Bird Flu Uncertainty Weighs on NZ Poultry Farmers as Biosecurity Costs Mount

Farmers and staff report significant mental strain and financial pressure from ongoing bird flu uncertainty, with no human casualties reported.
It's quite hard to stop a wild bird flying over a free range paddock.
Jim Brown of Kaimai Eggs on the limits of biosecurity on a mostly free-range farm.
Mark

Nothing has actually hit a poultry farm. Why is this a story?

Mimi

Because the preparation is already costing people. Kaimai Eggs has built separate zones for people and birds and finished upgrades, and Jim Brown says the waiting wears on him and his staff.

Luke

Worth noting that the mental toll is Brown's own account. The article doesn't cite any survey or wider measure of farmer wellbeing.

Mark

Fair. What about the regulations?

Mimi

They were published last month and require commercial operators to have an H5N1 biosecurity programme. The industry bodies will update their guidelines to help members meet them.

Mark

And the cost concern?

Mimi

Brown splits it in two: upgrading facilities, and the ongoing paperwork. He worries most about very small producers.

Luke

Again, that's his view. The piece gives no figures for what compliance costs, so how hard small farms are hit is unquantified.

Mark

What about the free-range problem he describes?

Mimi

He says it's hard to stop a wild bird flying over a paddock. Kaimai is 80% free-range, though it can move birds indoors if the risk rises.

Luke

What's confirmed is three wild bird detections, none since August, and no poultry cases. How the risk will evolve through the migratory season is unknown.

  • Three wild bird detections of H5N1 have put Bay of Plenty egg farmers on edge, even though no poultry has been infected so far.
  • Kaimai Eggs has split its site into separate biosecurity zones and can confine its birds indoors when migratory risk peaks from September to March.
  • Free-range hens on a 50-hectare property are hard to shield, since a single wild bird flying over a paddock could change everything.
  • New 2026 regulations require every commercial poultry operator to run an H5N1 biosecurity programme, and small producers face the steepest costs.
  • Industry bodies are rewriting guidelines to help members comply, while farmers watch for new wild bird detections and the strain it puts on their finances and nerves.

In the Bay of Plenty, a family egg farm is living through a waiting that many in New Zealand's poultry sector now share: a dangerous bird virus has been found in wild birds but has not yet touched a single commercial flock. Jim Brown and his wife Karlene, whose business grew out of a family farm and now feeds thousands of households, have answered that uncertainty with fences, cleaning routines and a readiness to keep their hens indoors. The new national rules that followed ask the same of every commercial operator, and the burden of doing so falls hardest on those with the least room to absorb it. For now the country stands in a quiet interval, its precautions tightening as the migratory season runs on.

Jim Brown has spent three to four years preparing his egg farm for a disease that has not yet reached a single commercial flock in New Zealand. He and his wife Karlene run Kaimai Eggs in the Bay of Plenty, and he says the waiting wears on farmers and their staff alike. The country's first case, an H7N6 outbreak at an Otago farm in December 2024, was contained quickly. H5N1, the strain now circulating worldwide, was found in a Wellington wild bird in July 2026, and three wild detections have been recorded since, none in poultry.

Those findings pushed Kaimai Eggs to tighten its precautions, especially during the Arctic migration season from September to March. The farm now keeps separate zones for people and birds, cleans between indoor and outdoor areas, and can bring birds inside when the risk rises. Eighty percent of its chickens roam free, and that is where the difficulty lies. "It's quite hard to stop a wild bird flying over a free range paddock," Brown said.

The business began in 2011 when his in-laws left dairy farming, and it has grown to employ about 30 people and supply cafes, supermarkets and markets across several regions. Brown says an outbreak would mean far more than lost birds: debt, restocking, and an uncertain path back to production. New regulations passed last month now require every commercial operator to hold an H5N1 biosecurity programme. Brown supports the rules but worries about smaller producers, for whom the upgrades and paperwork are a heavy load. The industry is preparing new guidance, and the next signals to watch are any fresh wild bird detections and how the smallest farms manage.

Jim Brown has spent the last three to four years getting his egg farm ready for a disease that, so far, has not reached a single commercial flock in New Zealand. That has not made the waiting any easier. Brown runs Kaimai Eggs in the Bay of Plenty with his wife, Karlene, and he says the uncertainty is taking a heavy mental toll on farmers and their staff.

The cause is highly pathogenic avian influenza. New Zealand's first confirmed case was the H7N6 strain at an Otago egg farm in December 2024, and it was quickly contained. The strain now circulating around the world, H5N1, was first found here in a wild bird in Wellington in July 2026. Three wild bird detections have been recorded in total. No cases have been reported in poultry.

Those three detections were enough to push Kaimai Eggs to tighten its precautions, particularly during the peak Arctic migratory bird season, which runs from September to March. The farm has set up separate biosecurity zones for people and for birds, with cleaning procedures between indoor and outdoor areas and the poultry sheds. It can also keep birds indoors if the risk climbs too high. Brown says the detections reinforced the seriousness of the threat among staff and led the business to finish its planned biosecurity improvements.

The farm covers 50 hectares, and 80% of its chickens are free-range, with the rest barn-raised. That is where the difficulty lies. "We are doing everything we can to look after the birds and we have to put them first," Brown said, "but it's quite hard to stop a wild bird flying over a free range paddock." Of the wait itself he said: "It's not a very healthy way to live, wondering when it could all be over, so we're following it really closely."

The business dates to 2011, when Otto and Vicky McGirr left dairy farming in the central North Island for the Bay of Plenty. Their daughter Karlene and her husband Jim returned from Europe when covid-19 hit in 2020, planning to help for a few weeks. They stayed and helped grow the operation. Kaimai Eggs now employs about 30 people, raises its own chickens from day-old chicks, and supplies cafes, supermarkets and farmers markets across Waikato, the Bay of Plenty and further north.

Brown says an outbreak would cost far more than the birds. Farmers would face lost income, continuing debt repayments, restocking costs and the loss of existing production. "What do you do with your customers, your chicken feed, no chickens, farm infrastructure and staff members, with no income and a long expensive route to re-population?" he asked. He also pointed to the wider stakes: according to the Egg Producers Federation of NZ, New Zealanders eat an average of 229 eggs per person each year, and he says any drop in supply could affect access to affordable protein.

Fiona MacMillian, executive director of both the Poultry Industry Association of New Zealand and the Egg Producers Federation, urged farmers to watch their flocks for signs of illness and to monitor wild birds for disease. She noted there have been no further H5 detections since August and no sign of the virus in any egg or poultry flock, but said good biosecurity remains the best defence.

Last month the government published the Biosecurity (Avian Biosecurity Control Programme Standards – H5N1) Regulations 2026. They require commercial poultry operators to have a biosecurity programme to protect their birds from H5N1. MacMillian said the two industry bodies will update their guidelines to help members comply.

Brown supports stronger measures, but says the costs fall in two places: physical upgrades to facilities, and the ongoing administrative work of compliance. "I just feel especially for some of the really small producers," he said. "It's a massive cost for them." What to watch next is whether any new wild bird detections follow, and how smaller farms cope with the new requirements.

I just feel especially for some of the really small producers. It's a massive cost for them.
— Jim Brown, Kaimai Eggs
Good biosecurity remains the best defence in preventing the spread of bird flu.
— Fiona MacMillian, PIANZ and Egg Producers Federation (paraphrased)
Contattaci Domande frequenti