In the ancient harbor of Ventotene, where European federalism was once dreamed into being, Taiwan's Vice President and Foreign Minister arrived quietly to sit among democracy's defenders — and Beijing's displeasure followed swiftly. China's formal protests to Italy and the EU reveal the enduring tension between the world's democratic aspirations and the geopolitical weight of a rising power that views such gatherings as provocations. The visit, rare precisely because its rarity reflects how much fear shapes diplomacy, asks a quiet but urgent question of Europe: when democratic values and econo
China protests Taiwan VP's rare EU democracy forum visit
No one can decide who is hosted in Ventotene and who is not
Mark
Why does it matter that Hsiao is vice president rather than, say, a foreign ministry official?
Mimi
Because it's a signal of Taiwan's standing and intent. A vice president is the second-highest office. China reads rank as a measure of respect and legitimacy. The higher the visitor, the more it looks like Taiwan is being treated as a state.
Luke
But we should note—Taiwan's government hasn't formally declared independence. So China's threat to use military force is based on its own claim, not on something Taiwan has actually done.
Mark
Why keep the visit secret until they arrived?
Mimi
Safety, according to Picierno. If China had known in advance, there could have been pressure on Italy to cancel, or worse, security risks for the officials themselves.
Luke
That's the stated reason. We don't have independent confirmation of specific threats, just the general context that these visits are diplomatically fraught.
Mark
What's Italy's actual position here?
Mimi
Ambiguous. They're hosting the conference and the Taiwanese officials, but their Foreign Minister won't meet with them. It's a way of saying yes and no simultaneously.
Luke
Right. Italy recognizes China, not Taiwan. So there are real constraints on what Rome can do without triggering Beijing's anger.
Mark
How does this fit into the bigger EU-China picture?
Mimi
China backed Russia in Ukraine. That poisoned EU-China relations. Now Taiwan is trying to build closer ties with Europe for security reasons. But Europe is caught between democratic values and economic dependence on China.
Luke
And we don't yet know how the EU will formally respond to these complaints. That's still to come.
Der Puls
- Taiwan's Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim arrived in Italy under deliberate secrecy — her presence only announced once she was already on the ground, a precaution that speaks volumes about the risks such visits carry.
- Beijing responded swiftly with formal 'solemn representations' to both Rome and Brussels, invoking its standing demand that nations recognizing China refuse all official contact with Taiwan.
- A European Parliament vice president pushed back publicly, declaring that no outside power — pointedly naming China's 'regime' — has the right to dictate who is welcomed at a European democracy forum.
- Italy is walking a careful line: hosting the visit while ensuring its foreign minister will not meet the Taiwanese officials, a studied gesture of distance toward Beijing.
- The EU now faces a signal moment — how it responds to China's complaints after the conference closes will reveal how much democratic pressure Europe can absorb before geopolitical caution wins out.
In the ancient harbor of Ventotene, where European federalism was once dreamed into being, Taiwan's Vice President and Foreign Minister arrived quietly to sit among democracy's defenders — and Beijing's displeasure followed swiftly. China's formal protests to Italy and the EU reveal the enduring tension between the world's democratic aspirations and the geopolitical weight of a rising power that views such gatherings as provocations. The visit, rare precisely because its rarity reflects how much fear shapes diplomacy, asks a quiet but urgent question of Europe: when democratic values and economic interests diverge, which does the continent choose to honor?
Beijing filed formal diplomatic complaints with Italy and the European Union after Taiwan's Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim and Foreign Minister Lin Chia-lung traveled to the Ventotene Conference for Freedom and Democracy on Italian soil. China's Foreign Ministry issued what it termed "solemn representations," reiterating its longstanding opposition to any official contact between Taiwan and nations that recognize Beijing — which claims the island as its own territory.
The visit was kept secret until the officials had already arrived, a precaution taken for their safety. European Parliament Vice President Pina Picierno announced their attendance Friday morning and defended it sharply, saying no outside power could dictate who was welcome at Ventotene. The conference also hosts Yulia Navalnaya, widow of Russian opposition figure Alexei Navalny, and Belarusian opposition leader Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya — a gathering that reads, unmistakably, as a roll call of those resisting authoritarian pressure.
What makes the moment striking is how exceptional it is for a Taiwanese official of Hsiao's rank to visit any country with formal ties to Beijing. Most nations fear economic or political retaliation if they receive senior Taiwanese figures. Italy maintains no formal diplomatic relations with Taiwan — like nearly all countries — yet both capitals host de facto embassies, a practical arrangement that stops short of recognition. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani will not meet with the Taiwanese delegation, a careful signal of the distance Rome is maintaining even as it opens its doors.
The EU is threading an increasingly difficult needle. Taiwan drew closer to Europe after Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine, and China's support for Moscow has already strained EU-China relations. How Brussels responds to Beijing's complaints — and what emerges after the conference closes Saturday — will reveal how willing Europe is to absorb Chinese pressure in defense of its democratic commitments.
Beijing filed formal complaints with Italy and the European Union on Friday after learning that Taiwan's Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim and Foreign Minister Lin Chia-lung had traveled to attend the Ventotene Conference for Freedom and Democracy on Italian soil. The Chinese Foreign Ministry issued what it called "solemn representations"—a diplomatic term conveying official displeasure—reiterating its blanket opposition to any official contact between nations that recognize China and Taiwan, which Beijing claims as its own territory.
The visit itself was deliberately kept secret until the Taiwanese officials had already arrived, a precaution taken for their safety. European Parliament Vice President Pina Picierno announced their attendance early Friday morning and defended the decision with pointed language, saying no outside power could dictate who was welcome at Ventotene and directly calling out what she termed the Chinese "regime" for attempting to interfere. The conference, which began Thursday and runs through Saturday, also hosts other prominent democracy advocates: Yulia Navalnaya, widow of the late Russian opposition figure Alexei Navalny, and Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya, a Belarusian opposition leader.
What makes this moment notable is how unusual it is for a Taiwanese official at Hsiao's level to visit any nation with formal ties to Beijing. Taiwan's government has not declared independence, yet China has repeatedly threatened military action to "reunite" the island with the mainland. Beijing has previously attacked Hsiao personally as an "independence diehard" and condemned her Democratic Progressive Party as separatist. The rarity of such high-level visits reflects the diplomatic minefield that host countries navigate—most fear economic or political retaliation from China if they receive senior Taiwanese officials.
Italy, like nearly all nations, does not maintain formal diplomatic relations with Taiwan. The Vatican is among Taiwan's only twelve official allies globally. Yet Italy and Taiwan maintain de facto embassies in each other's capitals, a practical arrangement that stops short of formal recognition. Italy's Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani will not meet with the visiting Taiwanese officials, a signal of the careful distance Rome is maintaining even as it hosts them.
The EU finds itself threading an increasingly difficult needle. On one hand, it has democratic commitments and growing strategic interest in Taiwan's security, especially after Taiwan sought closer European ties in 2022 following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. On the other hand, China's support for Russia in that same conflict has already strained EU-China relations considerably. The bloc must balance its stated values against the economic and geopolitical weight of Beijing. How the EU responds to China's complaints, and what statements emerge after the conference concludes Saturday, will signal how willing Europe is to absorb Chinese pressure when hosting democratic voices from contested territories.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
No one can decide who is hosted in Ventotene and who is not, and China should not interfere— European Parliament Vice President Pina Picierno
China firmly opposes official interactions of any form with Taiwan by nations who have ties with China— Beijing's Foreign Ministry
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei Deutsche Welle ↗
Politics & Governance