In a moment when more than a million young adults in Britain sit outside work, study and training, the prime minister has placed his government's answer within a larger story about how a society raises its young. Andy Burnham argues that the state must step in early, long before a young person becomes dependent on benefits, and that money should flow first into opportunity while the savings arrive only after years of patience. The debate is sharpened by a rival vision from the Conservatives and Reform, who would cut faster and deeper, and by a Labour left still bruised from its last welfare re
Burnham Pledges Early Intervention and 'Benefits Backstop' to Tackle Youth Jobs Crisis
Benefits must become the backstop, not the starting point.
Burnham says benefits should be the backstop, not the starting point. What is he actually proposing?
Two things together. Early help, from childhood and school vocational training onward, and a reworked benefit system for under-25s built around a new youth allowance at the standard universal credit rate.
Who loses out?
Some young people would lose personal independence payments and the health element of universal credit. McFadden says those with lifelong disabilities would get more, through an extra-costs benefit.
That's his account of a report I haven't seen in full. The reporting confirms the direction, not how many people end up better or worse off.
And the Conservative plan?
It would cut 70% of child disability claims tied to ADHD and milder conditions. Whately accepted that could mean around half a million children losing payments, while promising £1bn for child mental health.
Note who calls it what. Labour's phrase, a charter for human misery, is political language. The half-million figure, though, comes from Whately's own acknowledgement.
What about the six-month job guarantee?
The Liberal Democrats say it's worth very little without a job afterward.
Right, and nothing here says how many of those placements lead to permanent work. Milburn himself says the savings take ten years, which is a promise, not a result.
El Pulso
- A million 18 to 24-year-olds are outside work, education and training, and the number has not been this high in over a decade.
- Milburn's review would replace some disability payments for under-25s with a youth allowance at the standard universal credit rate, drawing fierce pushback from within Labour's own ranks.
- Ministers are racing to offer a fully funded six-month job after a year on universal credit, though critics say the promise means little without a job at the end.
- The Conservatives and Reform want faster welfare cuts, and Labour warns that proposed cuts to child disability claims would be a charter for human misery.
- Ten years of investment must come before the benefits bill falls, and the government must hold its left wing together while it waits.
In a moment when more than a million young adults in Britain sit outside work, study and training, the prime minister has placed his government's answer within a larger story about how a society raises its young. Andy Burnham argues that the state must step in early, long before a young person becomes dependent on benefits, and that money should flow first into opportunity while the savings arrive only after years of patience. The debate is sharpened by a rival vision from the Conservatives and Reform, who would cut faster and deeper, and by a Labour left still bruised from its last welfare rebellion. What unfolds will test whether a generation can be offered a real path in before it is asked to accept the discipline that comes with one.
Andy Burnham has used the pages of the Guardian to set out how his government will respond to Alan Milburn's review of youth unemployment. He calls the response not a traditional reform but a societal and generational one, a root-and-branch rethink of how childhood is supported. The figures that frame it are hard to ignore: the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training has passed a million for the first time in more than a decade.
Milburn's proposals are sweeping. Some young people would lose personal independence payments and the health element of universal credit, replaced by a youth allowance at the standard rate. Alongside this, a taxpayer-funded job guarantee would reach under-25s who have spent a year on universal credit. Burnham wants support to come with responsibilities, and benefits to be the backstop rather than the starting point. Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, admits there will be an element of compulsion and that some will receive less, while insisting that the long-term disabled would in fact gain.
Across the political divide, the Conservatives would cut child disability claims tied to ADHD and milder conditions, a move that could leave around half a million children without payments. Labour says this would push families into poverty and homelessness. Milburn himself is candid that savings will take a decade, and that there is no free lunch. Whether the Labour left will accept the compulsion, and whether patience survives the pull toward faster cuts, remains the open question.
Andy Burnham used a piece in the Guardian to set out how his government will answer Alan Milburn's long-awaited review of youth unemployment, due to be published. The prime minister said the response would not be "a traditional" reform but a "societal and generational" one, and he promised what he called a root-and-branch rethink of how childhood is supported in the modern world.
The numbers behind it are stark. The count of Neets, meaning 18 to 24-year-olds not in employment, education or training, passed a million this year for the first time in more than a decade. Burnham pledged to bring it down. He said ministers would step in at every stage where young people fall behind, long before they are out of work and reliant on the state, including by offering more vocational training in schools.
Milburn's report, according to the Guardian, promises almost half a million job and education opportunities within a decade. It also advises sweeping changes to benefits for under-25s. Some young people would lose personal independence payments and the right to claim the health element of universal credit. In their place would come a new youth allowance paid at the standard universal credit rate. Separately, the government has announced that a taxpayer-funded work scheme will be extended to under-25s who have claimed benefits for a year. Eligible 18- to 24-year-olds would be guaranteed a fully funded six-month job matched to their skills after 12 months on universal credit. The Liberal Democrats said that offer is worth "very little" without a job at the end of it.
Burnham is plainly wary of resistance from the left of his own party, whose MPs rebelled last summer to block Keir Starmer's welfare changes. He said the government would invest in young people and give them a proper chance, but that support "will have to come with responsibilities". Benefits, he wrote, must become "the backstop, not the starting point".
Milburn, speaking on the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg, said the government must be candid: it would take ten years for the benefits bill to fall, and investment would have to come first. To critics who want immediate cuts, he said there is "no such thing as a free lunch". Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden acknowledged the review would carry an element of compulsion for Neets and that some people would receive less than they do now. He pointed to the Netherlands, where a youth desk would "literally knock on your door" with offers of training or work. He denied that Milburn proposes banning young people from health-related benefits, saying the review addresses those with long-term disabilities who can never work. They would get more than now, he said, with a benefit for extra costs and a local fund for short-term needs. He argued change was needed because the number of young people claiming Pip has doubled since the start of the decade, and those on the health element of universal credit are up 80%.
Burnham turned his fire on the Conservatives and Reform, who want deep, immediate welfare cuts. Kemi Badenoch has vowed to cut the bill by £36.1bn by 2030 if her party wins the next election. Under the Conservative plans, 70% of child disability-related claims linked to ADHD and "milder" behavioural disorders and learning disabilities would be cut. Labour called this "a charter for human misery". Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately acknowledged it could mean around half a million children losing disability-related payments, but said the aim was to help those children, and that child mental health services would receive £1bn. Burnham said such cuts would drive children into poverty, worsen family homelessness and pile pressure on councils and the NHS.
A Children's Commissioner survey with more than a million responses found over half of young people worried about getting a good job. Dame Rachel de Souza said they are ambitious and want to work, but that too many are let down by careers advice. Milburn said he had not met one young person who wanted to be a Neet, and that the system had failed them. The test ahead is whether Labour's left accepts the compulsion in the package, and whether a ten-year payoff survives pressure for faster cuts.
Citas Notables
Benefits must become the backstop, not the starting point.— Andy Burnham, prime minister
There's no such thing as a free lunch.— Alan Milburn, BBC Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg