Canada, China resume military talks after years of diplomatic strain

The resumption of talks marks a shift after years of tension
Canadian and Chinese military officials held their fifth defence coordination dialogue last week, signaling a thaw in relations.
Mark

Why does it matter that these two countries are talking about military issues again?

Mimi

Because for years they weren't. The relationship had frozen over, and when you lose military-to-military communication, you lose a safety valve. These talks are a way to reduce misunderstanding when tensions flare.

Luke

But the source doesn't actually say what they discussed or what they agreed to. We know they met. We don't know what came out of it.

Mark

What caused the freeze in the first place?

Mimi

Broader diplomatic strain, but specifically China pointed to Canada sending navy ships through the Taiwan Strait as a provocation. That's a real flashpoint.

Luke

Right, and that issue hasn't been resolved. So we're talking again, but the underlying disagreement is still there.

Mark

Is the Carney government betting that dialogue will smooth things over?

Mimi

It seems to be. The government says these talks protect Canadian interests. The idea is that open channels reduce the risk of miscalculation.

Luke

That's the government's framing. The Conservatives say it's a mistake. We should note that this is contested—there's no consensus here.

Mark

What do we actually know happened in the meeting?

Mimi

We know it happened. We know both sides called it candid and in-depth. That's about it.

Luke

Exactly. The government won't say what was discussed. So we're reporting on the fact of the meeting, not its substance. That's an important distinction.

  • Canada and China held their fifth defence coordination dialogue last week, the most concrete sign yet that military-to-military contact is being deliberately revived after years of diplomatic stagnation.
  • China's defence ministry moved first to announce the talks, describing them as candid and substantive — while Ottawa offered only a muted acknowledgment and no details, deepening concerns about transparency.
  • The path to resumed talks was not smooth: Beijing had previously cited Canadian navy transits through the Taiwan Strait as a provocation that blocked progress, making this resumption a carefully negotiated step.
  • Conservative opposition is pushing back hard, arguing that expanding defence ties with China contradicts Canadian security values and risks entangling Ottawa in Indo-Pacific tensions it cannot control.
  • The government's strategy of limited public disclosure is itself becoming a flashpoint, with critics warning that normalization without scrutiny may carry costs that Canadians cannot yet see.

Across the quiet machinery of diplomacy, Canada and China have resumed a conversation long interrupted — their fifth formal defence dialogue, held last week, signals that Ottawa under Prime Minister Carney is deliberately rebuilding military channels with Beijing after years of frost. The meeting, confirmed first by China's defence ministry and acknowledged only cautiously by Canada, reflects the enduring tension between engagement and caution that defines relations between middle powers and rising ones. What is said in these rooms shapes the silences that follow — and for now, both the words and the silences remain carefully guarded.

Ottawa confirmed this week that Canadian and Chinese military officials met last week for their fifth formal defence coordination dialogue — a resumption of talks that had largely stalled during years of diplomatic tension. China's defence ministry announced the meeting first, calling it a candid and in-depth exchange. Canada's defence department acknowledged the report days later but declined to share details, citing its practice of not publicizing working-level meetings.

The thaw has not come easily. Military-to-military contact had cooled significantly, and when Canadian officials began signaling in early 2024 that they wanted more direct channels with Beijing, resistance followed quickly. China's ambassador pointed to Canadian navy transits through the Taiwan Strait as a barrier — a gesture Beijing read as a challenge to its sovereignty claims over the island.

The Carney government has framed these talks as part of a broader strategy to deepen Canada's relationship with China across multiple domains. But that framing has drawn sharp criticism from Conservative opposition members, who argue that military cooperation with Beijing runs counter to Canadian security interests, particularly given rising tensions across the Indo-Pacific.

Ottawa maintains that dialogue protects Canadian interests — yet it has released nothing about what was discussed, what was agreed, or what comes next. That opacity is fueling concern among critics who believe the government is moving toward normalization faster than public accountability allows. For now, the fact that the two sides are talking again is being treated as progress in itself, even as the destination of that conversation remains unannounced.

Ottawa confirmed this week that Canadian and Chinese military officials sat down for talks last week—their fifth formal defence coordination dialogue since diplomatic relations began thawing under the Carney government's effort to rebuild ties with Beijing. The Chinese defence ministry announced the meeting first, describing it as "a candid and in-depth exchange" on military matters. Canada's defence department acknowledged the report days later, though it declined to offer details, saying the government does not typically publicize working-level meetings between officials.

The resumption of these talks marks a significant shift after years of tension between the two countries. The relationship had cooled considerably, and military-to-military contact had largely stalled. Canadian military officials had begun signaling in early 2024 that they wanted to open more direct channels of communication with their Chinese counterparts, a move that faced immediate resistance. China's ambassador at the time pointed to Canada's decision to send navy ships through the Taiwan Strait as a barrier to progress—a gesture Beijing viewed as provocative and a challenge to its sovereignty claims over the island.

The timing of last week's dialogue reflects the Carney government's broader strategy to deepen Canada's relationship with China across multiple domains. The defence talks are part of that larger diplomatic push, though they have already drawn sharp criticism from Conservative opposition members, who argue that military cooperation with China runs counter to Canadian security interests and values. The Conservatives have made clear they view any expansion of defence ties with Beijing as a mistake, particularly given ongoing geopolitical tensions in the Indo-Pacific region.

Ottawa's official position is that the talks serve to protect Canadian interests through dialogue, even as the government maintains a policy of limited public disclosure about such meetings. The defence department has not released details about what was discussed, what agreements might have been reached, or what the next steps might be. This opacity has only fueled concern among critics who worry that the government is moving too quickly to normalize relations without sufficient public scrutiny.

The fifth dialogue represents a continuation of efforts that began years earlier but were interrupted by the diplomatic freeze. Whether these talks will lead to substantive military cooperation—joint exercises, information sharing, or other forms of coordination—remains unclear. The government has offered no timeline for future meetings or any indication of what concrete outcomes it hopes to achieve. For now, the fact that the two countries are talking again is itself being treated as progress, even as questions linger about where the relationship is headed.

China's defence ministry described the exchange as candid and in-depth on military issues
— China's defence ministry
Ottawa says it does not publicize working-level meetings but that talks are about protecting Canadian interests
— Canadian defence department
Envie de l'histoire complète ? Lire l'original sur CP24 Toronto ↗
Nous contacter FAQ