China Eastern crash: cockpit recorder sent for analysis as first human remains are found at mountain site

All 132 people onboard died, including a young family travelling for medical treatment for their 18-month-old daughter; relatives are grieving.
Life-saving flights become fatal flights.
Wang Baiyang on his sister's family, who were flying to Guangzhou for their toddler's medical care.
Mark

Let's start with what's actually in hand. What do investigators have?

Mimi

One recorder, the cockpit voice recorder. It's badly damaged, but an official said its storage units are relatively complete, so it's been sent to Beijing for decoding.

Mark

And the other one?

Mimi

Not found yet. That's the flight data recorder, and the search continues on the mountainside.

Luke

Worth saying plainly: nobody knows why this plane fell. The piece notes it came down from above 6,000 metres during cruise, and that's all that's established about the cause.

Mark

There was talk about the pilots. How firmly is that addressed?

Mimi

The airline's Yunnan branch chairman, Sun Shiying, said the three pilots were healthy and performed well. That's the airline speaking, though.

Luke

Right. That's an airline official's statement, not an investigative finding. It answers speculation but doesn't close anything.

Mark

What about the human side?

Mimi

Wang Baiyang's sister, her husband and their 18-month-old daughter were flying for the child's medical treatment, their first flight, after an earlier one was cancelled.

Luke

Note that Wang is a pseudonym, and that account comes from China Youth Daily. It's moving, but it's one family's story relayed through state media.

Mark

And the US role?

Mimi

The NTSB was invited because Boeing is American, but travel isn't confirmed because of visa and quarantine rules.

Luke

So who joins the inquiry is still open.

  • A six-year-old Boeing 737-89P plunged from over 6,000 metres in cruise, and the cause remains unknown.
  • More than 300 rescuers are combing steep, weather-hit terrain in Teng County, where the impact scattered the aircraft widely.
  • The cockpit voice recorder has been recovered badly damaged and is being decoded at an institute in Beijing.
  • The flight data recorder is still missing, and its discovery is critical to explaining the descent.
  • US NTSB investigators want to join the inquiry, but visa and quarantine rules leave their travel unresolved.
  • Families are mourning lost relatives, and pilots have been publicly defended amid speculation about their role.

On a remote mountainside in Teng County, Guangxi, rescuers working through poor weather have begun to recover the remains of the 132 people who were aboard a China Eastern Boeing 737 that fell from cruising altitude on Monday afternoon. In the way such losses always arrive, the sudden end of ordinary journeys has left families reaching for the last messages they exchanged and for some account of why a machine that had passed its checks should have broken apart in the sky. The answer now rests with a damaged voice recorder in Beijing and a flight data box still hidden in the hills, and until those are read, the grief of the families must wait alongside the investigation.

More than 300 rescue workers were still searching a remote mountainside in Teng County, near Wuzhou in Guangxi, when officials announced that the first human remains had been found. Work had paused briefly that day because of poor weather. The China Eastern Boeing 737 had gone down on Monday afternoon after falling from more than 6,000 metres, breaking apart on impact, and all 132 people on board were killed.

One black box, the cockpit voice recorder, has been recovered, badly damaged but described by officials as relatively complete in its storage units. It has been sent to Beijing for decoding. The flight data recorder has not yet been found. Investigators hope the two together can explain how an aircraft that had passed its pre-departure checks came down in the middle of its flight. The plane was a six-year-old 737-800, a common jet and distinct from the 737 Max.

Families have begun to speak through state media. A man known as Wang Baiyang described his sister Gu Hanyu, her husband Guo Zengqiang and their 18-month-old daughter, who were travelling to Guangzhou for the child's medical treatment. It was their first flight together, and the earlier booking they had been given had been cancelled. Before boarding, Gu sent a video of her laughing daughter playing in the lounge. "Life-saving flights become fatal flights," Wang said. "It was their first and last flight."

As speculation turned toward the pilots, the airline's Yunnan branch chairman said the three pilots had been in good health and performed well. Because the aircraft was American-built, the US National Transportation Safety Board has been invited to join, though its travel depends on unresolved visa and quarantine arrangements. What the recorder reveals, and whether the missing box is found, will determine what investigators can say next.

More than 300 rescue workers were still combing a remote mountainside in Teng County, near Wuzhou in Guangxi province, on Wednesday evening when officials announced that the first human remains had been found. Work at the site had been briefly suspended earlier that day because of poor weather. The recovery follows the crash of a China Eastern Airlines Boeing 737 on Monday afternoon, which killed all 132 people on board.

The aircraft went down after plunging from more than 6,000 metres (20,000ft). The cause is not known, and investigators have said that establishing it may prove difficult. The plane struck the mountain with such force that much of it disintegrated on impact.

One of the two black boxes, the cockpit voice recorder, has been recovered. It is badly damaged, but Zhu Tao, an official at the Civil Aviation Administration of China, said its storage units are damaged yet "relatively complete". They have been sent to an institute in Beijing to be decoded. The second black box, which records flight data, has not yet been found, and the search for it continues. Investigators hope the two recorders can explain why a plane that had passed safety checks before departure came down during the cruising phase of its flight.

According to flight data trackers, the aircraft was a six-year-old Boeing 737-89P. The 737-800 family is among the most common passenger jets in the world, and is distinct from the 737 Max, which was grounded worldwide after fatal crashes in 2018 and 2019.

Chinese state media have begun to publish details about those on board. In China Youth Daily, a man using the pseudonym Wang Baiyang said his 26-year-old sister, Gu Hanyu, her husband Guo Zengqiang and their 18-month-old daughter were among the passengers. It was the first flight of their lives. They were travelling to Guangzhou so the child could receive medical treatment, and had originally been booked on an earlier flight that was cancelled. Gu, who was born deaf, met Guo on a blind date, and the couple married in February 2020 at a simple ceremony. Before boarding, she sent the family a video of her daughter jumping around the lounge, playing with her mask and giggling.

"For the past two days, I felt like I had a dream," Wang said, adding that he kept thinking his sister would call the next morning. His grandfather had died just before the news of the crash arrived. "Life-saving flights become fatal flights," he said. "It was their first and last flight."

A retiree surnamed Zhang, from Shenzhen, visited the site and told Reuters that his nephew had been on board. With tears in his eyes, he said he hoped the country would investigate thoroughly and determine whether the cause was the manufacturer's fault or a maintenance problem.

Amid speculation that the pilots might have been responsible, Sun Shiying, chairman of the airline's Yunnan branch, told reporters on Wednesday that the three pilots on board were in good health, "had good performance" and had maintained harmonious relationships with their families.

This is the worst air disaster in China in more than a decade. The inquiry is led by Chinese authorities, but because the aircraft was built in the United States, investigators from the US National Transportation Safety Board have been invited to take part. Whether they can travel is unsettled, held up by visa and quarantine requirements. The NTSB said it is working with the State Department to resolve those issues with the Chinese government before any travel is decided. What the Beijing analysis of the cockpit recorder yields, and whether the flight data recorder is found, will shape what investigators can say next.

The recorder's storage units were damaged but relatively complete.
— Zhu Tao, Civil Aviation Administration of China
It was their first and last flight.
— Wang Baiyang (pseudonym), brother of passenger Gu Hanyu
Quer a matéria completa? Leia o original em The Guardian ↗
Fale Conosco FAQ