Outside a Minneapolis arena on a September evening, two groups gathered around a question that has unsettled American sports and culture: who belongs in women's athletics. Sophie Cunningham's public stance on transgender eligibility has become a focal point for a national debate, drawing organized supporters and counterprotesters to WNBA venues across the country. What unfolded in Minneapolis was not merely a sports argument but a collision of deeply held convictions about fairness, identity, and the boundaries of civil discourse — one that left some attendees shaken by the harshness of words
Cunningham rally draws heated clash between women's sports advocates and trans activists
Athletes and supporters reported receiving abusive verbal harassment including wishes of harm.
I'm here to play basketball, but I'm also here to be me.
Mark
So what actually happened at this rally? Was it just two groups yelling at each other, or was there something more organized about it?
Mimi
There were two distinct groups with opposing views on transgender athletes in women's sports. One side, supporting Cunningham's position, gathered for a rally. The other side came to counter that message. The confrontation escalated when counterprotesters used bullhorns to direct harsh language at the supporters.
Luke
But we should be clear about what we know versus what we're inferring. We know a man said specific inflammatory things through a bullhorn. We know another counterprotester called XX-XY Athletics a hate group. We don't know how many people were on each side, how long it lasted, or whether there was any physical confrontation.
Mark
Why does Cunningham herself matter to this story? Is she actively involved in organizing these rallies?
Mimi
She's the focal point because she publicly stated her support for keeping biological males out of women's sports. But she's been clear that she didn't organize the rallies. She's praised attendees for exercising free speech, but she's also said she's primarily focused on playing basketball.
Luke
That's an important distinction. The rallies exist because of her public stance, but she's not directing them. She's also not disavowing them. That's a meaningful middle position, and it's worth noting that the source doesn't show her condemning the counterprotesters' language either.
Mark
What about Kotzmacher? Why is she significant?
Mimi
She's an athlete who lost a state championship in high school to a team with a transgender pitcher. That specific loss motivated her to become an advocate for women's sports. She's attended both rallies and has been directly targeted with abusive language.
Luke
The source confirms she was told "should've been aborted" at the first rally and that she believes the same person confronted her at the second one. But we're relying on her identification of the person. We don't have independent confirmation that it was definitely the same individual.
Mark
These rallies are happening in multiple cities. Is this a coordinated national movement?
Mimi
Similar demonstrations have taken place outside Fever games in Seattle, Portland, and other WNBA cities. So there's clearly a broader pattern of activism around this issue.
Luke
But the source doesn't tell us whether these are coordinated by a single organization or if they're independent groups responding to the same issue. We know the pattern exists; we don't know the structure behind it.
The Pulse
- A man with a bullhorn told rally attendees they 'should have been aborted,' escalating what might have been a tense but civil demonstration into something far more personal and wounding.
- The same counterprotester had reportedly appeared at a prior Minneapolis rally in August, suggesting an organized and recurring opposition rather than a spontaneous reaction.
- A college softball player who lost a state championship to a team with a transgender pitcher has become a recurring face at these rallies, embodying how individual athletic experiences are fueling the broader movement.
- Similar demonstrations have spread to Seattle, Portland, and other WNBA cities, signaling that the conflict is no longer local but a traveling flashpoint following the league's schedule.
- Cunningham has refused to soften her position, framing her advocacy as inseparable from her identity — and the rallies, and the confrontations, show no sign of fading.
Outside a Minneapolis arena on a September evening, two groups gathered around a question that has unsettled American sports and culture: who belongs in women's athletics. Sophie Cunningham's public stance on transgender eligibility has become a focal point for a national debate, drawing organized supporters and counterprotesters to WNBA venues across the country. What unfolded in Minneapolis was not merely a sports argument but a collision of deeply held convictions about fairness, identity, and the boundaries of civil discourse — one that left some attendees shaken by the harshness of words exchanged in a public square.
On a Thursday night in late September, two opposing groups assembled outside Target Center in Minneapolis to argue over one of American sports' most contested questions. Supporters of WNBA player Sophie Cunningham had organized a rally against biological males competing in women's athletics; across from them, counterprotesters arrived to challenge that message. The atmosphere turned hostile when a man wielding a bullhorn directed deeply personal abuse at rally attendees, telling them they 'should have been aborted.'
It was the second such gathering in Minneapolis in under two months. The August rally had drawn prominent figures including Riley Gaines and Jennifer Sey, founder of XX-XY Athletics, a women's sports apparel company that the counterprotesters repeatedly labeled a 'hate group' through a megaphone. One attendee present at both events, NCAA softball player Kendall Kotzmacher, identified the bullhorn-wielding man as the same individual who had confronted her in August.
Kotzmacher's path to advocacy began with a high school state championship loss to a team that included a transgender pitcher — a defeat that transformed her into a vocal supporter of sex-based eligibility protections. Her story mirrors that of many attendees who see these rallies not as protests but as personal reckonings.
Cunningham has said she did not organize the demonstrations but has praised those who attend as exercising their right to free speech. 'I'm not gonna dim my light just because maybe people don't agree,' she said earlier this season. With rallies now spreading to WNBA cities across the country and the rhetoric on both sides growing sharper, the debate shows every sign of following the league — and Cunningham — wherever they go.
Outside Target Center in Minneapolis on a Thursday night in late September, two groups gathered to make their case about who belongs in women's sports. Sophie Cunningham supporters had organized a rally to advocate for keeping biological males out of women's and girls' athletics. Across from them stood counterprotesters who came to oppose that message. The confrontation turned sharp when a man with a bullhorn, wearing a shirt that read "abortion," directed hostile language at the rally attendees. He told them they "should have been aborted." Another counterprotester used a megaphone to repeatedly label XX-XY Athletics, a women's sports apparel company that opposes biological males competing in women's sports, a "hate group."
This was the second time in less than two months that Minneapolis had hosted one of these demonstrations. The first rally took place on August 2, and it too drew both supporters and counterprotesters. That earlier event included Riley Gaines, former NFL sideline reporter Michele Tafoya, and Jennifer Sey, the founder of XX-XY Athletics. Kendall Kotzmacher, a NCAA softball player at Colorado Christian University and a Minnesota native, attended both rallies. She told reporters that the man with the bullhorn at Thursday's event was the same person who had confronted her at the August gathering. At that first rally, she said, he had used a megaphone to yell about how "awful" the supporters were. During that encounter, she recalled, someone told her she "should've been aborted when I was younger."
Kotzmacher's involvement in the women's sports advocacy movement traces back to a specific loss. In high school, her team lost a state championship game to a team that featured a transgender pitcher. That defeat became a turning point for her, pushing her to become an advocate for protecting women's sports from what she and others see as an unfair competitive advantage. The rallies themselves began after Cunningham, an Indiana Fever guard, publicly stated her support for keeping biological males out of women's and girls' sports. She has said she did not organize the demonstrations but praised the attendees for exercising their right to free speech.
Cunningham's stance has generated organized activism on both sides of the issue. Similar rallies have taken place outside Fever games in Seattle, Portland, and other WNBA cities. The demonstrations reflect a national debate that has intensified in recent years, with passionate advocates on multiple sides willing to show up in public spaces to make their positions clear. When asked about her involvement in the broader conversation, Cunningham framed it as part of her identity. "I'm here to play basketball, but I'm also here to be me," she said earlier in the season. "I'm not gonna shadow that or hide or, you know, dim my light just because maybe people don't agree with that." The rallies show no sign of stopping, and the intensity of the rhetoric—on both sides—suggests the debate will continue to draw crowds and confrontation wherever Cunningham plays.
Notable Quotes
I'm here to play basketball, but I'm also here to be me. I'm not gonna shadow that or hide or dim my light just because maybe people don't agree with that.— Sophie Cunningham
He had a megaphone and was just yelling everything about how awful people we are. At one point, I got told that I should've been aborted when I was younger.— Kendall Kotzmacher, describing the first rally
Want the full story?
Read the original at Fox News ↗