In the aftermath of high-level diplomacy between Washington and Beijing, American soybean farmers find themselves standing outside a door that has closed for reasons both political and economic. China's decision to exclude US soybeans from its latest round of tariff relief is less a singular act of exclusion than the culmination of a market that has quietly reorganized itself — around South American supplies, record inventories, and the cold arithmetic of crushing margins that no longer favor American beans. It is a reminder that trade relationships, like trust, are rebuilt slowly and lost qui
China's Soybean Slump Locks Out US Cargoes Despite Tariff Deal
We are not interested in making further purchases as these will incur losses.
Mark
So the tariff deal fell apart for soybeans specifically?
Mimi
Not exactly. China is cutting tariffs on many US farm products, but soybeans were excluded from that relief. They still carry a 10% tariff.
Luke
But here's the thing—even without the tariff, the crushers say they wouldn't buy. The margins are negative. They're losing money processing soybeans at current prices.
Mark
So it's not really about the tariff?
Mimi
It's part of it. The tariff makes US beans uncompetitive. But the real issue is that Chinese processors are already stocked through February with cheaper Brazilian beans that have higher oil content.
Luke
And we should note—the state-run companies did buy 13.7 million metric tons of US soybeans following the May trade deal. So there was a commitment. But private crushers? They've gone entirely to South America.
Mark
Why would they do that if the price is the same?
Mimi
Brazilian soybeans have more oil in them. That matters to processors. Plus, they've already booked the shipments. They're not looking to buy more.
Luke
The inventory numbers are striking—7.96 million tons sitting in Chinese plants, the highest in fifteen years. That's not a tariff problem. That's overcapacity meeting weak demand.
Mark
What happens next?
Mimi
Unless crushing margins improve or global supplies tighten, Chinese buyers probably won't import more beans. They'll use their reserves or shut down plants.
Luke
And Chicago futures are already down. The market is pricing in continued weakness as the US harvest ramps up and China keeps buying less.
El Pulso
- US soybeans were conspicuously left off China's tariff relief list after the Xi-Trump summit, even as other American farm goods received concessions — a pointed omission for the single largest US agricultural export to China.
- Chinese crushing plants are drowning in inventory, holding 7.96 million tons of soybeans — a fifteen-year high — while processing margins have turned negative, meaning every ton crushed is a loss.
- Brazilian and Argentine beans have effectively locked American suppliers out through early 2027, offering comparable prices but superior oil content that makes them the rational choice for processors already bleeding money.
- Commercial buyers have nearly stopped purchasing altogether, with only fifty soybean cargoes booked across all of September — the lowest volume in four years — as private crushers pivot entirely to South America.
- Chicago soybean futures have already slipped 1.5 percent this week, with analysts warning of further pressure as the US harvest peaks into a market that has decided, for now, it simply does not need American beans.
In the aftermath of high-level diplomacy between Washington and Beijing, American soybean farmers find themselves standing outside a door that has closed for reasons both political and economic. China's decision to exclude US soybeans from its latest round of tariff relief is less a singular act of exclusion than the culmination of a market that has quietly reorganized itself — around South American supplies, record inventories, and the cold arithmetic of crushing margins that no longer favor American beans. It is a reminder that trade relationships, like trust, are rebuilt slowly and lost quickly.
China's soybean market has effectively shut its door to American suppliers — not through politics alone, but because the economics have stopped working. Last week's summit between Xi Jinping and Donald Trump produced tariff relief for a wide range of US farm products, but soybeans, America's largest agricultural export to China, were left off the list. For US farmers, the timing could hardly be worse.
The 10% tariff that has persisted since last year's trade war certainly plays a role, but a senior executive at a major Chinese oilseed processor was blunt: his company has already booked October and much of November from South America, and any US purchases would generate losses. Brazilian soybeans trade at roughly the same price as American beans — around $590 per ton with freight — but carry higher oil content, making them more valuable to processors who extract oil and meal for livestock feed.
The domestic picture has deteriorated sharply. Some 111 major processing facilities are sitting on 7.96 million tons of soybeans in storage, the highest level in at least fifteen years. Government efforts to shrink China's hog herds have cut into demand for soybean meal, and processors expect fourth-quarter demand to remain soft. Crushing margins have turned brutal: losses range from $17.90 to $29.83 per ton depending on origin, and in Rizhao, China's largest processing hub, a single ton processed recently lost 33.54 yuan.
The buying has nearly stopped. In the first three weeks of September, Chinese buyers booked only around fifty cargoes total — the fewest in four years. State firms like COFCO and Sinograin accounted for roughly thirty of those US purchases, honoring a May trade commitment, while private crushers have turned entirely to South America. When Sinograin auctioned imported soybeans recently, less than 38 percent found buyers.
Analysts see little prospect for change unless crushing margins recover. Commercial buyers are more likely to draw down reserves or idle plants than import additional beans. Chicago soybean futures have already fallen 1.5 percent this week, with further pressure expected as the US harvest peaks. The tariff exclusion matters — but it is merely the final obstacle in front of a market that has already made up its mind.
China's soybean market has effectively closed its door to American suppliers, not because of politics alone but because the economics have stopped working. Last week's summit between President Xi Jinping and President Donald Trump produced tariff relief for a broad range of US farm products—but soybeans, the single largest agricultural import from America, were left off the list. The timing could hardly be worse for US farmers: Chinese crushers have already locked in their needs through early February with shipments from Brazil and Argentina, and the math no longer favors buying American.
The problem runs deeper than tariffs, though the 10% levy that has persisted since the trade war began last year certainly matters. A senior executive at a major Chinese oilseed processor put it plainly: the company has booked all its October shipments and much of November from South America. Any additional purchases from the US would generate losses. Brazilian soybeans are trading at roughly the same price as American beans—around $590 per ton including freight—but they carry a crucial advantage: higher oil content, which makes them more valuable to processors who extract oil and meal for animal feed.
The domestic demand picture in China has deteriorated sharply. Crushing plants across the country are sitting on massive inventories. As of late September, 111 major processing facilities held 7.96 million tons of soybeans in storage, the highest level in at least fifteen years. This glut exists partly because the government has been working to shrink China's hog herds, cutting into demand for soybean meal, a key livestock feed. Processors expect fourth-quarter demand to remain soft, so there is no urgency to buy.
The economics of processing have turned brutal. Crushers face negative margins—they lose money on every ton they process. For soybeans arriving in November from the US Pacific Northwest or Gulf ports, losses range from $17.90 to $29.83 per ton. Brazilian beans show losses of about $17.90 per ton. In Rizhao, China's largest processing hub, a facility processing one ton of soybeans on a recent Tuesday lost 33.54 yuan, roughly $5. Under these conditions, buying more soybeans makes no sense.
The buying has nearly stopped. In the first three weeks of September, Chinese buyers booked around fifty soybean cargoes total—the fewest in four years. State-run companies like COFCO and Sinograin accounted for about thirty of those cargoes from the US, following through on a trade deal signed in May that committed them to purchasing 13.7 million metric tons of American soybeans. Private crushers, by contrast, have turned entirely to South America. When Sinograin held an auction of imported soybeans recently, only 37.3 percent of the 514,000 tons offered found buyers.
Johnny Xiang, founder of AgRadar Consulting in Beijing, sees little prospect for change unless crushing margins recover. Commercial buyers, he said, are more likely to draw down their own reserves or idle plants for maintenance than import additional beans. Chicago soybean futures have already fallen 1.5 percent this week, and analysts expect further pressure as the US harvest peaks and Chinese demand continues to weaken. The tariff exclusion matters, but it is merely the final obstacle in front of a market that has already decided it does not need American soybeans right now.
Citas Notables
We have booked for all of October and much of November shipments from Brazil and Argentina. Most of these cargoes will arrive around the high demand Chinese New Year period. We are not interested in making further purchases as these will incur losses.— Senior executive at a Chinese oilseed processing company
Unless margins recover, commercial buyers are unlikely to book more cargoes from overseas. If supplies tighten, buyers are more likely to turn to reserve auctions or idle plants for maintenance than import more beans.— Johnny Xiang, founder of AgRadar Consulting, Beijing
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en Reuters ↗