Across African cities, a three-dollar blouse ordered on a phone is quietly unraveling decades of local manufacturing and retail labor. Shein and Temu, two Chinese e-commerce giants, have claimed 37 percent of South Africa's online clothing market in just four years, displacing thousands of jobs that will not return without deliberate intervention. The tension at the heart of this story is ancient: the gap between what is cheapest for the individual and what is most sustaining for the community. African governments now face the enduring question of whether a continent can be both a market and a
Chinese e-commerce giants Shein and Temu threaten African retail jobs and local industries
8,100 retail and manufacturing jobs failed to materialize in South Africa in 2024, with projections of 34,000+ additional job losses by 2030 across the sector.
They sucked up billions of rands in sales, and undercut local manufacturers
Mark
So Shein and Temu are just cheaper than local retailers. Why can't local businesses just lower their prices too?
Mimi
Because they can't. A local manufacturer has to pay rent on a factory, wages for workers, taxes to the government. Shein operates from China and often avoids taxes entirely through these freight forwarder networks. The cost structure is completely different.
Luke
But we should be careful here—the study showing 8,100 jobs "failed to materialize" is a projection based on assumptions about what would have happened without these platforms. That's not the same as jobs that actually existed and were lost.
Mark
Fair point. So we don't know for certain how many jobs are actually gone?
Mimi
We know that in South Africa, these two platforms captured 37 percent of online sales in their sector in just a few years. That's real market share. Whether every job in that projection would have existed is debatable, but the displacement is happening.
Luke
And the 34,000 jobs by 2030—that's a modeled scenario, not a forecast. It depends on whether things stay the same or get worse. Governments could intervene.
Mark
Which some are trying to do. South Africa changed its import rules. But can you actually ban an app?
Mimi
That's the real question. The union wants to ban them, but enforcement is hard when people can use freight forwarders or VPNs. It's not like stopping a physical store.
Luke
And banning raises its own questions—are you protecting jobs or denying consumers affordable access to products? That's a political choice, not just an economic one.
Mark
So what's the actual solution here?
Mimi
That's what governments are wrestling with. You want affordable digital commerce, but you also want local industries to survive. Those two things are in tension right now.
Luke
And the real tension is whether Africa becomes a place where things are made or just a place where things are bought. That's the long game.
Il Polso
- Shein and Temu have seized 37% of South Africa's online clothing market since 2020, erasing 8,100 jobs in a single year and threatening 34,000 more by 2030.
- Local manufacturers are structurally outgunned — they pay rent, wages, and taxes that Chinese platforms largely avoid, making price competition not just difficult but mathematically impossible.
- The platforms' reach extends even into countries where they have no official presence, as freight-forwarding networks allow consumers from Guinea-Bissau to Ghana to order freely, bypassing customs and duties.
- Labor unions in South Africa are pushing for app bans, while industry leaders in West Africa are demanding stronger customs enforcement and quality standards to level the playing field.
- African governments are caught between two legitimate goods: the real relief that cheap imports offer to price-sensitive consumers, and the long-term cost of hollowing out domestic industry.
Across African cities, a three-dollar blouse ordered on a phone is quietly unraveling decades of local manufacturing and retail labor. Shein and Temu, two Chinese e-commerce giants, have claimed 37 percent of South Africa's online clothing market in just four years, displacing thousands of jobs that will not return without deliberate intervention. The tension at the heart of this story is ancient: the gap between what is cheapest for the individual and what is most sustaining for the community. African governments now face the enduring question of whether a continent can be both a market and a maker.
A young shopper in Lagos or Johannesburg orders a silk blouse for three dollars after watching an influencer unbox it on TikTok. It arrives within a week. For millions of Africans, this is simply how shopping works now — and the consequences are only beginning to be counted.
Shein arrived in South Africa in 2020; Temu followed in 2024. Within four years, the two platforms had captured 37 percent of the country's online clothing, textile, footwear, and leather sales — a segment worth roughly $405 million in 2024 alone. A study commissioned by the Localization Support Fund found that 8,100 jobs — nearly 3,000 in manufacturing and over 5,000 in retail — never materialized that year because purchasing power flowed directly to Asia. By 2030, more than 34,000 additional positions could disappear. Simon Eppel of the South African Clothing and Textile Workers' Union says the platforms have "sucked up billions of rands in sales" and is now calling for measures as drastic as banning the apps outright.
What makes these platforms so hard to counter is not price alone but sophistication. They use consumer data to anticipate demand before traditional retailers recognize it, and they deploy influencer culture to make shopping feel like entertainment. In Ghana, industry chairman Tsonam Cleanse Akpeloo acknowledges the appeal in price-sensitive economies, but he has watched the same dynamics erode competitiveness in aluminum and hardware sectors. Meanwhile, freight-forwarding networks allow consumers across the continent — even in countries with no official Shein or Temu presence — to place orders using foreign addresses, further bypassing customs and tax obligations that local businesses cannot escape.
The structural unfairness is the crux of the policy problem. A local retailer pays rent, salaries, and taxes. These platforms often do not, or pay far less. South Africa has begun tightening import rules; Akpeloo is urging similar enforcement across West Africa. But the deeper question is not simply about regulation — it is about what kind of economy Africa chooses to build. A delivery driver earns a wage from a Chinese order, but a textile worker sustains an entire ecosystem of fabric producers, factories, and communities. The continent's governments must decide whether Africa will remain a consumer market or become a producer — a choice whose consequences will extend far beyond the price of a blouse.
A young person in Lagos or Johannesburg opens TikTok during a lunch break, watches an influencer unbox a silk blouse, and orders it for three dollars. The package arrives in a week. This is how shopping works now for millions of Africans, and it is reshaping the continent's retail landscape in ways that are only beginning to be measured.
Shein and Temu, both Chinese e-commerce platforms, have built their global empires on a formula: prices so low they seem impossible, product ranges so vast they contain nearly everything, and marketing so pervasive it feels less like advertising and more like entertainment. Shein arrived in South Africa in 2020. Temu followed in 2024. Within four years, the two platforms had captured 37 percent of South Africa's online clothing, textile, footwear and leather sales—a market segment worth roughly 7.3 billion rand, or about $405 million, in 2024 alone. The speed of this takeover has alarmed labor unions, manufacturers, and government officials across the continent.
The numbers tell a stark story. A study commissioned by the Localization Support Fund found that in South Africa, 2,818 manufacturing jobs and 5,282 retail positions never materialized in 2024 because of competition from Shein and Temu. That is 8,100 jobs that did not exist because purchasing power flowed directly to Asia instead. The projections are worse: by 2030, the same study estimates that more than 34,000 additional retail and manufacturing jobs could vanish under current market conditions. Simon Eppel, a research director with the South African Clothing and Textile Workers' Union, describes the situation plainly. The platforms have "sucked up billions of rands in sales, and undercut local manufacturers," he said. The union is now calling for stricter controls, and Eppel has proposed banning the apps outright as one possible response to the price pressure bearing down on domestic industry.
What makes these platforms so difficult to compete against is not just their prices but their speed and sophistication. They use digital data to identify which products consumers want before traditional retailers even know demand exists. Influencers—often young people with large followings—create a constant stream of content showing new purchases. Discounts appear and disappear. The line between entertainment and shopping blurs entirely. For consumers in price-sensitive markets, the appeal is undeniable. Tsonam Cleanse Akpeloo, chairman of the Association of Ghana Industries in Accra, acknowledges this directly: "Their prices are attractive in price-sensitive economies where consumers naturally look for products that fit their budgets." But for local business owners, the problem is structural. A company that uses high-quality materials and maintains higher labor and safety standards cannot match Shein's or Temu's prices. In Ghana, Akpeloo has watched similar dynamics destroy competitiveness in aluminum and hardware sectors.
The platforms' reach extends far beyond countries where they have official operations. Freight forwarders—intermediaries who provide customers with delivery addresses in countries where Shein and Temu operate directly—have become crucial infrastructure. A customer in Guinea-Bissau can order from Shein using a Portuguese address, and the package gets forwarded home. Mariama Sow, who runs a business importing shoes, accessories, and human hair for salons, relies on this system. She praises the reliability of the products and the prices. But she also hears complaints from other customers about quality and sizing, and she has noticed something more troubling: younger shoppers are abandoning local retailers entirely.
For African governments, the issue extends beyond retail competition into questions of taxation and industrial policy. A local retailer pays rent, staff salaries, and taxes. Shein and Temu often do not, or pay far less, creating an unequal playing field that has nothing to do with efficiency or innovation. South Africa has begun tightening rules on small online imports to address this imbalance. Akpeloo is calling for similar action across West Africa: "We need stronger action against smuggling, better enforcement of customs and quality standards." Goods entering markets without proper duties and taxes add another layer of pressure on businesses already struggling to compete.
Yet the story is not simply one of predatory foreign platforms destroying local industry. The deeper question is where economic value gets created and who captures it. A delivery driver earns money from an order placed in China. A textile worker, by contrast, supports an entire local ecosystem—fabric producers, sewing factories, retailers, and the communities that depend on them. For African governments, the challenge is not to reject digital commerce or affordable products but to decide whether the continent will remain primarily a consumer market or become a producer. That choice will shape not just retail but the entire economic future of the region.
Citazioni salienti
They sucked up billions of rands in sales, and undercut local manufacturers— Simon Eppel, South African Clothing and Textile Workers' Union
Their prices are attractive in price-sensitive economies where consumers naturally look for products that fit their budgets— Tsonam Cleanse Akpeloo, Association of Ghana Industries
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su Deutsche Welle ↗
Media & Entertainment