In a country where the number of elders is climbing and households are quietly absorbing new kinds of loss, a few geriatric specialists are asking families to learn the difference between ordinary forgetfulness and the slow erosion that signals dementia. Their argument turns less on any single lapse than on a pattern: a person who once managed a home with ease beginning to stumble over what was once routine. They also remind listeners that not every fog of memory is the same illness, since depression, poor sleep and certain medicines can cloud the mind and often can be treated. The message, of
Dementia Is Not a Normal Part of Ageing, Experts Urge Families to Act on Early Signs
Misplacing spectacles is one thing; repeating the same question within minutes is another.
Mark
What's the simplest test the doctors are offering families?
Mimi
Whether it gets in the way of daily life. Dr Dutta says someone who has managed the household for years and suddenly can't handle familiar tasks or money needs to be seen.
Luke
Worth noting that's guidance, not a diagnostic rule. Nothing here says one sign confirms dementia.
Mark
Why do they stress a full evaluation rather than a quick memory test?
Mimi
Dr Chakrawarty says a single test or symptom isn't enough. History from a family member, a medicines review, a neurological exam, and blood tests all feed in.
Mark
And some causes are treatable?
Mimi
Yes: depression, sleep disorders, medicine side-effects and certain medical conditions can affect memory.
Luke
Though the piece doesn't say how often forgetfulness turns out to be one of those causes. No figures are given.
Mark
What role does the family play?
Mimi
Dutta suggests patience, no confrontation, and written notes of what they observe, which a doctor can use.
Luke
Also, the article gives no data on India's dementia numbers or access to specialists. The urgency is stated, not quantified.
Il Polso
- A repeated question asked twice within minutes is becoming the signal families are being urged to take seriously.
- Doctors warn that stigma and the habit of blaming old age are delaying diagnoses and making caregiving harder for households already stretched thin.
- A full clinical workup, including history from a close relative, medicine review, neurological exam and blood tests, is being pressed as the path to separating dementia from treatable mimics.
- Depression, sleep disorders and medication side-effects can imitate dementia, so early assessment may uncover causes that can be reversed.
- As India's elderly population grows, families are being pushed to plan support and safety before the decline deepens.
In a country where the number of elders is climbing and households are quietly absorbing new kinds of loss, a few geriatric specialists are asking families to learn the difference between ordinary forgetfulness and the slow erosion that signals dementia. Their argument turns less on any single lapse than on a pattern: a person who once managed a home with ease beginning to stumble over what was once routine. They also remind listeners that not every fog of memory is the same illness, since depression, poor sleep and certain medicines can cloud the mind and often can be treated. The message, offered as India's population ages, is that noticing early and looking carefully can open the door to care, clarity and better planning for everyone who lives alongside the person affected.
Forgetting where the spectacles were left is something most people recognise. Asking the same question twice within a few minutes is something else, and three Indian geriatric specialists want families to learn to tell the two apart. Dementia is becoming a more familiar presence in homes as the older population grows, and the doctors say the earliest signs are often easy to dismiss.
Dr Harjit Singh Bhatti of Sitaram Bhartia Institute pointed to the warning signs that set dementia apart from ordinary ageing: forgetting an important conversation, getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood, struggling with household routines, unexplained money mistakes, trouble managing medicines, or sudden changes in mood and suspicion. Dr Shelly Dutta of RML Hospital urged families to watch for a progressive pattern rather than judge from one incident, asking whether forgetfulness is interfering with daily life. She also warned that stigma and the habit of blaming age can delay care, and advised patience, dignity, written notes of changes, and the input of a relative who knows the person well.
Dr Avinash Chakrawarty of AIIMS described what a proper assessment involves. It cannot rest on a single test: it needs a detailed history, a review of medicines, a neurological examination, screening tools and, where needed, blood work and brain imaging. He stressed that depression, sleep problems and medication effects can mimic dementia and are often treatable, so not every lapse should be labelled as dementia. Dementia itself is an umbrella term, with Alzheimer's the most common cause, followed by vascular, Lewy body and frontotemporal forms, each with its own early signs.
The experts' shared message is that early recognition brings timely assessment, a chance to treat what can be treated, and time for families to plan for the years ahead.
Misplacing your spectacles is one thing. Asking the same question twice within a few minutes is another. That is the line three Indian geriatric specialists are asking families to learn to see, as the country's older population grows and dementia becomes a more common presence in households.
Dr Harjit Singh Bhatti, a consultant in geriatric medicine at Sitaram Bhartia Institute of Science and Research, said that occasionally forgetting where an object was put, or taking a little longer to recall a name, can happen in normal ageing. The warning signs, he said, look different: forgetting an important conversation, getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood, or struggling with routine household tasks. He added that unexplained financial mistakes, trouble managing medicines, language problems, and unusual suspicion, irritability or apathy also call for medical evaluation.
Dr Shelly Dutta, Associate Professor of Medicine at RML Hospital, urged families to look for a pattern of progressive change rather than judge from one incident. The question she said matters is whether forgetfulness is interfering with managing daily life. Someone who has run a household independently for years and suddenly struggles with familiar tasks, repeatedly misses appointments or cannot handle routine financial transactions should be seen by a doctor, she said.
Dutta also pointed to stigma and the habit of putting every cognitive change down to old age. Both, she said, can delay diagnosis and make caregiving harder. Her advice to families was practical: approach the person with patience and dignity, avoid confrontation, and write down the changes observed. A relative who knows the person well can give a doctor valuable information, and an early assessment gives the family time to understand the condition, discuss safety and plan long-term support.
Dr Avinash Chakrawarty, Head of Geriatric Medicine at the National Centre for Ageing at AIIMS, Delhi, explained what a proper assessment involves. It cannot rest on a single memory test or one symptom, he said. It should include a detailed history from the person and a close family member, a review of medicines, a neurological examination, and an evaluation of how cognitive changes affect daily activities. Doctors may use validated screening tools, including the Mini-Cog, the Mini-Mental State Examination and the Montreal Cognitive Assessment. Depending on findings, tests may include blood work for vitamin B12 levels, thyroid function and metabolic abnormalities, plus brain imaging where indicated.
That breadth matters because memory trouble does not always mean dementia. Chakrawarty noted that depression, sleep disorders, medication side-effects and certain medical conditions can affect memory and concentration, and some of these causes are treatable. He cautioned against assuming every instance of forgetfulness is dementia.
Dementia, he explained, is an umbrella term for conditions that cause cognitive decline severe enough to affect independent functioning. Alzheimer's disease is the most common cause. Vascular dementia can follow damage to the brain's blood vessels. Dementia with Lewy bodies may involve visual hallucinations, fluctuating alertness and movement-related symptoms. Frontotemporal dementia can first show up as changes in personality, behaviour or language rather than memory.
Bhatti added a group who should seek assessment promptly: people who repeat questions, have progressive memory loss, are losing independence, or show cognitive changes alongside unexplained falls, especially if they have several illnesses or take many medicines. With India's population ageing, the experts' shared message is that early recognition allows timely assessment, identification of treatable causes, and better planning for families.
Citazioni salienti
Dementia is different. Repeatedly asking the same question within minutes, forgetting an important conversation, getting lost in a familiar neighbourhood or struggling with routine household tasks are warning signs.— Dr Harjit Singh Bhatti, Sitaram Bhartia Institute of Science and Research
Some of these causes are treatable, which is why it is important not to assume that every instance of forgetfulness is dementia.— Dr Avinash Chakrawarty, AIIMS Delhi
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su DT Next ↗
Science & Space