In Miami, the community that once felt most secure under American immigration law is discovering its own vulnerability. Florida's Cuban Americans, many of whom backed Donald Trump on the promise of removing criminals, now watch relatives and neighbours swept up in ICE arrests and deported, even without criminal records. The tension between loyalty to a political movement and the fear of losing one's own family has opened a quiet fissure, one that will be tested in the November vote. It is a reminder that policies aimed at strangers often return to reshape the lives of those who cheered them on
Cuban Americans who backed Trump now confront the fallout of his deportation drive
Cubans in Florida now realise they are as vulnerable as any other diaspora.
Why does this story land differently for Cubans than for other immigrant groups?
Because they were told, for decades, that they were the exception. The Cuban Adjustment Act gave them favoured status, and Labrador says that assumption of safety is what has collapsed.
Worth noting that the 68% who voted Trump is a figure for Florida Cuban Americans, and the White House's claim of more than 3 million departures is the administration's own number, not independently verified here.
Labrador says he was blindsided. Was he?
The story itself points out Trump promised the largest deportation programme in American history, repeatedly, even in Florida. Labrador assumed it meant criminals only.
Right, so it's less a hidden plan than a gap between what voters assumed and what was said. That's his account of his own thinking, though.
The FIU poll seems contradictory.
It is. 76% disapprove of deporting Cubans with no criminal record, yet 68% say they'll vote Republican.
And that doesn't tell us how many of those are the same people, or whether disapproval will change a single vote. Salazar's race is the real test, and it's still undecided.
What about Heydi Sanchez?
Her case shows the human weight: a mother removed in a day, a daughter in Tampa with her father.
ICE says she chose to leave without the child. Sanchez's account of the separation differs in tone, and the reporting doesn't resolve that dispute.
El Pulso
- Arrests now reach schoolyards, bus stops and courthouses, places once considered safe for families.
- Lawyers' waiting rooms overflow with relatives desperate to stop deportations before they happen.
- A mother and daughter were seized from a hospital bed after a car crash and deported within days.
- A FIU poll shows 76% of South Florida Cubans oppose deporting people without criminal records, yet most still plan to vote Republican.
- Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar, locked in a tight race, is publicly breaking with the White House on deportations.
In Miami, the community that once felt most secure under American immigration law is discovering its own vulnerability. Florida's Cuban Americans, many of whom backed Donald Trump on the promise of removing criminals, now watch relatives and neighbours swept up in ICE arrests and deported, even without criminal records. The tension between loyalty to a political movement and the fear of losing one's own family has opened a quiet fissure, one that will be tested in the November vote. It is a reminder that policies aimed at strangers often return to reshape the lives of those who cheered them on.
In Miami, immigration lawyer Ismael Labrador's waiting room has not emptied since the Trump administration began its crackdown two years ago. Relatives of detained people fill his appointment book, all racing to win releases before deportation. Labrador, born in Cuba, voted for Trump and now regrets it. He had believed the promised mass deportations would target people with criminal records. His own cousin was deported to Cuba despite his efforts.
Phone videos have captured arrests in places once considered off-limits. Grace Calero and her 19-year-old daughter, Giulianna Carriel, both Ecuadorean, were taken to hospital after a car crash in Kissimmee. While they were being treated, ICE agents arrested them, and within days they were deported to Ecuador.
The White House says Trump is delivering what voters asked for. Yet Florida's Cuban community is divided. A poll found 76% of South Florida Cubans oppose deporting those without criminal records, but 68% still plan to vote Republican. Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar, in a tight race, has said the policy has gone too far and that Hispanics who helped elect Trump feel betrayed.
Heydi Sanchez's story gives the human cost a face. Having left Cuba in 2019, she built a life in Tampa, working with autistic children and the elderly, and became a mother after a long fertility struggle. When Trump revoked humanitarian parole for about 300,000 Cubans, her check-in with ICE was moved up without warning. She was detained, her US-citizen daughter Kailyn was handed to her father, and she was flown to Havana in shackles. Now living in a one-bedroom apartment in rural Mayabeque, she tells her daughter over video calls that she is away working.
In November, Republicans may feel the frustration of Cuban voters who have discovered they are as vulnerable as anyone else.
In Miami, the waiting room of immigration lawyer Ismael Labrador has not been empty since the Trump administration began its crackdown on undocumented immigrants two years ago. His appointment book is full of relatives of detained people, all trying to win their release before they are deported. Business is booming, Labrador says, and he wishes it weren't.
Labrador was born in Cuba, and he is one of the 68% of Florida's Cuban Americans who voted for Donald Trump two years ago. He regrets it now. Cubans have long held a favoured place in US immigration law under the Cuban Adjustment Act, a measure from the 1960s. But widespread ICE arrests across Florida have left the community more exposed than it ever imagined, he says. His rule of thumb: if you don't have a Green Card, you may be a target. His own cousin was caught up in the detentions, and despite his efforts Labrador could not stop him being deported to Cuba. "It's hard when you're fighting against a lot of resources," he says.
Phone videos have captured arrests in places once considered off-limits: outside schoolyards, at bus stops, at youth sporting events, inside courthouses during scheduled immigration hearings. Few images have landed like the footage of Grace Calero, 39, and her 19-year-old daughter, Giulianna Carriel, both Ecuadorean. Two months ago they were driving to work in Kissimmee, central Florida, when another car hit theirs, and they were taken to hospital by ambulance. While they were being treated, ICE agents arrested them. Within days they had been deported to Ecuador.
The White House says Trump was elected to deliver mass deportations and is doing so. A spokeswoman told the BBC last week that he "stopped the invasion of our country" and that more than 3 million people in the country illegally have left as a result of his policies. ICE says it is targeting anyone who has broken immigration law and is in the US illegally. Trump was open about his plans: on the 2024 campaign trail, including at Florida rallies, he repeatedly promised to launch the largest deportation programme in American history on Day One. Labrador and many other Latino voters assumed it would apply only to people with criminal records. "We got blindsided," he argues. He says he voted to remove criminals, alleging that communists came from Cuba under Biden, and never expected the administration to go after everybody.
The sentiment has reached Congress. Maria Elvira Salazar, who represents Florida's 27th District, recently released a video filmed outside the White House saying the deportation policy had gone too far. Addressing Trump, she said the Hispanics who helped him reach the White House in 2024 feel betrayed. She is in a tight race against fellow Cuban American Eliott Rodríguez, the Democratic candidate, and her closeness to Trump on immigration could cost her the seat.
Florida is still Trump country. At a recent gathering of Cuban American entrepreneurs in Miami, real estate businessman Juan Omar Sixto said Miami and Cuban Americans love Trump and agree that anyone who crossed the border illegally should go, though he acknowledged entering the US illegally himself six decades ago. A Florida International University poll released Thursday found a split picture: 76% of South Florida Cubans disapprove of deporting Cubans with no criminal record, yet 68% plan to vote Republican in November. Elsewhere Latino support is slipping. Trump beat Kamala Harris 56.1% to 43% in the state, its biggest margin since 1988, helped by Latino voters. A recent NBC News/Telemundo poll of 8,000 registered Latino voters found nearly 60% want Democrats to control Congress, against 35% who want Republicans. High supermarket and petrol prices are a major factor.
Stories like Heydi Sanchez's also weigh on people. She left Cuba in 2019 as its economy collapsed and crossed the border from Mexico illegally. After nine months in detention she was released under an i-220B Order of Supervision, which lets her stay but carries the constant threat of removal. She settled in Tampa, worked with autistic children and the elderly, and after a difficult and expensive fertility struggle had a daughter, Kailyn. Last year Trump revoked temporary humanitarian parole for about 300,000 Cubans. Sanchez sensed trouble when her regular ICE check-in was moved up without warning. At the appointment she was detained, Kailyn was handed to her father, a US citizen, and within a day Sanchez was on a deportation flight to Havana in shackles, with no right of appeal.
The BBC's Will Grant met her in Mayabeque, a rural province outside Havana, where she lives in a one-bedroom apartment. "It's like the sky fell in and crushed me," she says. On video calls her daughter asks her to come home, and Sanchez tells her she is away working. More than a year on, despite expressions of support from several US politicians, including Salazar, she remains in limbo. ICE says the parent stated she wanted to be removed without the child and left her with a safe relative in the US.
The administration has sent thousands back to an island Washington itself calls a failed state, now suffering its worst energy crisis amid a months-long US fuel blockade. In November, Republicans may feel the frustration of Cuban voters who now see they are as vulnerable as any other diaspora.
Citas Notables
This isn't what I voted for.— Ismael Labrador, Miami immigration lawyer
The same Hispanics who helped you get to the White House in 2024 feel betrayed today.— Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar, addressing Trump