Each generation learns anew that the mind, like the body, keeps its own calendar, and that forgetting a name is not the same as losing one's way home. In New Delhi, on a late October day, a group of geriatric specialists spoke to the public about that difference, urging families not to dismiss persistent memory lapses as the ordinary price of age. Their concern is shaped by a growing population of older Indians and by new treatments that make an early, careful diagnosis more consequential than it once was. What they ask for is patience: a pattern observed over time, a thorough look for treatab
Dementia Is Not Normal Ageing: Experts Urge Families to Act on Persistent Memory Loss
Not every forgotten name should cause alarm, but persistent memory loss must not be ignored.
What is the simplest way to tell normal forgetting from something more serious?
The doctors keep coming back to function. Misplacing spectacles is ordinary. Asking the same question within minutes, or getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood, is not.
Dr Dutta talked about patterns rather than single incidents. Why?
One bad day proves little. What worries her is someone who managed the household for years and now struggles with it, misses appointments, or can't handle routine money matters.
Worth saying that nobody here claims a family can diagnose this at home. Dr Chakrawarty is explicit that no single test or symptom is enough.
Right, and that's why he lists history from a relative, a medicines review, a neurological exam and screening tools like the Mini-Cog and MoCA.
And some of the causes are treatable?
Yes. Depression, sleep disorders, medication side-effects, B12 or thyroid problems can all affect memory. That's an argument for getting checked, not for assuming the worst.
The article mentions lecanemab and donanemab, but only for eligible patients with early Alzheimer's and in certain settings. It doesn't say how available they are in India, so I wouldn't read that as a promise of treatment.
So what is the practical advice for families?
Be patient, avoid confrontation, write down what you observe, and bring a relative who knows the person well to the appointment.
One more gap: the piece gives no figures on how many people in India are affected. The ageing population is cited as context, not measured.
Il Polso
- Forgetting where the spectacles are is forgiven, but asking the same question again within minutes is the sign families are being told not to ignore.
- Experts warn that the habit of blaming every lapse on old age is quietly delaying diagnoses that could come sooner.
- A full evaluation is being pressed for, with cognitive screening, blood tests and brain imaging, because depression, poor sleep and medicine side-effects can mimic dementia.
- New biomarkers and drugs such as lecanemab and donanemab are raising the stakes, turning early recognition from a courtesy into a race against progression.
- The message is landing as a call to watch for patterns, write down changes and bring a close relative to the consultation before daily life begins to break down.
Each generation learns anew that the mind, like the body, keeps its own calendar, and that forgetting a name is not the same as losing one's way home. In New Delhi, on a late October day, a group of geriatric specialists spoke to the public about that difference, urging families not to dismiss persistent memory lapses as the ordinary price of age. Their concern is shaped by a growing population of older Indians and by new treatments that make an early, careful diagnosis more consequential than it once was. What they ask for is patience: a pattern observed over time, a thorough look for treatable causes, and a dignified response that lets the person and those who care for them face what is coming with understanding rather than denial.
On October 26, three geriatric specialists in New Delhi made a simple but urgent point: forgetfulness may come with age, yet persistent memory loss is not part of growing old. Repeated questions, struggles with familiar tasks and a steady slide in everyday functioning can signal dementia, and families should not wave these signs away.
Dr Harjit Singh Bhatti of Sitaram Bhartia Institute drew the line clearly. Misplaced spectacles are ordinary; getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood, forgetting important conversations or fumbling household routines are not. Unexplained money mistakes, trouble managing medicines, and sudden irritability or apathy also deserve medical attention.
Dr Shelly Dutta of RML Hospital urged families to look for progressive change rather than judging from a single incident. Her test is whether memory problems interfere with running daily life. She warned that stigma and the reflex to blame age can delay diagnosis and make caregiving harder. Her advice was practical: approach the person with patience and dignity, avoid confrontation, keep notes on what you notice, and bring someone who knows them well to the doctor.
Dr Avinash Chakrawarty of AIIMS stressed that no single test settles the question. A proper assessment includes history from the person and a family member, a medicine review, neurological examination, standard screening tools and, where needed, blood tests and brain imaging. This thoroughness matters because several treatable conditions can mimic dementia. He also outlined the main types, from Alzheimer's disease, the most common, to vascular, Lewy body and frontotemporal dementia.
Bhatti added that new blood-based biomarkers and disease-modifying treatments for eligible early Alzheimer's patients have made timely diagnosis more important. As India's older population expands, the experts' message was consistent: not every forgotten name signals trouble, but persistent and progressive memory loss must not be ignored. Early recognition, Bhatti said, helps families reach appropriate care, plan for safety and support caregivers with understanding and dignity.
On October 26, in New Delhi, three geriatric specialists made the same point to PTI: forgetfulness can come with age, but persistent memory loss is not a normal part of growing old. They said repeated questions, trouble with familiar tasks and a steady decline in everyday functioning can signal dementia, and families should not wave them away.
Dr Harjit Singh Bhatti, consultant in geriatric medicine at Sitaram Bhartia Institute of Science and Research, drew the line plainly. Misplacing spectacles or taking longer to recall a name can happen with ordinary ageing. Dementia looks different: asking the same question again within minutes, forgetting an important conversation, getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood, or struggling with routine household work. He added that unexplained financial mistakes, difficulty managing medicines, language problems, and unusual suspicion, irritability or apathy also warrant medical evaluation.
Dr Shelly Dutta, Associate Professor of Medicine at RML Hospital, urged families to look for a pattern of progressive change rather than judge from one incident. Her test is whether forgetfulness interferes with managing daily life. Someone who has run a household independently for years and suddenly struggles with familiar tasks, repeatedly misses appointments or cannot handle routine financial transactions should be seen by a doctor. She said stigma, and the habit of blaming every cognitive change on old age, can delay diagnosis and make caregiving harder.
Dutta also offered practical advice. Families should approach the person with patience and dignity, avoid confrontation, and write down the changes they notice. A relative who knows the person well can give valuable information at a consultation, and early assessment gives families time to understand the condition, discuss safety and plan long-term support.
Dr Avinash Chakrawarty, Head of Geriatric Medicine at the National Centre for Ageing at AIIMS, Delhi, said diagnosis cannot rest on a single memory test or an isolated symptom. A proper assessment includes a detailed history from the individual and a close family member, a review of medicines, a neurological examination, and an evaluation of how cognitive changes affect daily activities. Doctors may use validated screening tools such as the Mini-Cog, the Mini-Mental State Examination and the Montreal Cognitive Assessment. Depending on the findings, blood tests for vitamin B12, thyroid function and metabolic abnormalities may follow, along with brain imaging where indicated.
That thoroughness matters, Chakrawarty said, because depression, sleep disorders, medication side-effects and certain medical conditions can also affect memory and concentration, and some of these causes are treatable. Not every instance of forgetfulness is dementia. He described dementia as an umbrella term for conditions that cause cognitive decline severe enough to affect independent functioning. Alzheimer's disease is the most common cause. Vascular dementia can follow damage to the brain's blood vessels. Dementia with Lewy bodies may involve visual hallucinations, fluctuating alertness and movement-related symptoms, and frontotemporal dementia can first appear as changes in personality, behaviour or language.
Bhatti said people who repeat questions, lose memory progressively, lose independence, or show cognitive changes alongside unexplained falls should seek assessment, especially if they have multiple illnesses or take several medicines. He noted that advances in blood-based biomarkers, brain imaging and disease-modifying treatments, including lecanemab and donanemab for eligible patients with early Alzheimer's disease in certain settings, have raised the importance of timely diagnosis.
The experts framed the push against the backdrop of India's expanding older population. Early recognition, they said, allows timely assessment, identification of treatable conditions, care planning and support for families. Bhatti summed it up: not every forgotten name should cause alarm, but persistent and progressive memory loss must not be ignored. Dementia cannot always be prevented, he said, but early recognition helps families reach appropriate care, plan for safety and support caregivers with greater understanding and dignity.
Citazioni salienti
Repeatedly asking the same question within minutes, forgetting an important conversation, getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood or struggling with routine household tasks are warning signs.— Dr Harjit Singh Bhatti, Sitaram Bhartia Institute of Science and Research
Families should approach the person with patience and dignity, avoid confrontation and document the changes they observe.— Dr Shelly Dutta, RML Hospital