In the long story of an Australian side searching for its shape, Pat Cummins has chosen to vouch for Cam Green as a number three who can carry both the bat and the ball. The question has lingered since a back injury took Green out of a whole home summer, and it sharpened when he was promoted into the middle order for the World Test Championship final. Cummins argues that batting first drop and bowling are not rival vocations but complementary ones, and that the West Indies tour, with its three scores of 40-plus, offered early evidence. Whether that faith holds will be tested as Green returns t
Cummins Backs Cam Green as Australia's Long-Term No.3 Despite Bowling Workload
Just because they both bowl doesn't work against them
Why is Cummins talking about this now?
Because Green is about to bowl again for Western Australia this weekend, after a back injury cost him last summer. The workload question is suddenly live.
What is Cummins's actual argument?
That batting at three and bowling aren't mutually exclusive. He says a number three has often done about half his batting before bowling, so the rest is similar to a middle-order player's.
That's his view, though, not evidence. Nothing in the report shows how Green's back will cope with both roles.
What backs up the faith in Green at three?
The West Indies. After a shaky start, he made three scores of 40-plus in his last three innings in tough conditions, and Australia swept the series.
Worth noting those are 40s, not centuries. Cummins calls it potential, which is a careful word.
Why does it matter for Webster?
If Green can bat three and bowl, Webster can stay in the side too, and two bowling allrounders could help with concerns over the fast bowling stocks.
The report says those fitness concerns exist but doesn't detail them, so I'd keep that link as a possibility.
And the opening spot?
Sam Konstas faces Cameron Bancroft in a Shield bat-off, with WA playing New South Wales on Saturday.
Nothing is decided there. We only know the contest is coming.
El Pulso
- Cummins has publicly staked his backing on Cam Green as the long-term No.3, just as Green prepares to bowl again.
- Doubts are circulating that Green's bowling workload could drain the batting he needs at first drop.
- Green's form in the West Indies, with three straight scores of 40-plus, has given the captain fresh evidence to cite.
- Selectors may keep Beau Webster in the side alongside Green, easing pressure on the specialist fast bowlers.
- A Shield bat-off between Sam Konstas and Cameron Bancroft, and Green's bowling fitness this weekend, will decide the top order before The Ashes.
In the long story of an Australian side searching for its shape, Pat Cummins has chosen to vouch for Cam Green as a number three who can carry both the bat and the ball. The question has lingered since a back injury took Green out of a whole home summer, and it sharpened when he was promoted into the middle order for the World Test Championship final. Cummins argues that batting first drop and bowling are not rival vocations but complementary ones, and that the West Indies tour, with its three scores of 40-plus, offered early evidence. Whether that faith holds will be tested as Green returns to bowling in the Shield, and the answer will help determine the shape of the top order before The Ashes.
Pat Cummins has put his weight behind Cam Green as Australia's long-term number three, and he has done it just as Green is about to bowl in anger again. The Test captain told the Herald Sun that he does not see batting first drop and bowling as two jobs that cancel each other out.
The question has trailed Green since a back injury kept him out of the entire home summer. His return to the Test side for the World Test Championship final came with a promotion to number three, made possible by the emergence of Beau Webster. The start was shaky, but in the West Indies Green found his footing, making three scores of 40-plus in his last three innings as Australia completed a series sweep. Cummins pointed to that tour as proof of potential.
With Green fit to bowl again, some observers wonder whether the combined load is too heavy. Cummins concedes bowling adds a variable, but argues a player at three has often done half his batting before he takes the ball, so the gap between disciplines can be just as long. He also points to precedent, from Mitch Marsh to Green himself, and to Australia's history of fielding two wicketkeepers at once. The selectors, he says, simply look for the best top six.
The opening spot remains unsettled. Sam Konstas and Cameron Bancroft meet in a Shield bat-off, with Western Australia against New South Wales the first test of the weekend. How Green's back holds up under a bowling load, and who wins that contest, will shape the top order heading into The Ashes.
Pat Cummins has put his weight behind Cam Green as Australia's long-term number three, and he has done it just as Green is about to bowl in anger again. The Test captain told the Herald Sun he does not see batting first drop and bowling as two jobs that cancel each other out.
The question has been hanging around since Green came back from a back injury that kept him out of the entire home summer last year. On his return to the Test side for the World Test Championship final, he was promoted to number three, a move made possible by the emergence of Beau Webster.
The start was shaky. But in the West Indies, in what the report describes as extreme conditions, Green found his footing, making three scores of 40-plus in his last three innings as Australia completed a series sweep. Cummins pointed to that tour as proof of potential. "I think he proved over in the West Indies that he has the potential to be a long-term No.3," he said.
With Green now fit to bowl again, starting with the Shield season this weekend, some observers have wondered whether the combined load is too heavy. Cummins accepted that bowling adds a variable. Traditionally, he noted, a bowler is slotted into the middle order to give him some rest. But he argued the concern is overstated: a player at three has often done roughly half his batting before he gets the ball, so the break between the two disciplines can be just as long.
He also reached for precedent. Australia has run allrounders in the batting order before, he said, naming Mitch Marsh and Green himself among others. The side has even fielded two wicketkeepers at once, in Alex Carey and Josh Inglis, and earlier Tim Paine and Matt Wade. The selectors, in his telling, simply look for the best top six. "Just because they both bowl doesn't work against them; it probably works for them," he said.
There is a selection logic behind the defence. If Green can bat at three and bowl, Webster, also an allrounder, can stay in the side. That could matter given the fitness concerns around Australia's fast bowling stocks, since two bowling options in the top six lighten the load on the specialist quicks.
The opening partnership remains the other open question. A Shield bat-off looms, and attention will turn to Western Australia's match against New South Wales on Saturday. Incumbent opener Sam Konstas will go head to head with Cameron Bancroft, while Green looks to show he is fit to bowl.
How Green's back holds up under a bowling load this weekend, and who wins the opening contest, will shape Australia's top order heading into The Ashes.
Citas Notables
I think he proved over in the West Indies that he has the potential to be a long-term No.3.— Pat Cummins, Australian Test captain, to the Herald Sun