-soaks, and prompt drying tend to work better, saving sanitiser for the moments that truly need it.

The product sits in a lot of Australian laundries, poured into the fabric softener compartment or straight into the drum during the rinse cycle. Laundry sanitisers are usually sold on a single promise: they remove 99.9 per cent of bacteria, including the kind that cause odour, along with viruses. They are growing in popularity. Two university experts who spoke to nine.com.au say they shouldn't be part of a regular routine.

Associate Professor Saniyat Islam, of RMIT University's School of Fashion and Textiles, explained how they work. Most household products are rinse-cycle additives built on quaternary ammonium compounds, known as quats, such as benzalkonium chloride. Quats carry a positive charge and are drawn to the negatively charged outer membranes of bacteria. Once attached, they disrupt the membrane, the cell contents leak out and the microbe dies. That makes them effective against flu, coronavirus and most bacteria. They do not work on bacterial spores or on norovirus, which causes gastroenteritis.

The cost of that action is what stays behind. Islam said quats deposit on fabric much as fabric softener does. Over time, towels can become less absorbent and technical sportswear can lose its moisture-wicking performance. The residue and added fragrance can also irritate sensitive skin or aggravate conditions such as eczema.

For most loads, the experts say, the product isn't needed. Washing removes most microbes, and drying removes more, particularly when clothes hang outside in the sun. Islam said adding sanitiser to every load means extra cost, extra chemicals going down the drain and more residue on fabrics and skin, with little added health benefit for most people. He also raised regular, low-level use of antimicrobials as a concern because of its contribution to antimicrobial resistance.

There are situations where it earns its place. Islam named a household member who is unwell with an infection, someone who is immunocompromised, elderly or a newborn, items soiled with bodily fluids, and shared or communal machines. It also makes sense when something that would normally go in a hot wash has to be cleaned cold because of fabric or care-label limits. The exception is gastro: after a case in the household, a hot wash is more effective against that virus, given how sanitisers work.

Alternatives exist. Islam said washing at 60 degrees or above with a good detergent is among the most reliable options for towels, sheets, underwear and cotton items that can take the heat, and many machines have a dedicated hygiene or sanitise cycle. He also recommended oxygen bleach (sodium percarbonate) in warm or hot water for colour-safe items, and chlorine bleach for white cotton or where the care label allows.

Many people buy sanitiser for smell. Associate Professor Cindy Gunawan, of the Australian Institute for Microbiology and Infection at the University of Technology Sydney, said that has a rational basis. Persistent odours on towels, sportswear and synthetic fabrics often come from bacteria that survive ordinary washing, such as Moraxella species, behind the "wet towel" smell. Killing them can reduce or eliminate the odour. But she said sanitiser is not a complete or always necessary fix, because it does not remove dirt, oils or sweat residues. Islam added that unless the oil is removed, the smell tends to return once the garment warms against the body.

The experts' suggestions for odour include a hot wash where the fabric allows, half a cup of white vinegar in the rinse cycle or half a cup of baking soda in the wash, enzyme-containing detergents, and pre-soaking in oxygen bleach. Moving washing to the line or dryer promptly after a cycle helps, as does washing sweaty items quickly or at least airing them before they go in the hamper. The advice points toward saving sanitiser for the specific cases above.

Adding a sanitiser to every load brings extra cost, extra chemicals going down the drain, and more residue on fabrics and skin, with little added health benefit for most people.
— Associate Professor Saniyat Islam, RMIT University
Sanitiser is not a complete or always necessary solution for odours. It does not remove dirt, oils, sweat residues.
— Associate Professor Cindy Gunawan, University of Technology Sydney
Envie de l'histoire complète ? Lire l'original sur Nine.com.au ↗
Nous contacter FAQ