A physician who spent years tethered to the fate of a health secretary he once helped confirm has now turned against him, calling his tenure a chain of failures that the country will have to reckon with. Sen. Bill Cassidy, a Louisiana Republican leaving Washington after losing his bid for reelection, has concluded that promises made in exchange for his decisive vote never became a working partnership. His indictment gathers the familiar costs of modern public health: rising bills, returning childhood diseases, and a food system still unchanged. It arrives at a moment when the balance of power
Cassidy Says Kennedy's HHS Tenure Is a 'Series of Failures,' Citing Measles and Health Costs
"There is no logic. This is about covering a series of failures."
Why does this criticism land differently coming from Cassidy?
He's a physician, he chairs the health committee, and his vote helped confirm Kennedy. He says he backed him after receiving serious commitments, so this is a man describing a deal he thinks was broken.
Worth separating that, though. The promise of a collaborative relationship is Cassidy's account. The reporting says it has not appeared to pan out, but we don't have the administration's version of what was promised.
And Kennedy's remark about leverage?
He said on Nov. 9 that the Senate no longer has leverage over him and that nothing will get in the way now. Cassidy read that as cover for failure.
That reading is Cassidy's interpretation of Kennedy's motive. Kennedy's words are on the record; the motive isn't.
He also cited infants dying from measles. Is that a confirmed count?
He said infants are dying and that the country lost elimination status. No figures were given in this interview.
Right, so we can't say how many. The claims about higher costs and little progress on processed foods are also his characterization, with no data offered here.
What should we watch?
This week's committee vote on Heidi Overton for FDA commissioner. Cassidy says he still has questions and can't predict the outcome.
And he's a lame duck. How much leverage he has left is unknown.
Le Pouls
- A departing Senate chairman calls the nation's health secretary's record a 'series of failures,' and the rift he once bridged is now open for everyone to see.
- Measles has returned with fatal force, infants have died, and the country has lost its elimination status, turning a policy dispute into a question of life and death.
- Secretary Kennedy's claim that a Republican Senate had been holding back his agenda, and that its coming loss of the majority frees him, has sharpened the feud into an open confrontation.
- Cassidy urges the president to change course and send a clear public message on vaccination, while Democrats weigh impeachment and Cassidy waves that path away.
- All eyes now turn to the HELP Committee's vote on FDA nominee Heidi Overton, a test of how much influence the outgoing chairman still wields, and its outcome remains uncertain.
A physician who spent years tethered to the fate of a health secretary he once helped confirm has now turned against him, calling his tenure a chain of failures that the country will have to reckon with. Sen. Bill Cassidy, a Louisiana Republican leaving Washington after losing his bid for reelection, has concluded that promises made in exchange for his decisive vote never became a working partnership. His indictment gathers the familiar costs of modern public health: rising bills, returning childhood diseases, and a food system still unchanged. It arrives at a moment when the balance of power in Washington is shifting, and when the question of who should steward American health is being asked out loud.
On a Sunday interview, Sen. Bill Cassidy of Louisiana delivered a sharp verdict on Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s leadership of the Department of Health and Human Services. Calling it a "series of failures," he said the secretary should be replaced, citing higher health care costs, a surge in measles deaths, the loss of the country's measles elimination status, and little progress on processed foods. Cassidy, a physician and Republican who is leaving the Senate after losing his reelection bid, has been in a bitter dispute with Kennedy for months.
The rift runs deep because Cassidy's support was decisive in Kennedy's confirmation. He backed the nomination after receiving what he called "serious commitments" from the administration, including a promise of a collaborative working relationship that, he says, never materialized. The latest clash followed remarks by Kennedy suggesting Senate Republicans had held back his Make America Healthy Again agenda, and that Democratic control of the Senate next year would free him. Cassidy dismissed that reasoning as cover for failure.
Cassidy returned repeatedly to the concerns of the MAHA mothers who had written to him during the confirmation fight. Processed foods were their priority, he said, and progress has been minimal. Now infants are dying from measles, and any of those mothers who hoped for better has every right to be disappointed. He warned that unvaccinated adults can carry death to young children, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems, and urged the president to say so publicly, again and again.
As for impeachment, which some Democrats have floated, Cassidy was dismissive, saying one could impeach "over a ham sandwich." He suggested the president's legacy was at stake and that a change of course could still serve him.
The moment is also a test of influence. Cassidy chairs the HELP Committee, which is set to vote this week on FDA commissioner nominee Heidi Overton. He said he does not yet know whether she will advance, as he continues to weigh questions after conversations with Overton, committee Republicans and his advisers.
On Sunday, Sen. Bill Cassidy of Louisiana sat for an interview and delivered a blunt verdict on the man running the Department of Health and Human Services. Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s time as secretary, Cassidy said, has been a "series of failures." Were he president, he added, he would choose someone else, because there needs to be accountability for higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the loss of the country's measles elimination status, and a lack of progress on processed foods.
Cassidy is a medical doctor and a Republican, and he is leaving the Senate early next year after losing his reelection bid. He has been in a bitter dispute with Kennedy for months over vaccine policy and other positions. The history matters here: Kennedy's confirmation last year hinged on Cassidy's support. Cassidy ultimately backed the nomination after, in his words, receiving "serious commitments" from the administration. He has said he was promised a "collaborative working relationship," and that relationship does not appear to have materialized.
The latest exchange was set off by remarks Kennedy made on Nov. 9. He suggested Republicans had been holding back his Make America Healthy Again agenda. With Senate Republicans expected to lose the majority in the new year, he said, the Senate would no longer have leverage over him. "That's a big deal," he said, adding that he did not think anything would get in the movement's way now. He also pointed to Stephen Miller as a "friend of our movement."
Asked about this, Cassidy said Kennedy was "obviously trying to provide cover for failure." He rejected the idea that having Democrats in charge of the Senate would make Kennedy's work easier, saying there was no logic in it and that it was about covering a series of failures.
Cassidy pressed the point on the issue that, he said, drew many of Kennedy's supporters to him. Processed foods, he said, were what "MAHA moms" wanted addressed, and progress has been minimal. Hundreds of those mothers contacted him during the debate over whether to support Kennedy's nomination. Now, he said, the country has lost measles elimination status and infants are dying from measles. Any MAHA mom hoping for something better, he said, has every right to be disappointed.
On the possibility of impeachment, which some Democrats have floated, Cassidy was dry. One can impeach "over a ham sandwich," he said, so Democrats will have to decide for themselves. He steered attention instead toward "the president's decision." In his view, higher costs, the lost elimination status and the stalled work on ultra-processed foods will taint the president's legacy. If the president wants something positive, Cassidy said, he should change course. He noted that voters signaled at the midterms that they dislike the status quo, particularly in health care.
Cassidy also addressed the measles outbreak directly, warning that an unvaccinated adult "could be the person that brings death to another," with implications for young children, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems. He urged the president to say publicly that individuals may do as they wish, but that they can bring measles or another disease into the health space of a child too young to be vaccinated. That message, he said, should be "pounded, pounded, pounded."
The interview comes as the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, which Cassidy chairs, prepares to vote this week on Heidi Overton's nomination for FDA commissioner. Asked whether it would advance, Cassidy said he did not know. He had been working the phones all week, speaking with Overton and others, and still had questions. He said he had also talked with four or five Republican members of the committee and with his advisers, and could not yet give an answer. That vote is the next concrete test of how much influence the departing chairman still holds.
Citations marquantes
If I were president, I would choose someone else because there needs to be accountability.— Sen. Bill Cassidy
The Senate no longer has any leverage over me. And that's a big deal.— Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Nov. 9